What 4x4? (Bangernomics)
What 4x4? (Bangernomics)
Author
Discussion

radiodanno

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

161 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
What would you buy if you were me?

Last Winter (as it went on and on and on) I swore I'd buy a Forester to get me to work safely, regardless of snow and ice. The original plan was to spend £2500 on a lovely 04 plate NON turbo and have it as my only car.

Since then, I've got into Bangernomics and it's going very well. Spent £850 on a 1999 Avensis at the start of June, have done 6500 miles without a single glitch. SO - I'm now minded to spend the same amount on a 4x4 to get me to work on those horrible snowy and icy days (100 mile round trip) and keep the Toyota for when the going's good (Avensis 41 MPG against Forester 30 MPG)

So, bearing in mind it'll effectively be a weekend car with a few weeks of driving Dec-March what would you buy?

Original plan: Forester Non Turbo.
Now thinking: Forester Turbo (Hooning an optional extra)

But what else can you get for the money that's reliable and brilliant in the snow?

All thoughts appreciated.


Blue Oval84

5,399 posts

192 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Before this descends into the usual "fit winter tyres to the Avensis" I'm going to suggest a hybrid solution...

I quite like the Subaru idea to be honest but, two random thoughts that popped into my head-

Are Jag X-Type 4X4s particularly cheap yet? If so, one of those, shod with winters or All Seasons (so you've no need to take them off in the summer) would probably get you where you're going. In fact Clarkson seems to think you can take it skiing, literally. He quite liked it IIRC, and the 3.0V6 is lovely.

Failing that, you could pick up an AWD Volvo T5 estate for well under £2.5K I think?

sunbeam alpine

7,251 posts

219 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Daihatsu Fourtrak (check carefully for rust)

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
i keep seeing grand cherokees for £1k . how bad can they be ?

radiodanno

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

161 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Blue Oval84 said:
Before this descends into the usual "fit winter tyres to the Avensis" I'm going to suggest a hybrid solution...

I quite like the Subaru idea to be honest but, two random thoughts that popped into my head-

Are Jag X-Type 4X4s particularly cheap yet? If so, one of those, shod with winters or All Seasons (so you've no need to take them off in the summer) would probably get you where you're going. In fact Clarkson seems to think you can take it skiing, literally. He quite liked it IIRC, and the 3.0V6 is lovely.

Failing that, you could pick up an AWD Volvo T5 estate for well under £2.5K I think?
TBH I've never had winter tyres on a car before, so that's something to look at. If the difference is 'Night and Day' then it's definitely an option.

I guess if I went for another car it would make up for the shortcomings of a 14 year old Avensis. The fact it's a saloon (not good for lugging/tip run etc/kids bikes) and it's not fun.

BUT: if the winter tyres are seriously good then it's got to be a serious consideration.

bitchstewie

68,506 posts

241 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
By all means get a 4x4 if you want one but if you do consider tyres also consider all-season.

I have a Freelander 2 which needs new rubber and I think I'm about to go get four Nokian WR G2's as they're supposed to be excellent in winter but are also suitable for all year use.

Without wanting to patronise trust me as someone who has a 2 ton 4x4 on "normal" tyres (Conti 4x4 Contact) that they may get going a little easier than a car on winter rubber in some situations but they don't stop easier - that is largely a function of the rubber.

radiodanno

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

161 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Brilliant, thanks for your help.

Question: Are the early Rav 4's permanent Four Wheel Drive - or are they an example of a car trying to figure out what's happening using mid 90s technology?!

minghis

1,579 posts

282 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
radiodanno said:
Brilliant, thanks for your help.

Question: Are the early Rav 4's permanent Four Wheel Drive - or are they an example of a car trying to figure out what's happening using mid 90s technology?!
The early (1994 I believe) RAV's had front wheel drive and a button that selected the 4 wheel drive.

oceanview

1,631 posts

162 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
jas xjr said:
i keep seeing grand cherokees for £1k . how bad can they be ?
The 4ltr petrols average 16-20 mpg, mid twenties for 2.5 diesel. Also, most are auto which normally spells trouble at that price range.

Liquid Tuna

1,403 posts

187 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
radiodanno said:
TBH I've never had winter tyres on a car before, so that's something to look at. If the difference is 'Night and Day' then it's definitely an option.
Yes, it really is. It's a revelation. Don't listen to anyone who hasn't used them as they won't have a clue. I've used winters on 2WD and 4WD cars. I've also driven a 4WD on normal summer tyres in snow and ice and a 2WD on winters is far superior. The best of all worlds is a 4WD on winters - unstoppable.

So if you're choosing between 2WD with winters and 4WD without, I'd say 2WD with winters every time. Even in the snow we had last winter which most will agree was the worst generally for decades, my missus's 2WD mazda 2 with winters was superb.

HaloGen8

1,413 posts

160 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
WeirdNeville said:
Seriously, just get winter tyres on a spare set of wheels and then wonder why anyone short of the highlands and islands lot in the UK thinks they need a 4x4 to deal with winter conditions.

However, a forester or legacy outback on winters would be truly unstoppable.
^^^this. I bought some replacement alloys (£20 for 4 Volvo 15") then bought a set of winter tyres. There was NOWHERE I couldn't go in the snow. Truely amazing. The A21 going to work was down to one lane and 15mph I have 40 mile commute, so I joined lane two behind the Toyota Hilux and Range Rover brigade and promptly zipped along including the uphill bits at a steady 40 mph with not a murmur or fuss. The look on people's faces as I climbed snow filled hills was priceless.
Winter tyres are like having an unfair performance advantage in the snow.

bigfatnick

1,012 posts

233 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Liquid Tuna said:
radiodanno said:
TBH I've never had winter tyres on a car before, so that's something to look at. If the difference is 'Night and Day' then it's definitely an option.
Yes, it really is. It's a revelation. Don't listen to anyone who hasn't used them as they won't have a clue. I've used winters on 2WD and 4WD cars. I've also driven a 4WD on normal summer tyres in snow and ice and a 2WD on winters is far superior. The best of all worlds is a 4WD on winters - unstoppable.

