How many drivers are above average?
How many drivers are above average?
Author
Discussion

Dr Jekyll

Original Poster:

23,820 posts

292 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Someone on R4 this morning was saying that 'Most drivers think they are above average but this is impossible'.

Of course for anything other than median average it's perfectly possible. Taking number of accidents as a very rough measure of driving ability, insurance companies must have some tables showing the distribution. If it's a bell shaped curve than only 50% of drivers are above average, but if 20% of drivers cause 80% of the accidents, then 80% of drivers could be above average.

Does anyone know what the distribution actually is?

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Eh?

Average by its very definition is the median of a group.

If that group happens to be, on average, good, then to be above average, you will need to be much, much better...

heebeegeetee

30,259 posts

279 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Dr Jekyll said:
Taking number of accidents as a very rough measure of driving ability,
Which I wouldn't...

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

277 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
Eh?

Average by its very definition is the median of a group.
No it's not. Need some maths revision before resitting that GCSE!



edo

16,699 posts

296 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
Dr Jekyll said:
Taking number of accidents as a very rough measure of driving ability,
Which I wouldn't...
no would I. Not crashing doesnt make you an above average driver (or even average).

Motown Junk

2,041 posts

248 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
mean, median or mode?

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Ozzie Osmond said:
Fidgits said:
Eh?

Average by its very definition is the median of a group.
No it's not. Need some maths revision before resitting that GCSE!
readit

Gcse's, that's what replaced the o levels right winkhehe

My definition may be flawed (I'm not an accountant, sorry), but my point stands.

If you take all the drivers in the uk, and take an average of skill level, now if that skill level is terrible [on average] then the amount of skill needed to be "above average" isn't that high, but if the average skill is actually quite good, then to be above average, you would need to be much much more skilled.

Now, if we were to take the average of the entire worlds driving skill. Then it is fair to say, the majority of uk drivers could be considered above average..

Dr Jekyll

Original Poster:

23,820 posts

292 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
edo said:
no would I. Not crashing doesnt make you an above average driver (or even average).
I did say a very rough measure, and ideally you would allow for mileage and road conditions. But the object of driving is to not crash, so I can't really think of a better measure.

Whether you are looking at mean or modal, the question is the same.

kambites

71,705 posts

252 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
You can't even hope to answer that question without coming up with a linear grading of driving skill.

Dr Jekyll

Original Poster:

23,820 posts

292 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
readit

Gcse's, that's what replaced the o levels right winkhehe

My definition may be flawed (I'm not an accountant, sorry), but my point stands.
Would you accept that most drivers have an above average number of eyes?

Fidgits

17,202 posts

260 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Dr Jekyll said:
Would you accept that most drivers have an above average number of eyes?
Not at all.

Assuming most drivers will have 2 eyes, I would say the average number of eyes a driver has is 2... Therefore, unless you have 3 eyes, you won't have above average number of eyes...

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
Eh?

Average by its very definition is the median of a group.
"Average" normally refers to the mean, not the median.

MiseryStreak

2,929 posts

238 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Above average what?

If it's a driver's ability to not be involved in an accident then it will be a normal distribution, like most things. Therefore average (which when undefined is usually taken to be the mean) would be right in the centre of the distribution with 50% either side. So most drivers cannot be above average, and in fact the large majority are less than 1 standard deviation away so could only be described as average.

Krikkit

27,942 posts

212 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
readit

Gcse's, that's what replaced the o levels right winkhehe

My definition may be flawed (I'm not an accountant, sorry), but my point stands.

If you take all the drivers in the uk, and take an average of skill level, now if that skill level is terrible [on average] then the amount of skill needed to be "above average" isn't that high, but if the average skill is actually quite good, then to be above average, you would need to be much much more skilled.
You're talking about taking the mean, not the median.

Take these numbers: 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 7, 8, 9.
The mean is 5.375 (sum them, divide by 8), the mode is 7 (the most common), the median is 6 (the centre of the sequence). Three very different results from the three simplest "averages", but which one is best? Complex question.

As Misery alludes to above, for a normal distribution of drivers there will be an equal split who are above and below average, gradually tailing off with skill as you go further away from the average (either very good or very bad drivers).

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Statistics aren't helping - as 88.2% of people are below average at them smile

Why don't we define a level of competence in driving, let's call it the PH standard, which most residents here think is acceptable.

Now I suspect this is quite a bit higher than the majority of "I drive to get from A to B and don't give a stuff about how" types.

I'd be surprised if 20% of drivers met the PH standard.


BOBTEE

1,034 posts

195 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
Not at all.

Assuming most drivers will have 2 eyes, I would say the average number of eyes a driver has is 2... Therefore, unless you have 3 eyes, you won't have above average number of eyes...
My friend drives, he has one eye. I don't know anyone with three eyes therefore the average number of eyes per driver is less than two. I have two eyes, I'm above average. smile

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Motown Junk said:
mean, median or mode?
Indeed

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
Not at all.

Assuming most drivers will have 2 eyes, I would say the average number of eyes a driver has is 2... Therefore, unless you have 3 eyes, you won't have above average number of eyes...
Most drivers have an above mean average of eyes, arms and legs.

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Fidgits said:
Dr Jekyll said:
Would you accept that most drivers have an above average number of eyes?
Not at all.

Assuming most drivers will have 2 eyes, I would say the average number of eyes a driver has is 2... Therefore, unless you have 3 eyes, you won't have above average number of eyes...
Correction - 88.3% of people don't understand statistics...

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Dr Jekyll said:
Someone on R4 this morning was saying that 'Most drivers think they are above average but this is impossible'.
Dunning kruger Effect

Not only possible but inevitable. Part of incompetance is the lack of ability to correctly judge competance.

If you take away the people who think they are above average in driving skill, and the people who are above average in driving skill you'll have almost no one left.