Lies by the dealer's parts dept - am I being unreasonable?
Lies by the dealer's parts dept - am I being unreasonable?
Author
Discussion

g3org3y

Original Poster:

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
A shame as by and large I've found BMW parts depts to be pretty decent (certainly more reliable than their Servicing counterparts).

Was getting the engine and gearbox mounts changed on the E36 Touring, bought from ECP but needed the nuts/inbuilt washers to fit. Not the kind of thing they have at ECP, dealer only part. Monday morning, called my local mechanics (who are always happy for me to supply parts) and agreed that I'd bring the car in Friday am to get the work done. Needed it done sooner rather than later as driving to Scotland next Fri for a wedding.

I'm away for work in Colchester (driving the E30) and my father kindly agreed to drop off the Touring on his way to work Friday. As such, I had an E36 with new mounts in boxes but no nuts back at my parents.

Nipped into the BMW dealer Monday lunchtime (with my RealOEM printout) who tell me they don't have the nuts in stock, they can order them and they'll be delivered the next day. I asked whether it would be possible to get them sent to the dealership local to my father so he can collect. Apparently not, but they can send direct to the house asap Tuesday morning.

Perfect I think, if sent off Tuesday morning (1st Class) they'll by at my father's house Weds if not Thursday at the latest to accompany the mounts when taken to the mechanic Friday morning.

Wednesday comes, nothing. Thursday comes, nothing.frown
Friday morning, my father takes the car to the mechanic, apologising at the lack of nuts. Certainly annoying as it makes me look a bit of a tt agreeing to supply the parts and missing the fittings.

I call the dealer's parts dept as soon as it opens enquiring as to what has happened.
After a minute or so on hold...
Parts Dept: "yes the parts arrived, we popped them in the post yesterday [Thursday] afternoon so you should get them in a couple of days"
Me: "Hmmm, that's not very helpful is it given that I wanted them by this morning?".

Anyway, by luck the mount situation was sorted (mechanic had some spare bits around). This morning (Saturday), guess what arrives...the nuts. Except, the chap who packaged them has made an error, inside is an invoice dated 16th August (Friday), 8:44am. About 5 minutes after I got off the phone from them.

Obviously they've forgotten to send them on Tues morning and only prompted to do so when I called on Friday. When done so, they've lied stating they were sent the afternoon before (despite the evidence on the enclosed invoice and the postmark on the envelope). I would not have minded as much if they simply admitted the mistake. To lie is a bit naughty.

So I'm annoyed for two reasons:
1) For a BMW main dealer to be unable to send parts without prompting. rolleyes
2) Telling lies to cover up a mistake. rolleyesrolleyes

I'll be going in on Monday to get a refund on the unused nuts (of course). I'm not one for grumps and arguments but I'm tempted to ask to speak to the Parts Dept Manager (if such exists, if not higher) to bring this issue up. Not sure what I hope to achieve, an apology would be nice and an admission that such service is unacceptable.

What do you guys reckon, am I being unreasonable?

CoolHands

23,712 posts

226 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
You're on a hiding to nothing. Forget it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Lying to cover their arse isn't on, but they probably have experience of admitting to stuff like that and then having a ballistic customer demanding compo for their wasted time etc etc.

Personally if it's the first time it's happened to me then I'd just let it go, "let he who is without sin..." and all that. If it happened again then it's not just an isolated cockup and I'd let the management know as they need to tighten up on their processes.

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
They forgot? It happens...

Or, maybe they were a wee bit hacked at you not giving them the chance to supply the other parts? Did you price them up at the Dealer?

In the past, we would go the extra mile to supply all the parts we could, a small % of something is better than 100% of bugger all! We worked on maintaining relatiopnships with customers, both within the trade and on the retail side. Even bloody Taxi Drivers can provide a revenue stream if handled correctly wink

Oh, and to this day, I still bump into old customers, and stop and have a chat. I actually enjoyed my job behind the counter, but I did have an active interest on all things with wheels.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
So to what extend did your "favoured customer special order" enhance their cash turnover this week?

N7GTX

8,312 posts

174 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Identical situation for me - forget to order the parts - this week with a Fiat dealer. I kicked off telling them how useless they were etc etc so they got their parts driver to go to their nearest rival, buy the parts from them then deliver them to a garage for me. That's how to correct a cock up.

If it makes you feel better tell the dealer principal the service is not good enough but you wont get any further really.

g3org3y

Original Poster:

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
charltjr said:
Lying to cover their arse isn't on, but they probably have experience of admitting to stuff like that and then having a ballistic customer demanding compo for their wasted time etc etc.

Personally if it's the first time it's happened to me then I'd just let it go, "let he who is without sin..." and all that. If it happened again then it's not just an isolated cockup and I'd let the management know as they need to tighten up on their processes.
I'm not wanting any 'compensayshun' and I'm certainly not one to go ballistic. I suppose I just want to feedback that I'm annoyed and get an apology (as well as refund).

