A3 as a second car? Or a normal 'boy racery' hatch?
A3 as a second car? Or a normal 'boy racery' hatch?
Author
Discussion

Grimezy93

Original Poster:

164 posts

162 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi,

I'm 20 and have been driving for just over 2 years now in a 1.2 8v Punto. It's fairly nippy for my needs but I've been on the look out for something more exciting for what seems like an age. My insurance is finally affordable on 'Hot hatches' so my options have opened up a bit more.

The thing is, I've always liked Audi's as my dads owned them for years and I really like the A3's understatement and build quality compared to similar hatches. I appreciate that they're not as thrilling or nippy as something like a Civic Type-r because of the weight, etc but it would surely be a decent improvement from my Punto regardless of that? I can afford to insure the 2.0 FSI sport or even the 3.2 V6 Quattro Sport at a push if it's worth the improvement over the 2ltr...

So my question is, are they decent all-round cars or would I be wasting my money on something that's below-par? I'd be looking at an 03-05 model in my budget (around the £5k mark at the moment). My daily uses are only a 5 mile each way commute to work down country lanes (hence why I want something a bit more thrilling) but I also make regular weekly/fortnightly trips up and down the motorway to visit friends so want something sturdy for that as well.

If A3's don't sound like they're for me, please feel free to suggest others. I've looked at Fiesta ST's although they sound a bit frantic and unrefined on long trips, I've looked at Civic Type-r's which I've heard need to be worked hard to feel the full effects, Cupra's which seem ok but some people question Seat build quality... Fabia vRS's which seem expensive for what they are but I've heard they're worthwhile and solid, and Cooper S JCW's which seem to be quick and fun to drive but have the negative gender image associated to them... The problem with a lot of these hatches is they seem to be very boy racery and give a negative image to the large part of society and it can be difficult finding decent examples that haven't been abused. Ideally I'm the kind of person who just wants a subtly styled car with a grunty engine powering it.

Any thoughts would be much appreciated.

pti

1,866 posts

175 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
e46 330Ci?

Not as thrilling to drive as a hot hatch but can still be hustled along quite nicely. Excellent on the motorway and way better on fuel than the Audi V6 lump. You'll get a decent facelifted M Sport within budget as well I'd imagine.

ETA - Cheaper to insure than hot hatches as well (IME)

Jonny_

4,729 posts

238 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Quite like the idea of a well-specced A3 3.2 V6 as a comfy, lazy mini-barge.

Would have to be the auto/DSG, and with sensibly sized wheels and standard suspension (as opposed to the usual 19's and S-Line combination that will rattle your fillings loose!). Ideally in Audi Resale Silver or similar nondescript colour to maximise subtlety smile

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
2.0 fsi is no good so I'd suggest counting that one out. Its very thirsty and not really that quick. The TFSIs are the best 4-cyl petrols. I haven't tried the 3.2 V6 but I've always admired them and they seem to offer great value on the used market. Essentially a Golf Mk5 R32 underneath driving

Grimezy93

Original Poster:

164 posts

162 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
pti said:
e46 330Ci?

Not as thrilling to drive as a hot hatch but can still be hustled along quite nicely. Excellent on the motorway and way better on fuel than the Audi V6 lump. You'll get a decent facelifted M Sport within budget as well I'd imagine.

ETA - Cheaper to insure than hot hatches as well (IME)
I might check out the e46 330Ci... My only issue being that we get really bad rain and snow where I am and the country lanes flood pretty easy or get pretty slippy even for FWD cars. People with Beamer's at work just don't bother coming in at the slightest sign of snow..

I haven't really driven in the snow in my Punto anyway as it's not worth the risk on my insurance at my age but what would the beamer be like in rain/lots of surface water? Would I struggle? Could that be all the more reason to go for the V6 lump for the 4wd aspect of it?

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

239 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Civic type R. Even out of Vtec it will be much quicker than your Punto and will be much more fun when you want to have a hoon. Very reliable too.

