Best MPG to hoonage ratio in the real world?
Best MPG to hoonage ratio in the real world?
Author
Discussion

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
As per the title, what cars would you say offer the best trade off between driver involvement and fuel economy?

I never actually measured it, but my Caterham always seemed to sip fuel quite parsimoniously at moderately enthusiastic road speeds (although it was a very different story on the track, as I once discovered, running out of fuel on the A1 coming back from Bedford Autodrome...)

The Elise and the mk3 MR2 also seem to get name checked a lot for fun and frugality, as does the Clio 182.

What else is there?


Bear Phils

891 posts

167 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Rotary engines. They are supposed to do 20 mpg more or less everywhere, however you drive them hehe

Edited by Bear Phils on Friday 16th August 12:20

speed_monkey

3,503 posts

220 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Chris71 said:
As per the title, what cars would you say offer the best trade off between driver involvement and fuel economy?

I never actually measured it, but my Caterham always seemed to sip fuel quite parsimoniously at moderately enthusiastic road speeds (although it was a very different story on the track, as I once discovered, running out of fuel on the A1 coming back from Bedford Autodrome...)

The Elise and the mk3 MR2 also seem to get name checked a lot for fun and frugality, as does the Clio 182.

What else is there?
Did you swallow a dictionary?? Had to google that one!

Good word though

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Chris71 said:
As per the title, what cars would you say offer the best trade off between driver involvement and fuel economy?

I never actually measured it, but my Caterham always seemed to sip fuel quite parsimoniously at moderately enthusiastic road speeds (although it was a very different story on the track, as I once discovered, running out of fuel on the A1 coming back from Bedford Autodrome...)

The Elise and the mk3 MR2 also seem to get name checked a lot for fun and frugality, as does the Clio 182.

What else is there?
I think Caterhams and the like are all in with a shot.

Although I have to say I'm fairly pleased with my smart Roadster. I might not thrash it, but I don't drive for economy either. On the daily I get 52-60mpg average. For the fun it offers I'm not sure there is much out there anywhere close to this mpg level.

Baldy881

1,559 posts

208 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I've always been hugely impressed with the return you get from a motorbike relevent to performance.

For example, three weeks back I did 1100 miles in a weekend up to and around Scotland on a revvy 636cc sports bike and it didn't feel like a slow 1100 miles by any stretch, yet when I totted fuel receipts up on return i'd put about £160 unleaded in for the miles done which I thought was great going. Not the cheapest fuel up that way either.

Admittedly on any bike that has plenty of oomph and 160mph capability you're unlikely to be giving it the full beans for any length of time but there was plenty of cracking open the throttle going on. And on a track day when you're more or less wapping it open at every possible opportunity you can forget decent MPG, period.


Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm getting 30mpg out of my E36 323, and I'm using full throttle in second and third for pretty much all my accelerating. I got the same out of my mk2 MR2 NA and thrashed that everywhere.

Weirdly the MX5 did 25mpg as standard and after I fitted a turbo. I suppose the difference was that it was thrashed everywhere when it was standard, but once the turbo went on I had to be a bit cautious to avoid loss of traction and speeding tickets.

I'm also getting 25mpg from my Elise, but it's almost exclusively used on b-roads, has a lumpy sport 160 spec engine and a close/low ratio gearbox. A 111S, standard K or a later Toyota engined Elise would be much better, according to friends who had them.

Bear Phils said:
Rotary engines. They do 20 mpg more or less everywhere, however you drive them hehe
My FC RX7 NA did 19mpg using everything I learnt on a "eco-drive" training course I did.

Thrashing it and getting flames out of the back got me 17mpg.

My old Silvia Turbo did 12mpg the one time I dared check. It wasn't even fast.

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Captain Muppet said:
I'm getting 30mpg out of my E36 323, and I'm using full throttle in second and third for pretty much all my accelerating. I got the same out of my mk2 MR2 NA and thrashed that everywhere.

Weirdly the MX5 did 25mpg as standard and after I fitted a turbo. I suppose the difference was that it was thrashed everywhere when it was standard, but once the turbo went on I had to be a bit cautious to avoid loss of traction and speeding tickets.
I always seemed to get better mpg from my old MX-5 than everyone else did. I didn't drive it particularly gently, but it was an RS-Ltd (mk1) with a lowered final drive and various other bits so maybe it was down to the car. Heard several people say forced induction didn't make any difference.