I find people are a lot more amenable if you cock up and admit it rather than try to lie and cover it up.

750turbo said:
They forgot? It happens...

Or, maybe they were a wee bit hacked at you not giving them the chance to supply the other parts? Did you price them up at the Dealer?

In the past, we would go the extra mile to supply all the parts we could, a small % of something is better than 100% of bugger all! We worked on maintaining relatiopnships with customers, both within the trade and on the retail side. Even bloody Taxi Drivers can provide a revenue stream if handled correctly wink

Oh, and to this day, I still bump into old customers, and stop and have a chat. I actually enjoyed my job behind the counter, but I did have an active interest on all things with wheels.
This WAS the BMW main dealer parts dept.

I gathered they forgot. Although annoying certainly not the end of the world. It's the attempted 'cover up' that probably gripes the most.

What I do or do not purchase from them is not their concern and I'm of the opinion there's no reason to be 'hacked off'. It's bad enough BMW parts depts are changing from parts counters with informed and knowledgeable people to a counter for selling MINI branded tat.

I've had plenty of parts that have been ordered-in and sent to me in the post. Certainly not 'going the extra mile' imo.

Ozzie Osmond said:
So to what extend did your "favoured customer special order" enhance their cash turnover this week?
Are you suggesting that I need to spend over X amount to ensure parts are sent out on time and without reminder?

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
charltjr said:
Lying to cover their arse isn't on, but they probably have experience of admitting to stuff like that and then having a ballistic customer demanding compo for their wasted time etc etc.

Personally if it's the first time it's happened to me then I'd just let it go, "let he who is without sin..." and all that. If it happened again then it's not just an isolated cockup and I'd let the management know as they need to tighten up on their processes.
I'm not wanting any 'compensayshun' and I'm certainly not one to go ballistic. I suppose I just want to feedback that I'm annoyed and get an apology (as well as refund).

I find people are a lot more amenable if you cock up and admit it rather than try to lie and cover it up.

750turbo said:
They forgot? It happens...

Or, maybe they were a wee bit hacked at you not giving them the chance to supply the other parts? Did you price them up at the Dealer?

In the past, we would go the extra mile to supply all the parts we could, a small % of something is better than 100% of bugger all! We worked on maintaining relatiopnships with customers, both within the trade and on the retail side. Even bloody Taxi Drivers can provide a revenue stream if handled correctly wink

Oh, and to this day, I still bump into old customers, and stop and have a chat. I actually enjoyed my job behind the counter, but I did have an active interest on all things with wheels.
This WAS the BMW main dealer parts dept.

I gathered they forgot. Although annoying certainly not the end of the world. It's the attempted 'cover up' that probably gripes the most.

What I do or do not purchase from them is not their concern and I'm of the opinion there's no reason to be 'hacked off'. It's bad enough BMW parts depts are changing from parts counters with informed and knowledgeable people to a counter for selling MINI branded tat.

I've had plenty of parts that have been ordered-in and sent to me in the post. Certainly not 'going the extra mile' imo.

Ozzie Osmond said:
So to what extend did your "favoured customer special order" enhance their cash turnover this week?
Are you suggesting that I need to spend over X amount to ensure parts are sent out on time and without reminder?
FFS, when will people realise that having a decent relationship with dealers, will very often pay off in the end. (Did you price the engine mounts at the Dealer? Did they have a chance to complete on price?)

We certainly used to try and keep customers happy in this respect, sales may very well sell the first car, who sells the second, third, etc...? Then again I did server a proper Parts Apprenticeship and knew my stuff in all prospects of the business.

Shame the money was cak at the time.

g3org3y

Original Poster:

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
750turbo said:
FFS, when will people realise that having a decent relationship with dealers, will very often pay off in the end. (Did you price the engine mounts at the Dealer? Did they have a chance to complete on price?)

We certainly used to try and keep customers happy in this respect, sales may very well sell the first car, who sells the second, third, etc...? Then again I did server a proper Parts Apprenticeship and knew my stuff in all prospects of the business.

Shame the money was cak at the time.
Should the amount I spend (or the order itself) determine the service? I didn't ask for them to order-in Scarlett Johansson for a blow job, just some nuts (which almost came to a tenner). They claimed they'd send it out, they forgot and they tried to cover it up.

Main dealer parts depts aren't stupid, they know in the majority of cases they can't compete with retailers like ECP. That's why a couple have taken to ebay and the like selling genuine parts at reduced prices.

Example, airflow sensor rubber boot that I needed. £26.10 at the dealer, 14.65+99p delivery online via ebay (Stratstone BMW).

