How to outsource code development
How to outsource code development
Author
Discussion

Golaboots

Original Poster:

369 posts

179 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Hello

I have a rather large project at work that may well have to rely on outsourcing some code development.
This is something that we've not previously had to do and I am left wondering how best to go about it.

I know this practive happens frequently with web design etc but the code in question here is for PLCs, small computers that run industrial facilities. There is a standard for this but it tend to have a diiferent flavour amongst the different hardware manufacturers.
A fairly detailed 'spec' can be sent but ultimately I'm sure there would be some tuning/fault finding when it comes to commissioning in the UK when hooked up to machines.

Any pointers greatly appreciated.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
Hire Brits, pay them in stage payments, and be absolutely clear about what you want, then don't change it.

I work for an Indian outsourcer, and I am quite certain it is significantly more complex to ship requirements out and get dodgy code back.

eps

7,169 posts

300 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
What language (programming) are we talking about?

Agreed on offshore stuff - it needs someone dedicated almost solely to manage it.

Crafty_

14,234 posts

231 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
What the others guys have said. Do not under estimate the communication barrier when explaining/documenting what you want. They will say they understand even if they don't, pot luck if you get back something that is close to what you wanted.

Write down exactly what you want - use case, workflows, design, mock up screenshots, test plans.. everything.

As someone said, you'll need someone to manage the relationship, possibly full time.

I would look at hiring a contractor/freelancer here. You may not end up with better code, but you will find the communication easier and are more likely to get a result. You could even look at a company who will do the work for you - if they choose to use outsourcers thats their problem!

I'm working on a system with three other parts of our business at the moment. We have more people organising the work and dealing with the relationships than we do writing code/testing etc.

Its working and there are other benefits to the set up (which is one reason why we do it), but for a small company/start up it can be a nightmare.

AndyBrew

2,774 posts

250 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
outsource to India, good luck!

mattdaniels

7,362 posts

313 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I've dealt with outsourcing to India, China and Russia in my career.

Don't. Just don't. In the long run, it's a false economy.

Smiler.

11,752 posts

261 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Who's PLC's are you using?

Smiler.

11,752 posts

261 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
How the funk did I just post again?

Pistonheads old and busted mobile software.

Edited by Smiler. on Sunday 18th August 22:03

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
I am an IT director and have used many outsouce partners from across the globe

For small to meduim projects (less than a couple hundred man days) I use a UK based company that has resource in Eatern Europe.

Costs are on par with UK resource but quality is signifantly higher (and therefore the overall project cost ends up lower)

Having a UK head office and management team means communication and escalation is not an issue.

Drop me a PM if you want details



beko1987

1,723 posts

165 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
The project I'm involved with at the moment started off being coded in India (I'm a tester, so not up on the jargon etc)
However, due to the vague instructions from the business,the development company doing a hash job coding, the business requirements then changing etc it was canned after a year andbought in-house.

Now, it's been almost completely re-written in-house using hired java guys, and 4 years and several million quid later it's just about to enter Parralel Run, despite it needing re-UATing as it's a different system now to what it was.

Anyway, check the code and resulting software carfully, we did and luckily got most of the money back, but not after some hefty court battles. Was based over in Bangalore I think. Every now and again one of the java guys comes across some of the recycled code and swears slightly

dcb

6,070 posts

296 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
mattdaniels said:
I've dealt with outsourcing to India, China and Russia in my career.

Don't. Just don't. In the long run, it's a false economy.
I can agree with you about India and China.

On one project I worked on, we had to use the Unix special /usr/bin/rm compiler
on the delivered source code from India, it was that good ;->

For all the other projects I worked on where coding or design was outsourced
to I or C, it was merely the case that significant rework was required back in
the UK before delivery to Alpha test could be attempted.

Only worked on one project with the Russians: they seemed pretty competent.



eps

7,169 posts

300 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
We had some code from India....

It was Client Server pairings..

When we initially ran the code we couldn't believe the speed of it, it was extremely rapid, much faster than anything we'd achieved. We then looked at the code and realised that none of the Client code was actually calling any of the Servers, instead all the information was being set within the Clients... f*ck!! In the end they requested 8 of the Indian developers to come over to the UK to fix all the problems..

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
the IT company my sister works for out sources a lot of work out to poland

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
When you do find someone to do it ... get someone who knows what they are talking about to draft the contract. whistle

The ultimate reasons for dissatisfaction are badly drafted specs and badly drafted contracts. Make it very clear what you want, and what happens if you don't get it. Beware wilful misinterpretation.

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
My experience of outsourcing would suggest that unless you're very precise and exacting it is a false economy. We found that by the time we'd written designs and specifications to enough detail for the offshore coders to develop, we may as well have written the code ourselves. In the end the level of rework required negated any cost benefits. Obviously the "blame" for this can be freely distributed around the project - poor specs, poor feedback from the developers, poor/slow QA of the product, but the physical separation and language/cultural barrier between the designers and the coders did not help at all.

jonamv8

3,303 posts

197 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
ewenm said:
My experience of outsourcing would suggest that unless you're very precise and exacting it is a false economy. We found that by the time we'd written designs and specifications to enough detail for the offshore coders to develop, we may as well have written the code ourselves. In the end the level of rework required negated any cost benefits. Obviously the "blame" for this can be freely distributed around the project - poor specs, poor feedback from the developers, poor/slow QA of the product, but the physical separation and language/cultural barrier between the designers and the coders did not help at all.
Very true, I have done this for over 5 years for 80% of my core business. What he says above and others do is correct. Unless you know what you are doing, who you are working with and how to get the best from them, DON'T BOTHER. People are blinded by the savings but it's false economy. Done right it's good but the margins today aren't what they sued to be.

Feel free to PM me