McWigglebum4th

32,414 posts

235 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
Hi,

I'm 20 and have been driving for just over 2 years now in a 1.2 8v Punto. It's fairly nippy for my needs but I've been on the look out for something more exciting for what seems like an age. My insurance is finally affordable on 'Hot hatches' so my options have opened up a bit more.

The thing is, I've always liked Audi's
They do say the first step in solving a problem is admitting you have a problem.

Thats a brave thing to say it in public


We're with you brother.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
Hi,

I'm 20 and have been driving for just over 2 years now in a 1.2 8v Punto. It's fairly nippy for my needs but I've been on the look out for something more exciting for what seems like an age. My insurance is finally affordable on 'Hot hatches' so my options have opened up a bit more.

The thing is, I've always liked Audi's as my dads owned them for years and I really like the A3's understatement and build quality compared to similar hatches. I appreciate that they're not as thrilling or nippy as something like a Civic Type-r because of the weight, etc but it would surely be a decent improvement from my Punto regardless of that? I can afford to insure the 2.0 FSI sport or even the 3.2 V6 Quattro Sport at a push if it's worth the improvement over the 2ltr...

So my question is, are they decent all-round cars or would I be wasting my money on something that's below-par? I'd be looking at an 03-05 model in my budget (around the £5k mark at the moment). My daily uses are only a 5 mile each way commute to work down country lanes (hence why I want something a bit more thrilling) but I also make regular weekly/fortnightly trips up and down the motorway to visit friends so want something sturdy for that as well.

If A3's don't sound like they're for me, please feel free to suggest others. I've looked at Fiesta ST's although they sound a bit frantic and unrefined on long trips, I've looked at Civic Type-r's which I've heard need to be worked hard to feel the full effects, Cupra's which seem ok but some people question Seat build quality... Fabia vRS's which seem expensive for what they are but I've heard they're worthwhile and solid, and Cooper S JCW's which seem to be quick and fun to drive but have the negative gender image associated to them... The problem with a lot of these hatches is they seem to be very boy racery and give a negative image to the large part of society and it can be difficult finding decent examples that haven't been abused. Ideally I'm the kind of person who just wants a subtly styled car with a grunty engine powering it.

Any thoughts would be much appreciated.
Buy a classic TVR or Lotus or some other kind of sports car. Lots more fun, much better residuals and won't look as gay as an A3 tongue out

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
pti said:
e46 330Ci?

Not as thrilling to drive as a hot hatch but can still be hustled along quite nicely. Excellent on the motorway and way better on fuel than the Audi V6 lump. You'll get a decent facelifted M Sport within budget as well I'd imagine.

ETA - Cheaper to insure than hot hatches as well (IME)
I might check out the e46 330Ci... My only issue being that we get really bad rain and snow where I am and the country lanes flood pretty easy or get pretty slippy even for FWD cars. People with Beamer's at work just don't bother coming in at the slightest sign of snow..

I haven't really driven in the snow in my Punto anyway as it's not worth the risk on my insurance at my age but what would the beamer be like in rain/lots of surface water? Would I struggle? Could that be all the more reason to go for the V6 lump for the 4wd aspect of it?
I do my winter commuting in an Elise. Last year I also had an MX5. This year I've got an E36 323. I suspect the 3-series will be better than the Elise, which has never got stuck.

I managed 7 years commuting in an MR2 without any snow related drama.

I've never had any car that couldn't cope with a bit of water, as long as the tyres weren't badly worn or cut slicks.

Winter tyres make a huge difference in how much grip you have to play with. I'm a big fan, although I've never actually got stuck in snow even on summer tyres (your winters may vary).

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
My only issue being that we get really bad rain and snow where I am it?
WTF..


rofl

Your profile says Worcester. Not exactly what I'd call challenging terrain.


excel monkey

4,825 posts

258 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
The problem with a lot of these hatches is they seem to be very boy racery and give a negative image to the large part of society and it can be difficult finding decent examples that haven't been abused. Ideally I'm the kind of person who just wants a subtly styled car with a grunty engine powering it.
Normally it's 300bhp/ton who leads the "anti hatchback" crusade, but based on what you've said, a saloon or coupe might suit you better.

