Guardian: Bad driving: what are we thinking?
Guardian: Bad driving: what are we thinking?
Author
Discussion

Chimune

Original Poster:

4,370 posts

254 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Here are 10 of the most interesting psychological biases and errors we face when behind the wheel:

1. We fail to realise when we're being aggressive – or we don't care
2. We believe we're safer than we really are
3. We forget that other drivers are people too …
4. … yet we behave more aggressively to those of 'lower status'
5. We believe we can see everything happening around us …
6. … yet we also think other drivers can't see us
7. We attribute near misses to a lack of ability in other drivers …
8. … while at the same time overestimating our own skills
9. We drive more recklessly when we're going solo
10. We believe hands-free car phones are safe.

article here.

All sounds quite sensible, but im sure PH has some thoughts !

Kentish

15,169 posts

265 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Sounds quite a fair summation to me!

pti

1,866 posts

175 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Kentish said:
Sounds quite a fair summation to me!
Yup.

Krikkit

27,942 posts

212 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
All sensible - recognising those faults in your own driving is a key step toward improving yourself. At the moment I'm working hard on rearward observation - I've got used to never being overtaken by another car, so my skills are neglected.

Harry Flashman

21,977 posts

273 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Sounds pretty accurate to me.

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
I don't get it.

The world is full of people who admit to being cr*p at maths. Or at spelling. Or who'll happily admit to being out of shape or unable to cook. There are many, many things for which people in general will public announce ineptitude.

But driving - why do very few people admit to being bad at that? I think on Pistonheads we should change this. Here and now, let's announce our bad habits. Let's admit to where we could improve. Let's embrace the fact that no driver is perfect.

I'll start:

I sometimes look at the wrong traffic lights on roundabouts. I have failed to observe red lights until quite late when paying attention to something else. I don't take in every road sign I see. Generally, my passive observation of stationary objects could be improved. And I'm working on it.












mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
motorhole said:
I don't get it.

The world is full of people who admit to being cr*p at maths. Or at spelling. Or who'll happily admit to being out of shape or unable to cook. There are many, many things for which people in general will public announce ineptitude.

But driving - why do very few people admit to being bad at that?
Because with Maths, Spelling etc it's very easy to define what's good performance vs. what's bad performance and these definitions are well accepted. I.e. if you get the right answer to a maths problem, or spell a word correctly, etc.

However with driving there's many more factors which mean people can't judge their own performance, and also are using difference definitions of 'good'.

E.g. a boy racer may prioritise journey times/progressiveness vs. fuel consumption/cautiousness. But a little old lady may have exactly the opposite priorities. They are both "good" by their own definitions, but the problem is they have different definitions to start with.

Another reason people can't recognise their own failings is because unlike spelling (where you get a word wrong) or maths (where you get the answer wrong) it's quite possible to be fairly 'bad' at driving and still not suffer any significant adverse consequences for a long time. (i.e. you can be a bit crap, but still manage not to crash for a while.) So this leads people to reinforce the belief that if they do 'what they want' and don't crash, then they must be a 'good driver'.

So I don't agree with your implication that most people should know they are bad drivers and are somehow shamed into not admiting it. Instead I think the problem is that i) people truly believe they are not bad drivers bcause they dont' crash, and ii) people are actually right that they are 'good drivers' but only when judged against their own criteria (speed/progression/caution/fuel etc).

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
motorhole said:
The world is full of people who admit to being cr*p at maths.
There's no excuse for being crap at maths and it shouldn't be socially acceptable to admit as much.


Atrevetetete

320 posts

161 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
There's no excuse for being crap at maths and it shouldn't be socially acceptable to admit as much.
99% of Maths is irrelevant to day to day life for most people. 

The 1% of Maths that's relevant is vital (e.g. basic numeracy and sums) but unless you work in something using more complex Mathematics chances are you won't need more.

motorhole

692 posts

251 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
So I don't agree with your implication that most people should know they are bad drivers and are somehow shamed into not admiting it. Instead I think the problem is that i) people truly believe they are not bad drivers bcause they dont' crash, and ii) people are actually right that they are 'good drivers' but only when judged against their own criteria (speed/progression/caution/fuel etc).
That's a very fair point. Although to be said, the same could be argued with cooking to an extent (I don't poison myself, therefore I'm okay at cooking). Nevertheless there are common exceptions. I suppose innocent ignorance is also common though - tailgater not realising the danger they are putting themselves in, middle lane sitters who don't know better, those baffled by indicating on roundabouts so they don't bother etc. You're right, makes it difficult to self-judge.