750turbo

6,164 posts

255 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
They got it very wrong, you know it, they know it, why make the life of the minimum wage guy awkward by moaning at the GM? (He may well pay lip service anyway, you will never know)

What I am getting at is, as you have said, Dealers Parts Depts are becoming acutely aware of what they are up against, and the clever ones are acting on it. Give them a chance!

Anyway, footie is on, I am having a beer Have a nice evening!

g3org3y

Original Poster:

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
750turbo said:
They got it very wrong, you know it, they know it, why make the life of the minimum wage guy awkward by moaning at the GM? (He may well pay lip service anyway, you will never know)

What I am getting at is, as you have said, Dealers Parts Depts are becoming acutely aware of what they are up against, and the clever ones are acting on it. Give them a chance!

Anyway, footie is on, I am having a beer Have a nice evening!
I don't want to make things difficult, an apology would be nice though.

Agreed though, much more interesting stuff to do - beer

I did ask them about Scarlett Johansson - NLA apparently. frown

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
So to what extend did your "favoured customer special order" enhance their cash turnover this week?
Are you suggesting that I need to spend over X amount to ensure parts are sent out on time and without reminder?
BMW dealers sell and service expensive cars - that's their business. If you can't understand that selling a few nuts & bolts to someone who's bought cheap parts from the local factor and having them fitted under the railway arches isn't the dealer's top priority then you're way out of touch.


bitchstewie

68,506 posts

241 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I'd want an apology. Not for the mistake, these things happen, but for them lying which I don't think is on.

Whether I'd go out of my way to try and get one is another matter.

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
retail is a service industry . good service is a given . the customer that spends a few quid may be back for a £60k motor or not . just provide good service as standard

excel monkey

4,825 posts

258 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
BMW dealers sell and service expensive cars - that's their business. If you can't understand that selling a few nuts & bolts to someone who's bought cheap parts from the local factor and having them fitted under the railway arches isn't the dealer's top priority then you're way out of touch.
Bluntly put, but correct.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
excel monkey said:
Ozzie Osmond said:
BMW dealers sell and service expensive cars - that's their business. If you can't understand that selling a few nuts & bolts to someone who's bought cheap parts from the local factor and having them fitted under the railway arches isn't the dealer's top priority then you're way out of touch.
Bluntly put, but correct.
Really? Mark-up on OE parts is considerably more than service and vehicle sales, and a happy customer buying nuts and bolts will usually need other bits in the not-so-distant future, bits that won't be available from ECP.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Anyway, by luck the mount situation was sorted (mechanic had some spare bits around). This morning (Saturday), guess what arrives...the nuts. Except, the chap who packaged them has made an error, inside is an invoice dated 16th August (Friday), 8:44am. About 5 minutes after I got off the phone from them.

Obviously they've forgotten to send them on Tues morning and only prompted to do so when I called on Friday. When done so, they've lied stating they were sent the afternoon before (despite the evidence on the enclosed invoice and the postmark on the envelope). I would not have minded as much if they simply admitted the mistake. To lie is a bit naughty.

So I'm annoyed for two reasons:
1) For a BMW main dealer to be unable to send parts without prompting. rolleyes
2) Telling lies to cover up a mistake. rolleyesrolleyes

I'll be going in on Monday to get a refund on the unused nuts (of course). I'm not one for grumps and arguments but I'm tempted to ask to speak to the Parts Dept Manager (if such exists, if not higher) to bring this issue up. Not sure what I hope to achieve, an apology would be nice and an admission that such service is unacceptable.

What do you guys reckon, am I being unreasonable?
Or they respond that the previous package must have got lost so they re-sent them following your call, or the guy answering the phone honestly believed your request had been fulfilled and the parts posted, but finishing the call with you finds that the guy on shift when the parts arrived didn't post them but put them ready for you to collect.
Not every lie is malicious it could have been an honest mistake a failure of their systems or the guy covering his own cock up.

excel monkey

4,825 posts

258 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
What do you guys reckon, am I being unreasonable?
"Am I being unreasonable?" is a very mumsnet phrase!

To use the mumsnet vernacular, YABOS smile

http://www.mumsnet.com/info/acronyms

As others have said, probably easiest just to suck it up, and quietly take your business elsewhere in the future. Don't waste your energy on furious phone calls and letters.

9mm

3,128 posts

241 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Yes. You need to find more important things to worry about.

droopsnoot

14,793 posts

273 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
But another way to look at it is you might have been dealing with someone new on the job who just didn't realise that not sending the parts out when they promised was going to cause a big problem elsewhere (not knowing or forgetting the rest of the story, if they knew it to start with), and getting a light telling-off from the parts manager might be all they need to remember it for the rest of their career. I made some mistakes when I was first starting out because I didn't know any better, and hearing about what a pain it was for the customer made me more careful in the long term. OP isn't expecting the parts person to be sacked, just reminded that doing what you say, and not trying to cover up mistakes, is important.