Have I been Spoilt by Turbo Cars? Insignia 1.8 Experience
Discussion
I've had turbo (petrol and diesel) mid-size cars for the past 10 years or so, (although I do ride a 600cc bike. I also drive my wife's 1.2 n/a Fabia -which is fine)
I recently had the pleasure of a rental 1.8 Insignia. Whilst the car was better than I'd expected it to be, the engine fitted was absolutely appalling.
There was almost no perceptible 'ooomph' below 5000rpm at all, when you did *eventually* get into the 'powerband' you had to change gear fairly quickly. Maybe it's a motorbike engine?
The accelerator pedal appeared to modulate noise only and have a very vague link with the engine speed. Even trying to keep the revs up and using the gears, it must have been one of the slowest, most unresponsive cars I've driven in recent times. Changing down a couple of cogs and flooring-it didn't have the expected effect.
Even stirring the gear lever I was out-dragged on the motorway by various loaded-up, small vans. Overtaking on single-carriageways was tricky. I'm not afraid of using revs, but even an MGB B-series has more useful shove, maybe
It claims to have 138bhp, which it may do, but it's a shame that Opel didn't produce a tractable engine with a decent torque curve that maxed at around 115bhp -It would have been far better to drive in the real world, even it it couldn't do a claimed 130mph.
I don't remember (smaller, admittedly) 1.8 petrol Cavaliers and Mk2 Mondeos being that bad ....or were they?
Am I wrong? Have my perceptions been changed over the past decade?
Incidentally, it is an "SRI", which seems to mean that it has massive, tram-lining 245 tyres on 18" rims and that the ride is overly-firm allowing you to feel every tiny bump in the road and not very compliant.
Admittedly most people wouldn't be bothered, but the car also has fairly vague steering that doesn't weight-up in the turns, with little feedback and the car feels slightly unsettled in bends.
My 60-odd thousand mile 'non-sporty', 'non-fast' TDCI 140 Mondeo Edge is far better in almost all ways, (performance, ride, handling, space, economy, outward visibility, comfort) other than the front seats, which are very comfortable and supportive in the Insignia.
Would any private or fleet buyer choose a 1.8 Insignia? do rental companies get them extremely cheap?
I recently had the pleasure of a rental 1.8 Insignia. Whilst the car was better than I'd expected it to be, the engine fitted was absolutely appalling.
There was almost no perceptible 'ooomph' below 5000rpm at all, when you did *eventually* get into the 'powerband' you had to change gear fairly quickly. Maybe it's a motorbike engine?
The accelerator pedal appeared to modulate noise only and have a very vague link with the engine speed. Even trying to keep the revs up and using the gears, it must have been one of the slowest, most unresponsive cars I've driven in recent times. Changing down a couple of cogs and flooring-it didn't have the expected effect.
Even stirring the gear lever I was out-dragged on the motorway by various loaded-up, small vans. Overtaking on single-carriageways was tricky. I'm not afraid of using revs, but even an MGB B-series has more useful shove, maybe

It claims to have 138bhp, which it may do, but it's a shame that Opel didn't produce a tractable engine with a decent torque curve that maxed at around 115bhp -It would have been far better to drive in the real world, even it it couldn't do a claimed 130mph.
I don't remember (smaller, admittedly) 1.8 petrol Cavaliers and Mk2 Mondeos being that bad ....or were they?
Am I wrong? Have my perceptions been changed over the past decade?
Incidentally, it is an "SRI", which seems to mean that it has massive, tram-lining 245 tyres on 18" rims and that the ride is overly-firm allowing you to feel every tiny bump in the road and not very compliant.
Admittedly most people wouldn't be bothered, but the car also has fairly vague steering that doesn't weight-up in the turns, with little feedback and the car feels slightly unsettled in bends.
My 60-odd thousand mile 'non-sporty', 'non-fast' TDCI 140 Mondeo Edge is far better in almost all ways, (performance, ride, handling, space, economy, outward visibility, comfort) other than the front seats, which are very comfortable and supportive in the Insignia.
Would any private or fleet buyer choose a 1.8 Insignia? do rental companies get them extremely cheap?
Edited by MC Bodge on Saturday 17th August 01:03
I'd buy the 1.8 at a push mainly because when I'd be looking at getting one (60K+ miles) I'd feel more comfortable than having the diesel with less to go wrong and currently I don't do enough miles for it to be an issue.