Devil2575 said:
There's no excuse for being crap at maths and it shouldn't be socially acceptable to admit as much.
I agree completely - I never suggested that it was socially acceptable, just that it's common smile It irks me when people say they don't understand fractions or percentages. Surely that should be covered by basic numeracy? One of my personal irritations was when writing reports for safety case authors in a company I worked for some time ago, we were instructed to write numbers in decimal notation because scientific notation was "hard to understand".

Safety case authors ffs!

GadgeS3C

4,727 posts

195 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Atrevetetete said:
Devil2575 said:
There's no excuse for being crap at maths and it shouldn't be socially acceptable to admit as much.
99% of Maths is irrelevant to day to day life for most people. 

The 1% of Maths that's relevant is vital (e.g. basic numeracy and sums) but unless you work in something using more complex Mathematics chances are you won't need more.
Can we agree that 99% of people are crap at the 1% of maths that matters to them wink

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Atrevetetete said:
99% of Maths is irrelevant to day to day life for most people. 

The 1% of Maths that's relevant is vital (e.g. basic numeracy and sums) but unless you work in something using more complex Mathematics chances are you won't need more.
Really?

I think it's because people have this view that it is socially acceptable.

It's completely incorrect though.

However people who admit to being crap at maths frequently can't even cope with the basic numeracy stuff.

santona1937

878 posts

161 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Really?

I think it's because people have this view that it is socially acceptable.

It's completely incorrect though.

However people who admit to being crap at maths frequently can't even cope with the basic numeracy stuff.
If one is any sort of work that is more than just being a warm body basic numeracy includes fractions, percentages and ratios on a regular basis.
The number of people I meet for whom even these basics are complex never fails to astound . More to the point, the number of people for whom high speed is the definition of good driving seems to be on the increase. A high number of my acquaintances seem to view horsepower, top speed and 0-60 times as the definition of a good car without regard to torque, driveability, etc. etc.



8potdave

2,810 posts

244 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
I would say that is quite accurate. It is true that people think they are better than they are.

Take my mother in law for example, she is a particular poor driver with the worst observational skills I've ever seen! (Hope she hasn't recently joined PH). I've been in a car with her before when she has stopped at a roundabout for no reason and when questioned she says "you can't be too safe". I explained it's potentially dangerous and she couldn't see why. Then she will pull straight out of a junction in front of someone, get beeped at and say "they were going too fast". So everything is someone elses fault.

Of course she is a MLM and again says that everyone else drives too quickly and shouldn't need to overtake her. I normally get out of the car with raised blood pressure, but her attitude is probably applicable to a large number of motorists and it's blatant in their driving style. My main letdown is that I am too impatient and can be considered aggressive on occasion (being honest). However I would say I have good observational skills and am confident in most situations. I know my faults but sadly not many people will admit to theirs!

CrutyRammers

13,735 posts

229 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Good article, but as always with these things, will be ignored by those who most need to read and digest it.

Atrevetetete

320 posts

161 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
Devil2575 said:
Really?

I think it's because people have this view that it is socially acceptable.

It's completely incorrect though.

However people who admit to being crap at maths frequently can't even cope with the basic numeracy stuff.
Yes really, what Maths does Tina from Guildford need apart from the basic numeracy to work out her shopping and day to bits like that?

Maybe not 99% but apart from basic numeracy based stuff, a few averages and percentages, what more do most folk need?

I agree with the principle that people are far too casual to say they're bad at it but that's just how it is. You spend ages studying at school and forget most of it, that's how most people think of Maths.

kambites

71,703 posts

252 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
I don't understand more than 1% of maths, and I'm a maths graduate... it's a big subject. hehe

HTP99

25,430 posts

171 months

Tuesday 20th August 2013
quotequote all
8potdave said:
I've been in a car with her before when she has stopped at a roundabout for no reason and when questioned she says "you can't be too safe".
Recently I went on a test drive with a couple who, I would say, were well into their 60's, poss early 70's, both of them stopped at roundabouts no matter if they were empty or not. Without me asking she remarked to me how the rules of using a roundabout had changed since her day of learning, apparently when both of them were learning to drive you had to stop at a roundabout even if clear and she had never been able to shake that part of driving off.