BMW E46 3-series - loads to choose from, good six cylinder engines.
Lexus IS - very subtle looks (to the point of blandness), decent engines, but not very sporty.
Volvo C30/S40 T5 - plenty of power, discreet looks.

Grimezy93

Original Poster:

164 posts

162 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
WTF..


rofl

Your profile says Worcester. Not exactly what I'd call challenging terrain.
I'm sorry, I forgot my profile shows my exact address and my route to work.. Because there definitely aren't any hilly environments around Worcester... Say I don't know, Malvern? And Malvern definitely isn't full of farmer's fields and roads that I have to commute down where all the water runs directly off the fields and into the roads causing them to flood whenever we have rain... Or have roads that aren't on the gritting routes when it does snow heavily around here...

But no, how could you possibly think I live anywhere else but slap-bang in the middle of Worcester City Centre where it's nice and flat. My mistake... I should put so much more information on my profile for strangers to see.

HurricaneABC

17 posts

159 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Golf mk2 gti or maybe a 206 gti - something a little different

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

296 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
HurricaneABC said:
Golf mk2 gti or maybe a 2065 gti - something a little different
Edited for more fun.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Grimezy93 said:
300bhp/ton said:
WTF..


rofl

Your profile says Worcester. Not exactly what I'd call challenging terrain.
I'm sorry, I forgot my profile shows my exact address and my route to work.. Because there definitely aren't any hilly environments around Worcester... Say I don't know, Malvern? And Malvern definitely isn't full of farmer's fields and roads that I have to commute down where all the water runs directly off the fields and into the roads causing them to flood whenever we have rain... Or have roads that aren't on the gritting routes when it does snow heavily around here...

But no, how could you possibly think I live anywhere else but slap-bang in the middle of Worcester City Centre where it's nice and flat. My mistake... I should put so much more information on my profile for strangers to see.
Because anywhere at least within 50 miles of Worcester is no worse than almost anywhere in the entire UK during winter. And many tens of thousands of drivers manage perfectly ok for 99.99% of the time.

Yes there will be exceptions, but that is why they are not the norm.

As for Malvern, yes know it, there's a rather famous British sports car manufacturer there (well Link wink ), I suspect the manage perfectly fine in the depths of winter though. biggrin

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
If you prioritise b-road hooming, there are better cars. If you prioritise long distance refinement, there are better cars etc etc.

But if you want a nice looking hatchback which is well screwed together, jack of all trades master of none, then an Audi A3 is not a bad car to consider.

Grimezy93

Original Poster:

164 posts

162 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
HurricaneABC said:
Golf mk2 gti or maybe a 206 gti - something a little different
Thanks for the suggestions. Do you not think they may be a bit too small for motorway slogs though? Like it wouldn't really feel like a step up from my Punto as it would still be like being in a tin can? I appreciate they would be 10x better than my Punto down country lanes and probably better than the A3 for handling but I'd be concerned about their overall performance on a longer slog...

HurricaneABC

17 posts

159 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Captain Muppet said:
Edited for more fun.
Ahh yeah forgot about that one!

Grimezy93

Original Poster:

164 posts

162 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
300bhp/ton said:
Because anywhere at least within 50 miles of Worcester is no worse than almost anywhere in the entire UK during winter. And many tens of thousands of drivers manage perfectly ok for 99.99% of the time.

Yes there will be exceptions, but that is why they are not the norm.

As for Malvern, yes know it, there's a rather famous British sports car manufacturer there (well Link wink ), I suspect the manage perfectly fine in the depths of winter though. biggrin
Again... my route to work isn't in Malvern town... Don't think you're quite grasping the country lanes in the middle of nowhere concept are you?

Edit: And if you're referring to Morgan believe it or not they're not a common sight cruising around Malvern, much more likely to be tucked up in their old man's garages never to see the light of day again except on the very specialist of occasions.

Edited by Grimezy93 on Monday 19th August 17:01

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
OP, maybe if you rank your priorities?