Why are fake-4wd cars front biased?
Why are fake-4wd cars front biased?
Author
Discussion

Johnnytheboy

Original Poster:

24,499 posts

217 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
OK I'll start two threads in GG today.

So me and my father (who knows a thing or two more than me about cars) were debating this today, having read the A45 review in Autocar and we don't know the answer.

Most cars with part time 4wd these days have a Haldex/Haldex-a-like system where the rear wheels are only driven when the front wheels lose grip.

Now, if the manufacturers have gone to the trouble of putting the plumbing of 4wd in, why not make this the other way round, particularly on performance models? In other words the car is rear wheel drive until the rear wheels begin to lose grip.

The A45 AMG is a prime example, the 4wd system AFAIK is only going in this model, and I imagine a good car would be much better with rear biased 4wd.

It's not impossible as Ford had rear biased (albeit permanent) 4wd in the 90s RS2000.

Apologies if a repost - I've seen this discussed obliquely but not directly.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all


The engine drives the gear box which drives the front diff and then the front diff then drives the shaft to the back axle

So i don't think you can have more power going to the back

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
The Infiniti G37 is RWD until the fronts require the oomph. The same system ATESA Nissan use for other cars.

Edited by TheHeretic on Saturday 17th August 14:35

GravelBen

16,555 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:


The engine drives the gear box which drives the front diff and then the front diff then drives the shaft to the back axle

So i don't think you can have more power going to the back
This is pretty much it - they're basically using the cheapest way they can find of turning a Fwd car into a 4wd one, presumably they don't think a more capable and driver-oriented solution is worth the extra cost.

Other examples like the G37 are based on Rwd cars which makes it a bit easier to do - plus Nissan have been using the ATTESSA system in various forms for 20+ years, so its not like they're having to pay for new technology.

Edited by GravelBen on Saturday 17th August 14:37

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
As others have said - it's cheaper and the vast majority of these cars are either based on a FWD platform or not a drivers car so they aren't losing sales.

The Skyline GTR have always been RWD until 4WD is required which IMO is the best of both worlds.

Johnnytheboy said:
It's not impossible as Ford had rear biased (albeit permanent) 4wd in the 90s RS2000.
Was it ?

Rickyy

6,618 posts

250 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Cost? Surely a car with a stronger rear bias would need a beefier rear diff and propshaft?

TheHeretic

73,668 posts

286 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
As others have said - it's cheaper and the vast majority of these cars are either based on a FWD platform or not a drivers car so they aren't losing sales.

The Skyline GTR have always been RWD until 4WD is required which IMO is the best of both worlds.

Was it ?
Infiniti uses the same system that I linked to earlier. I've never driven a GTR, but I have driven the G37x, and it is superb fun in twisty sections on the limit. You can really feel the front scrubbing slightly, and then it just gets pointy and you can really push round corners.

Disco You

3,749 posts

211 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
The Veyron is rear until necessary right?

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
I think recent Audi RS4's have a 60/40 RWD bias.

El Capitano

1,157 posts

224 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
McWigglebum4th said:


The engine drives the gear box which drives the front diff and then the front diff then drives the shaft to the back axle

So i don't think you can have more power going to the back
I thought you could do a Haldex modification to essentially flip the bias to the rear though?

GravelBen

16,555 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
El Capitano said:
I thought you could do a Haldex modification to essentially flip the bias to the rear though?
I think the ones I've heard of just hold it at its rearmost bias (which is usually 50:50 or 60f:40r) rather than the normal 90:10 or whatever it is before slippage.

Johnnytheboy

Original Poster:

24,499 posts

217 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Johnnytheboy said:
It's not impossible as Ford had rear biased (albeit permanent) 4wd in the 90s RS2000.
Was it ?
Yep.

GravelBen

16,555 posts

261 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
blade7 said:
I think recent Audi RS4's have a 60/40 RWD bias.
They'd be Torsen rather than Haldex wouldn't they? The older ones were at least, longitudinal engines made it easier to use proper 4wd.

xRIEx

8,180 posts

179 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Johnnytheboy said:
It's not impossible as Ford had rear biased (albeit permanent) 4wd in the 90s RS2000.
Was it ?
He may have been thinking of the RS200, which of course had the engine and gearbox at the rear.

texaxile

3,819 posts

181 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
xRIEx said:
He may have been thinking of the RS200, which of course had the engine and gearbox at the rear.
RS200's were around 1986-87 iirc, but there was a limited run of 4WD RS2000 Escorts made around 1992. I have no idea what the drive system was like on them though,but I always thought the RS200 was a permanent 4WD 60/40 split.

bungle

1,874 posts

271 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
El Capitano said:
I thought you could do a Haldex modification to essentially flip the bias to the rear though?
They certainly used to do a "blue" Haldex (more rear bias, or cut in quicker, can't remember; was always popular with VAG Haldex cars) and then an "orange" Haldex (essentially more of a "race-mode" Haldex, but no real idea what that meant!).

dvs_dave

9,040 posts

256 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
HALDEX doesn't require the use of a center diff. Packaging advantage, but performance disadvantage.

A haldex system can only apportion up to 50% of available drive torque away from the primary driven axle. A permanent AWD system with a center diff (eg Audi quattro) can, depending on diff type, apportion the available drive torque to either axle as required. It's also more efficient and doesn't upset handling balance. This is because windup between axles is handled automatically and seamlessly. Haldex deals with it by electronically controlling the haldex clutch slip. This wastes energy and can give odd torque transfer alterations between axles.

skyrover

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
because most crossover/car based 4x4's have transversely mounted engines

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
It's because you need your torque distribution to match your static mass distribution! Most vehicles these days have a mass distribution that is front biased (when unloaded) as they are generally front engined / transmissioned. So the "point" of 4x4 is to get more traction, and the longitudinal force transfer capability of a tyre is determined by the normal (vertical) load on that tyre (and obviously the frictional co-efficient). So, if your car is 65% / 35% (F/R) by mass, the average optimum traction will come from having a torque split that matched that mass split.

At this point the concept of "handling" and "driver satisfaction" in conjunction with dynamic mass transfer rears it's head, and things get complicated. The more "handling" biased (i.e. sliding the car, and getting oversteer because keen drivers prefer that) the more the static (and dynamic) torque split will be towards the rear of the car. Whereas for a non sporting car, which needs max traction under low dynamic loading, will have a front based split that doesn't move too far rearwards. If you imagine say a 4x4 SUV on a icy cambered road, if the torque split was too far rearwards, as soon as the driver tried to drive away the rear wheels would spin and the back of the car would slide sideways down the camber into the ditch. For the majority of untrained drivers this is alarming, and hence is avoided by the manufacturers. Because exactly no one is going to be "power sliding" a Kuga or a CashCow this is the torque split the manufacturers implement!


dvs_dave

9,040 posts

256 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
^^^^^ one reason, but not the defining reason! A proper 3 diff system can achieve at least the same, or better depending on center diff type!

[/needless use of exclamation marks]