It's also interesting how much some cars vary. I've got a Rover 75 diesel auto estate (going away from the hoonage bit here, obviously...) and that can easily get down to 25 mpg in town, but it will return 40 mpg on a flowing B-road and a genuine 50 mpg if you coax it gently along the motorway. None of which goes far enough to offset my TVR which averaged about 16 mpg the last time I checked.

Off to the classifieds for a browse at Smart Roadsters. I remember being chased by one down a B-road in something that should, by rights, have been a much quicker point-to-point machine.

rsv gone!

11,288 posts

272 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Baldy881 said:
I've always been hugely impressed with the return you get from a motorbike relevent to performance.

For example, three weeks back I did 1100 miles in a weekend up to and around Scotland on a revvy 636cc sports bike and it didn't feel like a slow 1100 miles by any stretch, yet when I totted fuel receipts up on return i'd put about £160 unleaded in for the miles done which I thought was great going. Not the cheapest fuel up that way either.

Admittedly on any bike that has plenty of oomph and 160mph capability you're unlikely to be giving it the full beans for any length of time but there was plenty of cracking open the throttle going on. And on a track day when you're more or less wapping it open at every possible opportunity you can forget decent MPG, period.
This. 40-50mpg average on an R1 is pretty impressive, given the amazing performance available.

stug45

98 posts

166 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
42-45 mpg in my jazz, redlined every gear and driven like a rally car....but eco if someone in front.

If I use the torque (rather than redlining) I get 50+ mpg.

Trying eco can see 65+mpg.


Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
stug45 said:
42-45 mpg in my jazz, redlined every gear and driven like a rally car....but eco if someone in front.

If I use the torque (rather than redlining) I get 50+ mpg.

Trying eco can see 65+mpg.
A lot of small hatchbacks can be a bit like that. The base spec Saxos and 106s handled brilliantly and seeming would not go below 45 mpg whatever you did. Does make me wonder about sportier variants like the Ignis Sport.

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
stug45 said:
42-45 mpg in my jazz, redlined every gear and driven like a rally car....but eco if someone in front.

If I use the torque (rather than redlining) I get 50+ mpg.

Trying eco can see 65+mpg.
Erm. Hoonage. Jazz. Does not compute.

JDMDrifter

4,067 posts

196 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
I've got a 1.4 16v Ibiza, not a rocket ship by any means!

But if you spank the crap out of it the least i've had is around 35mpg, not too shabby and quite a fun steer smile

nbetts

1,455 posts

260 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
M135i
Bloody quick when you want...
Very frugal when you want...

Can powerslide when you want...

Really is a 'hard to beat combination'.

powerandtorque

201 posts

222 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Anything small and light with a modernish (ie fuel injected) engine wins here.

Probably the ultimate must be something like an entry level Caterham - weighs as much as a fag packet, small engine that sips fuel (eg 1.4/1.6 K-Series or the newer Sigma ones), and still you grin like a cheshire cat.

Struggling to think what would better that other than a bike.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Captain Muppet said:
I'm also getting 25mpg from my Elise, but it's almost exclusively used on b-roads, has a lumpy sport 160 spec engine and a close/low ratio gearbox. A 111S, standard K or a later Toyota engined Elise would be much better, according to friends who had them.
My brother used to get an easy 40mpg when commuting in his S1 with a ported head, performance exhaust and running an Emerald ECU.

HannsG

3,135 posts

165 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
35mpg locally in Saab Ttid. Drive it very very hard....

Chris71

Original Poster:

21,549 posts

273 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
I guess the Alpina D3 would have to be an interesting inclusion on those grounds...

Boydie88

3,283 posts

180 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
VX220, an Elise with a more powerful and more economic engine.

nbetts said:
M135i
Bloody quick when you want...
Very frugal when you want...

Can powerslide when you want...

Really is a 'hard to beat combination'.
55 miles in 56 mins = 60.9 mph?!

Edited by Boydie88 on Tuesday 20th August 11:48

chris182

4,240 posts

184 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
You're quite correct about the Clio 182. I drive mine like I stole it and it consistently manages just over 40mpg smile. I do maintain it to a particularly anal level, use Mobil 1 fully synthetic oil and only Tesco 99 fuel which may help but I am very impressed. I think having such enormous grip and confidence actually improves mpg as one can carry more speed through the corners and avoid braking as much as possible.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
Erm. Hoonage. Jazz. Does not compute.
A Jazz with some decent suspension becomes more and more appealing biggrin

45mpg with plenty of space, hmmmm