However, the newer 1.4T unit available in them I think would be a lot better, I've the predecessor of the engine in my MK1 Vectra, and its very well suited to it as an all rounder, but the Insignia is a bigger car.
I've found most modern cars to be fairly similar in the steering / noise generator factor I'm afraid I think its the way mainstream stuff has gone. Funnily enough, I found the MK2 tdci focus I had as a hire car absolutely terrible for the above, the torque curve was utterly flat and no differentiation in engine note across the range, at least you could change the exhaust on a petrol! I actually sold my MK2 focus petrol at a great loss because I found the steering feel on it so bad I would actually get the train back to my parents rather than drive.
Everyone is different though - the facelift Insignia apparently has amended steering to provide more feel, + the electronic handbrake is now optional!
BTW Mr Vauxhall, as I've defended the Insignia twice today I'm hoping to wake up with one outside tomorrow for my services
However, the newer 1.4T unit available in them I think would be a lot better, I've the predecessor of the engine in my MK1 Vectra, and its very well suited to it as an all rounder, but the Insignia is a bigger car.
I've found most modern cars to be fairly similar in the steering / noise generator factor I'm afraid I think its the way mainstream stuff has gone. Funnily enough, I found the MK2 tdci focus I had as a hire car absolutely terrible for the above, the torque curve was utterly flat and no differentiation in engine note across the range, at least you could change the exhaust on a petrol! I actually sold my MK2 focus petrol at a great loss because I found the steering feel on it so bad I would actually get the train back to my parents rather than drive.
Everyone is different though - the facelift Insignia apparently has amended steering to provide more feel, + the electronic handbrake is now optional!
BTW Mr Vauxhall, as I've defended the Insignia twice today I'm hoping to wake up with one outside tomorrow for my services

Pferdestarke said:
Driven in isolation you're fine. Compared back to back and you're scuppered!
Come again?The 2.0TDCI Mondeo (and probably any other similar car) would leave that 1.8 Insignia for dust.
By way of comparison, accelerating from low speed, through the gears, a Golf Blue motion easily had the legs on the 1.8 Insignia, as well as did the various vans.
As I said, I also drive a 1.2 petrol Fabia, which isn't exactly a ball of fire, and a 600cc bike, which likes rpm.
That car was slow and unresponsive. the 6 gears also needed lowering.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 21:14
I really rate the Insignia - despite the humble badge it's pretty much up there with the Audis etc. The fact that you can buy one for eight grand is a plus point, and the fact that it doesn't have a BMW badge is firmly in its favour. The petrol is a bit dismal, but so is a 318i. Weight and unreaslistic emissions targets have killed petrol cars. Glad to hear the EPB is now optional as it's the one thing that spoilt it for me.
iSore said:
I really rate the Insignia - despite the humble badge it's pretty much up there with the Audis etc.
In over-firm ride, big wheels and not-so-great handling? The interior and dash is like a 90s Aiwa stereo. The Mondeo's isn't great, but a bit more restrained
The Insignia is generally much better than the Vectra though.
I'm no badge snob, I drive a Ford.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 21:23
iSore said:
I really rate the Insignia - despite the humble badge it's pretty much up there with the Audis etc. The fact that you can buy one for eight grand is a plus point, and the fact that it doesn't have a BMW badge is firmly in its favour. The petrol is a bit dismal, but so is a 318i. Weight and unreaslistic emissions targets have killed petrol cars. Glad to hear the EPB is now optional as it's the one thing that spoilt it for me.
Funny that, a mate of mine recently went from an Insignia of some sort - fairly well specced with a biggish engine - to a 2.0 TDi A5. He said they are worlds apart in every way. The guy's a car bloke, so I can take that at face value.MC Bodge said:
Come again?
The 2.0TDCI Mondeo (and probably any other similar car) would leave that 1.8 Insignia for dust.
By way of comparison, accelerating from low speed, through the gears, a Golf Blue motion easily had the legs on the 1.8 Insignia, as well as did the various vans.
As I said, I also drive a 1.2 petrol Fabia, which isn't exactly a ball of fire, and a 600cc bike, which likes rpm.
That car was slow and unresponsive. the 6 gears also needed lowering.
The Fabia 1.2 is called HTP (High Torque Power) and it's design is to give you a torquey shove when required so it drives almost like a turbo diesel would.The 2.0TDCI Mondeo (and probably any other similar car) would leave that 1.8 Insignia for dust.
