Insurance question - loss of resale value
Insurance question - loss of resale value
Author
Discussion

siwebster

Original Poster:

417 posts

224 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

A couple of weeks ago someone ran into the back of the wife's car (Qashqai). All is ok, nobody hurt, insurance are handling it, 3rd party is liable and the car is currently being repaired - £4300 + vat damage to rear quarter, suspension, etc.

This will now show on HPI as being damaged and repaired, which I'm sure will affect the resale value of the car - so here's where my questions start...

I think the 3rd party should be liable for this difference as there shouldn't be any reason to be out of pocket if the accident was the fault of someone else - is this right?

Our insurance company don't seem to be able to give a straight answer, so I was hoping for some PH expertise on this and also any tips on how to approach it.

Just to add - I'm not looking for compensation over and above, there's been no compensation claim for any non-existent whiplash or anything like that, I really don't agree with it. But I do think that when we come to sell the car we should be able to have the market value for it rather than the reduced value that it will be now. I am already anticipating a rise in insurance premiums due to the scam that is 'because you've been involved in a no-fault accident you're more likely to be involved in a fault accident'...

Thanks for any advice.



will_

6,035 posts

234 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Unless they are writing it off, how will it show up on HPI?

If they are writing it off, then you'll get the market value of the car.

SmoothCriminal

5,983 posts

230 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Don't know where you are getting this information from that if they repair it they will record it as it is completely wrong.


If they repair the car it won't show up on a hpi report

SteveSteveson

3,209 posts

194 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Ye. Doesn't a HPI check only show if it is written off and then repaired, in which case you will have had the payout for the car and purchased it back...

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
As said, it won't show on a HPI report unless it's a total loss. Cars are damaged and fixed through the insurance all the time.

TA14

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
siwebster said:
I think the 3rd party should be liable for this difference as there shouldn't be any reason to be out of pocket if the accident was the fault of someone else - is this right?
Yes, that's quite right they should be. But you won't get this money. It's not fair and you'll have to take it on the chin.

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TA14 said:
siwebster said:
I think the 3rd party should be liable for this difference as there shouldn't be any reason to be out of pocket if the accident was the fault of someone else - is this right?
Yes, that's quite right they should be. But you won't get this money. It's not fair and you'll have to take it on the chin.
Why would anyone be out of pocket?

TA14

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SMcP114 said:
Why would anyone be out of pocket?
because when you sell the car if anyone asks whether it has been in an accident you'll have to answer less; some people won't then be interested; selling to a smaller market you'll achieve a lower price; basic economics.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SMcP114 said:
TA14 said:
siwebster said:
I think the 3rd party should be liable for this difference as there shouldn't be any reason to be out of pocket if the accident was the fault of someone else - is this right?
Yes, that's quite right they should be. But you won't get this money. It's not fair and you'll have to take it on the chin.
Why would anyone be out of pocket?
Because normal car buying guides say things like "look for panel gaps and changes in paint finish, which may indicate that it's been in a crash" and "walk away".

Some potential buyers with a good eye may indeed walk away, but others may use the inevitable tell-tales of damage repair to haggle down the price.

IanV12

11,949 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
You could claim for diminution of value but that is only really relevant on a high end car, it will have minimal effect on a car such as this

This company will do a report if necessary and there is information on their website.

http://www.diminution.me.uk/

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
If it's fixed correctly, as it should be (especially with the insurer paying for the repair), there should be absolutely no difference in condition from how it was before the damage.

There is no excuse for poor repairs. The car will be worth the same as it was before the damage, which I suspect will be light considering the insurance decided to fix it at all.

TA14

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SMcP114 said:
If it's fixed correctly, as it should be (especially with the insurer paying for the repair), there should be absolutely no difference in condition from how it was before the damage.
that could be true. It may even be in better condition
SMcP114 said:
The car will be worth the same as it was before the damage,
You may feel that way but the market does not agree with you.

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
This 'market' you speak of only dictates the value of cars that are recorded on the vcar register.

Most of us are driving cars that have been damaged and are none the wiser.

siwebster

Original Poster:

417 posts

224 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SmoothCriminal said:
Don't know where you are getting this information from that if they repair it they will record it as it is completely wrong.


If they repair the car it won't show up on a hpi report
Thanks for all replies so far - only reason I said the above is it's what I was told this afternoon by our insurance company, but they couldn't advise anything about loss of resale value. It did seem a bit strange, I thought damage was only recorded if the car was written off as a total loss.

The guy at the insurance company could have misinformed me, but I want to make sure I'm as fully informed as possible.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
SMcP114 said:
This 'market' you speak of only dictates the value of cars that are recorded on the vcar register.

Most of us are driving cars that have been damaged and are none the wiser.
Yep, this is exactly true. Lots of accident repaired cars on the road with nothing on the hpi register

For £4300 I'd imagine OPs Qashqui will get a proper quality repair though

TA14

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
va1o said:
SMcP114 said:
This 'market' you speak of only dictates the value of cars that are recorded on the vcar register.
Yep, this is exactly true.
It might be true for you but not generally as I and others posted above.

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TA14 said:
It might be true for you but not generally as I and others posted above.
Apologies, but I'm unsure what point you are trying to make?

How, to the untrained eye, is a repaired car worth less than an unrepaired car?

TA14

14,332 posts

289 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TA14 said:
because when you sell the car if anyone asks whether it has been in an accident you'll have to answer yes; some people won't then be interested; selling to a smaller market you'll achieve a lower price; basic economics.

IanV12

11,949 posts

189 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
cars are designed to be repairable
if it has been done well, it will be better than new

SMcP114

2,916 posts

223 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
TA14 said:
TA14 said:
because when you sell the car if anyone asks whether it has been in an accident you'll have to answer yes; some people won't then be interested; selling to a smaller market you'll achieve a lower price; basic economics.
I envy your view on the used car market to be perfectly honest. I wish I could share it, but my experience from inside the industry, including damage repaired cars, leaves me with a slightly different opinion.