Porsche Engine Rebuilding
Porsche Engine Rebuilding
Author
Discussion

Sump

Original Poster:

5,512 posts

198 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I've put this in GG instead of the Pork area is so that it gets more of a general view rather than Pork specific.

I was thinking to myself today, what is so specific about rebuilding this engine that it should only go to someone like Hartech/Autofarm etc?

Surely a local well established engine rebuilding firm should be able to do the cylinder liners etc with no problem at a lower cost?

As long as they're established with a good reputation, I can't see why they wouldn't be able to do it. It seems whenever there is a cracked liner report or anything, it's an automatic response for Hart or AF etc. But has anyone actually just had a local company do it?

From what I understand the Porsche indys charge around £5k.

For the record, if there is very specific Porsche stuff involved with this engine that only Porsche Indys can do, then ignore this thread and just delete it hehe


edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
In the same vain why not take your Porsche to a good Kwik Fit for servicing?

You pay for the experience knowing a specialist has been there and done it, will get it right first time, have any specialist or bespoke tools etc.

NicD

3,281 posts

288 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
if its your car and your money you can take it to whoever the hell you like.

tbc

3,017 posts

206 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
All about trust

For some the thought of leaving it with anyone other than a Porker specialist who works at them day in day out is a no brainer

Some will not even consider leaving it with a garage that could be doing a 1.0 Kia one minute and a Porker the next


Sump

Original Poster:

5,512 posts

198 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
edc said:
In the same vain why not take your Porsche to a good Kwik Fit for servicing?

You pay for the experience knowing a specialist has been there and done it, will get it right first time, have any specialist or bespoke tools etc.
An engine rebuilder is a specialist confused

edc

9,695 posts

282 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Sump said:
An engine rebuilder is a specialist confused
The 2 outfits you mention have a track record with those engines. If you read some of the Hartech thread comments he clearly knows some of the foibles of those engines and builds in work around or improvements. With A N other engine builder you are paying them to find these things out along the way or not find them at all. Similarly, you'll find gearbox and auto gearbox specialists. Some other garage could surely do the same job but you would trust one more than another based on reputation or referrals. For the record I've never used those outfits and take my Porsche to Kwik Fit for an oil change.

DanielSan

20,113 posts

198 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
If one day I decided that actually I do like the look of the 911 then I've got a couple of trusted friends who are mechanics, one of which works on a couple from time to time, to be honest I'd get one of those to do it and just tell them to take their time. I trust them to do the job properly regardless of what they work on most. It's all nuts and bolts at the end of the day.

Sump

Original Poster:

5,512 posts

198 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I'm not sure to be honest. I think it's very naive to think that a decent engine rebuilding firm wouldn't know about the Porsche issues that have been going on for the last 15 years or so....

911p

2,361 posts

211 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
Others, many in fact can do it, the point is that the engine is likely to fail again in the same way if preventative measures are not made.

That's where the expertise of people like Hartech come in, making the engine bulletproof so it won't require a further rebuild at some point.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
As others have said you pay for the specialists on those marques who will know all the work around and tricks why save £500 or so when you can be utterly certain. From my own experience even simple engines on other cars like the supercharged motor in the cooper S ive seen enough engine builders make a mess of building them in the wrong manner.