Advice please...interesting situation
Advice please...interesting situation
Author
Discussion

rodtheknob

Original Poster:

30 posts

187 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Hi...need some advice please. Purchased an Alfa GT 25,000 miles(JTS)at the start of the year...developed a knock in bottom end quickly after I purchased it....paid for a fully rebuilt engine to be installed which came with a 12 month warranty.

New engine installed...started to use a good bit of oil(smelt like burning oil also)Ran for over a 1000 miles monitoring the oil level. Then the catalytic converter gave up the ghost.

Replaced the cat (expensive)and a week later still was not very happy with the engine as the Engine management light was coming on and still using way too much oil. Smoking bad on start up and running badly.

Engine is covered under warranty so the garage are putting "another" engine into the car to replace my "faulty" one.

Question here is could the fact that the new engine was using vast amounts of oil have damaged my catalytic converter?

(just to add the car was MOT'd the day before it had the engine installed and passed emissions test.

stevesingo

5,048 posts

253 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Almost certainly if it was leaving a trail of blue smoke.

rodtheknob

Original Poster:

30 posts

187 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
I am confident this is the case also however tricky one to dispute with garage....eg should I have paid for the cat??

Pistom

6,433 posts

190 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Getting into dispute over stuff like this can be costly and time consuming.

I would give up now, cut my losses and move on.

A smokey engine will fk up a cat.

VolvoT5

4,155 posts

205 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
IMO it was probably the duff engine that has knackered your CAT. Good luck in getting the garage to pay for it though.

rodtheknob

Original Poster:

30 posts

187 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
thanks for the advice. You have confirmed my suspicions. Worth following up with the garage though as if he has fitted a component to the car that is faulty (engine) that has caused another component to fail (cat) as a result surely its worth disputing?

Benbay001

5,895 posts

188 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
rodtheknob said:
thanks for the advice. You have confirmed my suspicions. Worth following up with the garage though as if he has fitted a component to the car that is faulty (engine) that has caused another component to fail (cat) as a result surely its worth disputing?
Id just be content with them replacing the engine under warranty. Sometimes car breakages need to be penciled up as experience or part of ownership. Even if they were caused by someone else.

KTF

10,721 posts

181 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Nothing to lose by asking them I guess.

But the engine failing at 25k makes my wallet hurt just thinking about it. How old is the car?

rodtheknob

Original Poster:

30 posts

187 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
Benbay001 said:
Id just be content with them replacing the engine under warranty. Sometimes car breakages need to be penciled up as experience or part of ownership. Even if they were caused by someone else.
Perhaps yes. Hard to stomach the price of a cat...when I say expensive we are talking shed of the week money....after paying for a new rebuilt engine a couple of months earlier, leaves a sour taste in the mouth

rodtheknob

Original Poster:

30 posts

187 months

Monday 19th August 2013
quotequote all
KTF said:
Nothing to lose by asking them I guess.

But the engine failing at 25k makes my wallet hurt just thinking about it. How old is the car?
car is 2006...25k miles full service history also