By way of comparison, accelerating from low speed, through the gears, a Golf Blue motion easily had the legs on the 1.8 Insignia, as well as did the various vans.
As I said, I also drive a 1.2 petrol Fabia, which isn't exactly a ball of fire, and a 600cc bike, which likes rpm.
That car was slow and unresponsive. the 6 gears also needed lowering.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 21:14
I think you experiencing an underpowered car with an engine that has unsuitable characteristics for the job it's applied to. The large wheels and tyres and the shed load of safety gadgets it's hauling around are all going to make it more noticeable than say an older 1.8 Cavalier or Vectra. The fly by wire throttle may also be deadening out power delivery for efficiency as well.
GM will not have bothered to have matched that gearbox and engine to that particular application, such as you noticing the final drive is too long. That's the problem of a giant parts bin im afraid
MC Bodge said:
Pferdestarke said:
Driven in isolation you're fine. Compared back to back and you're scuppered!
Come again?The 2.0TDCI Mondeo (and probably any other similar car) would leave that 1.8 Insignia for dust.
By way of comparison, accelerating from low speed, through the gears, a Golf Blue motion easily had the legs on the 1.8 Insignia, as well as did the various vans.
As I said, I also drive a 1.2 petrol Fabia, which isn't exactly a ball of fire, and a 600cc bike, which likes rpm.
That car was slow and unresponsive. the 6 gears also needed lowering.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 21:14
hedges88 said:
The Fabia 1.2 is called HTP (High Torque Power) and it's design is to give you a torquey shove when required so it drives almost like a turbo diesel would.
I know what HTP stands for, but steady-on, that's a bit of an exaggeration.hedges88 said:
I think you experiencing an underpowered car with an engine that has unsuitable characteristics for the job it's applied to.
Quite. more grunt, less top-end power would be better.FWIW, the car is very slow, not just a bit peaky.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 22:19
goneape said:
Funny that, a mate of mine recently went from an Insignia of some sort - fairly well specced with a biggish engine - to a 2.0 TDi A5. He said they are worlds apart in every way. The guy's a car bloke, so I can take that at face value.
It's easy to convince yourself that the extra few grand you've spunked were well spend. Audis are alright, but I'd put money on the Ope....I mean Vauxhall dashboard being made by Ze same German firm as the Audi.The A5 is however a more expensive car - comparison with the A4 would be fairer. I'm a car bloke too, but VAG stuff doesn't impress me a lot.
MC Bodge said:
In over-firm ride, big wheels and not-so-great handling?
The interior and dash is like a 90s Aiwa stereo. The Mondeo's isn't great, but a bit more restrained
The Insignia is generally much better than the Vectra though.
I'm no badge snob, I drive a Ford.
Nothing wrong with the handling but the SRi does ride very poorly. The basic one (do they still do the Merit?) is a nicer all rounder. I've driven a 1.6 Opel Insignia hire car - the full 1996 cavalier experience but okay if you can bag one for 5 grand. There are a few in the UK now, ex Channel Islands hire cars. I'd suffer one if it were cheap enough.The interior and dash is like a 90s Aiwa stereo. The Mondeo's isn't great, but a bit more restrained
The Insignia is generally much better than the Vectra though.
I'm no badge snob, I drive a Ford.
Edited by MC Bodge on Friday 16th August 21:23
MC Bodge said:
Quite. So why did Opel think that a 1.8 with the torque curve of a racing car and high gears would be suited to a heavy family car?
Because it's probably a fair bit more efficient and less polluting than an engine designed to provide torque and power? Not everyone wants a diesel, not even sales reps, but it's a heavy sales rep car with no pretension of performance, of course a 138bhp is going to feel lacking in it. It's probably pretty cheap to run as a company car, even if it is a sack of s
te. It might not have the torque of a diesel (which a lot of rep mobile driver sure like to bang on about), but if you wanted an Insignia and couldn't stand the clatter of a diesel engine, you'd either get the 1.8L and deal with it or get the proper VXR, with a turbocharged V6.I don't think it's an isolated case. The rental 1.7 Astra I had after I wrote off my Fiat Seicento - I was expecting a lot more in terms of oomf from the car with the bigger engine, but clearly the extra weight didn't help and the engine isn't tuned well. I found it very lacking in grunt, and family members and friends who've had recent petrol Vauxhalls have said much the same thing. I think maybe it's to do with trying to tune them for minimum emissions, but don't quote me on it, I'm not exactly a know it all!
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