So if you're choosing between 2WD with winters and 4WD without, I'd say 2WD with winters every time. Even in the snow we had last winter which most will agree was the worst generally for decades, my missus's 2WD mazda 2 with winters was superb.
I put some of those 4.5mm part worn winters you see on ebay on my bangernomics Bmw 325 after living in a ski resort and seeing how everyone drove normal cars, not 4x4's, and never have an issue.

The way i describe it to most people is that it turned driving on snow/ice into driving on gravel. The whole world became a really rather smooth, gravel rally stage. Never got stuck, never had issues, did drift constantly. 3rd gear powerslides in the snow were oddly controllable. Winter tyres turn you into a driving god.

The only issue i see for you is that you'll be doing in in a front wheel drive car. So it wont be quite as much fun. But thats why the gaffer tape gods invented hand brake buttons that could be taped down easily!

Watchman

6,391 posts

276 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Any Scooby on winter tyres will make everyone else's choice seem odd as soon as the snow falls. My Legacy on Nokians became everyone's tow vehicle up our hill. My current car, a Merc ML on some Grabber AT tyres is decent enough but isn't in the same league as the Leggy.

My choice for the next car will be a Subaru Outback 3.6 litre petrol auto. Unstoppable when everyone else is stuck and a generally nice drive when the weather's fine. And a good tow vehicle come holiday time.

steve2

1,875 posts

249 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
minghis said:
radiodanno said:
Brilliant, thanks for your help.

Question: Are the early Rav 4's permanent Four Wheel Drive - or are they an example of a car trying to figure out what's happening using mid 90s technology?!
The early (1994 I believe) RAV's had front wheel drive and a button that selected the 4 wheel drive.
We have a 96 Rav4 and it is permanent 4 wheel drive with an electronic diff lock button

Love it in the snow and handles foot deep stuff

405dogvan

5,329 posts

296 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
For a regular British Winter (unless you live somewhere remote) all you need is a car

For the winters we've been having of late tho, winter tyres make a lot of difference. They aren't really about snow and ice tho - they're about wet roads and temps under 7degrees - where existing tyres start to 'go off'.

None of that will help if it snows and/or we get lots of ice - then you need something with proper 4wd, proper snow tyres and maybe even chains or something like that. Worst-case, you'll need that for about 5 days in a year and a whole car with unique tyres etc. for 5 days transport is hardly bangernomics is it?

In fact, owning 2 cars is not bangernomics really...

Also - remember that it's great being in a car which 'goes anywhere' but you can only get as far as the person in-front anyway. Even if you are 'king of the terrain' you'll be spending your day pulling other people out of ditches...

So, summary, put winters on the Avensis and on the bad days - take the day off like anyone with sense would...

Edited by 405dogvan on Sunday 18th August 15:00

radiodanno

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

161 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
405dogvan said:
For a regular British Winter (unless you live somewhere remote) all you need is a car

For the winters we've been having of late tho, winter tyres make a lot of difference. They aren't really about snow and ice tho - they're about wet roads and temps under 7degrees - where existing tyres start to 'go off'.

None of that will help if it snows and/or we get lots of ice - then you need something with proper 4wd, proper snow tyres and maybe even chains or something like that. Worst-case, you'll need that for about 5 days in a year and a whole car with unique tyres etc. for 5 days transport is hardly bangernomics is it?

In fact, owning 2 cars is not bangernomics really...

Also - remember that it's great being in a car which 'goes anywhere' but you can only get as far as the person in-front anyway. Even if you are 'king of the terrain' you'll be spending your day pulling other people out of ditches...

So, summary, put winters on the Avensis and on the bad days - take the day off like anyone with sense would...

Edited by 405dogvan on Sunday 18th August 15:00
I know what you're saying, but every day off work costs me £250. (self employed). It also irritates the company who give me gainful work.

By Bangernomics, I guess I mean no/minimal depreciation and minimal running costs. I guess I'd justify having a Forester Turbo as 'essential come the winter' to my wife whilst making the vicar next door's fillings fall out every time I start it at 4am.

Supernova190188

936 posts

170 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
can't go wrong with an Isuzu Trooper 3.1! cheap and reliable.

Pistom

6,433 posts

190 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
What was the issue with winter tyres again? 2 winters ago I was towing 4x4s out of ditches with my RWD with winter tyres. Getting a 4x4 for roa use sounds a bit OTT unless you've got children to get to school over small speed humps.

bearman68

4,942 posts

163 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Supernova190188 said:
can't go wrong with an Isuzu Trooper 3.1! cheap and reliable.
Not cheap to run though lol. Put big knobbly tyres on that, and the snow will come over the bonnet before it stops going forward. Trust me I've done it.

radiodanno

Original Poster:

1,092 posts

161 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
WeirdNeville said:
You earn £250 a day but can't muster more than an Avensis, or even a spare set of shoes for it??
Yep. The car was paid for in less than a week, and the 'Debt Free Dream' is a few steps closer.

In all seriousness, my drive to work is a soul-less experience. I PERSONALLY get more enjoyment from spending the money on other things - but I never sneer at those who like a nice car to drive.

Anyway, thanks for your input. In reality, I'm trying to find a legitimate reason for buying something - when really I should just say "I want it, I can afford it, why not?"

wink