Vintage Watches with "Patina"
Discussion
I stumbled upon this article on the Hodinkee watch blog eulogising the pleasing effects of "patina" on a watch:
http://www.hodinkee.com/blog/2010/6/11/letters-fro...
I find it interesting - I do tend to agree that a nice, aged vintage watch is more appealing than one which has been restored to squeaky clean, as-new condition. However, I guess there's a line between "patina" and "beaten up old watch".
It would be interesting to gauge reactions on here re: patina. Do we like, and does it add value legitimately to a watch? I've seen Rolexes pushed higher and higher in value by hundreds of pounds due to a "tropical dial" or a "ghost bezel" - passing fad or an emerging, more discerning trend?
http://www.hodinkee.com/blog/2010/6/11/letters-fro...
I find it interesting - I do tend to agree that a nice, aged vintage watch is more appealing than one which has been restored to squeaky clean, as-new condition. However, I guess there's a line between "patina" and "beaten up old watch".
It would be interesting to gauge reactions on here re: patina. Do we like, and does it add value legitimately to a watch? I've seen Rolexes pushed higher and higher in value by hundreds of pounds due to a "tropical dial" or a "ghost bezel" - passing fad or an emerging, more discerning trend?
I think that misses the point somewhat. It's nothing to do with X or Y fading nor a watch looking as old as it is but the way a watch has been worn during adventure and gained markings because of that adventure. For the owner, it would remind them of great times.
The author has overlooked the scratches on the bezel and the damaged pip, for instance.
The author has overlooked the scratches on the bezel and the damaged pip, for instance.
I do not agree.
Faded lume is OK. In fact faded lume is goodness. But not because it looks nice. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind it at all. I'm just indifferent to the exact colour of the lume.
What faded lume does for me is add another clue. It helps me establish whether or not I'm looking at a watch with an original dial.
But that's not patina. Patina is discolouration of the face with age. I don't mind a little, but I try to buy vintage watches without it.
For me the joy of collecting these vintage pieces is in knowing that they are in exceptional condition for their age. Dials with nasty age spots or dials that are massively discoloured do nothing for me. The watches no longer look how they were designed to look. They don't look smart or tidy on the wrist.
I genuinely don't understand the appeal of heavily aged watches with blotchy dials and corroded or brassed cases. But I'm glad that they do appeal to some people as it means less competition for the much rarer "as new" pieces!
Faded lume is OK. In fact faded lume is goodness. But not because it looks nice. Don't get me wrong, I don't mind it at all. I'm just indifferent to the exact colour of the lume.
What faded lume does for me is add another clue. It helps me establish whether or not I'm looking at a watch with an original dial.
But that's not patina. Patina is discolouration of the face with age. I don't mind a little, but I try to buy vintage watches without it.
For me the joy of collecting these vintage pieces is in knowing that they are in exceptional condition for their age. Dials with nasty age spots or dials that are massively discoloured do nothing for me. The watches no longer look how they were designed to look. They don't look smart or tidy on the wrist.
I genuinely don't understand the appeal of heavily aged watches with blotchy dials and corroded or brassed cases. But I'm glad that they do appeal to some people as it means less competition for the much rarer "as new" pieces!

Gassing Station | Watches | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


