MX-5 RC 2.0 or SLK200 - help me decide!
MX-5 RC 2.0 or SLK200 - help me decide!
Author
Discussion

Willwors

Original Poster:

77 posts

159 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I have driven two fantastic cars this week - and can't for the life of me make up my mind about which one to go for.

I want the car for a bit of weekend fun, but also (and perhaps more importantly) to do some proper touring in, to take to Europe, and really rack up the miles.

The MX-5 feels very much like my old MK2 and is extremely impressive. It's very good value with leather and nav etc. within my budget, but I suppose my concern is that it's a bit small for long trips. I thought the 1.8 litre was a bit lacking, but that the 2.0 was OK on power.

The new SLK200 is fantastic too and I loved the combination of the new turbocharged unit and 7GTronic box, but probably a little bit over-budget and therefore I think I am probably looking at one of the end of the line Kompressor models. I think my concerns here are the cost of maintenance and any associated reliability problems this model might have had.

Does anyone have any say in what they would go for in this situation - and is there anything else I should be trying out?!

Thanks

Will

zebra

4,555 posts

245 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Mx5. May lack some of the luxuries of the Merc but is better looking, better handling and you can still tour in it. I tour in my exige which has less luggage space than the 5.

At the end of the day, it's all down to what you want, which you prefer to drive, which you prefer the look of and what you intend to use the car for.

Ecosseven

2,384 posts

248 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
MX-5 for me. I own a mk3.5 sport tech which has the 2.0 engine and the 6 speed 'box. The SLK will have more torque, better refinement and better quality plastics. The MX-5 will be more fun to drive, cheaper to run and possibly more reliable. Looks are subjective but I think both cars are attractive. The SLK probably has a slightly more feminine image if that is something that bothers you.


Willwors

Original Poster:

77 posts

159 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I think the SLK has a better quality interior argument actually isn't true, the MX-5 interior quality is fantastic.

Do we know when the new Alfa/Mazda joint venture is due to hit showrooms?

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Try a Boxster. 2 boots, great handling, bit bigger and more powerful than an MX5.

Superhoop

4,919 posts

224 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Willwors said:
I think the SLK has a better quality interior argument actually isn't true, the MX-5 interior quality is fantastic.

Do we know when the new Alfa/Mazda joint venture is due to hit showrooms?
Early 2015