Who'd Swap Their Company Car For A Van.
Who'd Swap Their Company Car For A Van.
Author
Discussion

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Started a new job a couple of months ago where I was given a new Astra (base diesel in doom black)as my company car. Any good? Not as bad as proper Vauxhall haters would have you believe but all in all pretty uninspiring. Within a week of getting the car (2 days to be exact) it crashed. Another surveyor put in in a ditch whilst out on a site visit. I picked up a 62 plate Fiesta Van as a temporary replacement till the Astra was repaired. Whist using the van I discovered three things. One the Fiesta IS an inspiring car to drive (as are most Fords), Two, In modern bright coloured, well designed company livery I think it looks cool (kinda sad considering I'm 47, but hey) and most importantly, Three I hadn't realised that with a car included in the charged of 11p per mile for personal use was my 62 mile daily round commute (£136.40 a month). A charge not incurred with the Fiesta van. Add to that £48 company car tax and my wee Fiesta van is saving me as near as damn £190 a month. I had a quick word with the fleet asking if I could keep it to which I was told "no problem".

I can't use the van for personal use at all, but hey £190 a month can buy or lease me a very nice new or nearly new car so it's all smiles.

Would anyone say "no! sorry. I just couldn't do it. Not a van"

Fubar1977

919 posts

171 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
If you`re happy with it then go for it I say.

I had a Fiesta van for about a month on loan whilst waiting for the dealer to sort a fault on a car I`d bought.
Quite a nice little motor, but I do have a soft spot for Fiesta`s.
£190 a month is a good saving.

jason61c

5,978 posts

205 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Tannedbaldhead said:
Started a new job a couple of months ago where I was given a new Astra (base diesel in doom black)as my company car. Any good? Not as bad as proper Vauxhall haters would have you believe but all in all pretty uninspiring. Within a week of getting the car (2 days to be exact) it crashed. Another surveyor put in in a ditch whilst out on a site visit. I picked up a 62 plate Fiesta Van as a temporary replacement till the Astra was repaired. Whist using the van I discovered three things. One the Fiesta IS an inspiring car to drive (as are most Fords), Two, In modern bright coloured, well designed company livery I think it looks cool (kinda sad considering I'm 47, but hey) and most importantly, Three I hadn't realised that with a car included in the charged of 11p per mile for personal use was my 62 mile daily round commute (£136.40 a month). A charge not incurred with the Fiesta van. Add to that £48 company car tax and my wee Fiesta van is saving me as near as damn £190 a month. I had a quick word with the fleet asking if I could keep it to which I was told "no problem".

I can't use the van for personal use at all, but hey £190 a month can buy or lease me a very nice new or nearly new car so it's all smiles.

Would anyone say "no! sorry. I just couldn't do it. Not a van"
So you save £190, however you'll get a lease car for £190ish, then pay for your commute, fuel, tax and insurance, costing another £250 per month on top? So in effect you're worse off?

BlueMeganeII

338 posts

190 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
By the sound of things he has the van at home too so would commute in it, he's just not covered for personal use.

wolf1

3,103 posts

281 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
jason61c said:
So you save £190, however you'll get a lease car for £190ish, then pay for your commute, fuel, tax and insurance, costing another £250 per month on top? So in effect you're worse off?
I read it as he takes it home so no comute. I use a van for work and take it home, no personal use but that also means no tax to pay and I can run something a touch thirstyer as I don't commute either.

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
wolf1 said:
jason61c said:
So you save £190, however you'll get a lease car for £190ish, then pay for your commute, fuel, tax and insurance, costing another £250 per month on top? So in effect you're worse off?
I read it as he takes it home so no comute. I use a van for work and take it home, no personal use but that also means no tax to pay and I can run something a touch thirstyer as I don't commute either.
You read it right. Do the commute in the van. Think I'd buy secondhand rather than lease. My mileage will be next to nothing so can do silly as far as running costs are concerned. That said, I've already got my old E Class estate and van on my drive along with an MG TF in the garage. What more could a man ask for? (well apart for a newer E Class Estate and an Elise).

V8RX7

28,982 posts

294 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Problem is most of us wouldn't want either a Fiesta van nor an Astra.

It would also depend on your job and home life.

However if the choice was a 200bhp small van or a 100bhp car then I'd choose the van.

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
or run a pickup, same tax deal, vat, etc.


Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
or run a pickup, same tax deal, vat, etc.
I've driven a lot of the popular pickups (work in construction). The Fiesta has the likes of the L200, Ranger and Navara well beaten when it comes to driving pleasure, ride and refinement.

Tannedbaldhead

Original Poster:

3,218 posts

163 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
V8RX7 said:
Problem is most of us wouldn't want either a Fiesta van nor an Astra.
Include me in that group.

The Astra was there when I joined and the Fiesta Van is a convenient (and more importantly free) means of transport to my place of work. In the past (prior to the credit crunch and construction industry slump) I had the pleasure of seeing 3 Series, A4s, C Classes, Passat CCs, Volvos and SAABs on my company car list, now you take what you can get :-(

On the plus side my person mileage is tiny and the money saved by taking the can be spent on something interesting/silly for weekend jaunts.

Mcbeth

225 posts

166 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
If it were me, I'd happily take the van over a boggo hatch and spend the extra cash on something fun.