Mercedes Dealership Problem
Discussion
Hi All,
Having a problem with a Mercedes dealership, just wondering where I go from here.
I bought a used C-Class on the 4th June and subsequently found there was a problem with the clutch. An odd one, when the car has been driven for a reasonable length of time the clutch pedal gets very stiff and doesn't spring back from the floor as it should. It went in to replace the master cylinder under warranty which unfortunately didn't fix the problem, the garage advised that to do any further investigation would require a strip down of the clutch and if it was found to be worn, the warranty wouldn't cover the work.
This is fine, I realise no warranty company covers clutches, my issue is they shouldn't have sold me a car with a duff clutch, and if it is worn they should stump up for a new one. Sale of Goods Act would back me up, I've spoken to a legal helpline who agreed with me and the Citizens Advice website even mentions a worn clutch as being an example of when you are entitled for a car dealer to make it right. Car is a 59 plate costing £15k with approx 42k miles so it's not like it's a £1k snotter.
The dealership has offered 50% of the cost of the repair and clutch if it is deemed to be at fault. My issue is if I get the diagnostics done and the clutch is worn this leaves me with 50% of a big bill. Merc UK have washed their hands and said they can't obligate the dealer to alter their offer. Is the next stage to get the work done and face a slog through the small claims court, or is there a better way?
Of course this could all be moot if the clutch doesn't turn out to be worn and the warranty company cough up.
Mod edit, no name and shaming please
Having a problem with a Mercedes dealership, just wondering where I go from here.
I bought a used C-Class on the 4th June and subsequently found there was a problem with the clutch. An odd one, when the car has been driven for a reasonable length of time the clutch pedal gets very stiff and doesn't spring back from the floor as it should. It went in to replace the master cylinder under warranty which unfortunately didn't fix the problem, the garage advised that to do any further investigation would require a strip down of the clutch and if it was found to be worn, the warranty wouldn't cover the work.
This is fine, I realise no warranty company covers clutches, my issue is they shouldn't have sold me a car with a duff clutch, and if it is worn they should stump up for a new one. Sale of Goods Act would back me up, I've spoken to a legal helpline who agreed with me and the Citizens Advice website even mentions a worn clutch as being an example of when you are entitled for a car dealer to make it right. Car is a 59 plate costing £15k with approx 42k miles so it's not like it's a £1k snotter.
The dealership has offered 50% of the cost of the repair and clutch if it is deemed to be at fault. My issue is if I get the diagnostics done and the clutch is worn this leaves me with 50% of a big bill. Merc UK have washed their hands and said they can't obligate the dealer to alter their offer. Is the next stage to get the work done and face a slog through the small claims court, or is there a better way?
Of course this could all be moot if the clutch doesn't turn out to be worn and the warranty company cough up.
Mod edit, no name and shaming please
Edited by Matt172 on Wednesday 21st August 20:17
Think I would pick a busy time for the Showroom (say Saturday mid morning) and have a conversation (you speak loudly don't you?) with the Sales Team, making sure you don't lose your temper, but stating the facts as you see it so others can hear, and refuse to leave or go into one of those little private rooms until it's is sorted out.
There is a good chance they will fall over themselves to be helpful, if they know that other visitors are earwigging!
There is a good chance they will fall over themselves to be helpful, if they know that other visitors are earwigging!

I've had the car since the 4th June and put probably 3000 miles on it now. It had its first diagnosis visit to Mercedes on the 28th June, I reported the fault a few days before that, as the first thing I did on getting the car was to drive to Gatwick and go on holiday for 2 weeks. Car would have done a maximum of 1000 miles til I reported the fault.
The problem has been there since I've owned the car, it only becomes apparent after say 30 minutes of driving so it was probably missed in the dealer checks.
I would go into the dealership arms windmilling, I've thought about rejecting the car but I really don't want to go down that route, apart from leaving myself car-less it took ages to find the spec I was after.
The problem has been there since I've owned the car, it only becomes apparent after say 30 minutes of driving so it was probably missed in the dealer checks.
I would go into the dealership arms windmilling, I've thought about rejecting the car but I really don't want to go down that route, apart from leaving myself car-less it took ages to find the spec I was after.
Edited by Matt172 on Thursday 22 August 06:17
I don't normally reply to these threads, as I'm not a legal expert. But my experience in this area would suggest:
-- Forget about rejecting the car. I know you don't want to, but it's just not an option at the moment. The dealer won't go for it, and they have every right to try and fix it before they have to.
-- As a 59 plate, it is out of the original warranty, and will be something 3rd party, with Mercedes branding. They will want to reduce costs as much as possible, so will claim it was a pre-existing fault and don't have to pay.
-- This means that if the garage went ahead and did the work, they will almost certainly end up saying it was wear, and want to do a 50/50 deal with you - the cheapest option for them.
As they have at least admitted it is faulty (not always straightforward!!!), I think pursuing the SOGA from the off, possibly with help from Citizens Advice Bureau, will probably be the easiest and least stressful option.
If you have sound, trustworthy, preferably written, legal advice already, you could mention it to the dealer as a final opportunity for them.
-- Forget about rejecting the car. I know you don't want to, but it's just not an option at the moment. The dealer won't go for it, and they have every right to try and fix it before they have to.
-- As a 59 plate, it is out of the original warranty, and will be something 3rd party, with Mercedes branding. They will want to reduce costs as much as possible, so will claim it was a pre-existing fault and don't have to pay.
-- This means that if the garage went ahead and did the work, they will almost certainly end up saying it was wear, and want to do a 50/50 deal with you - the cheapest option for them.
As they have at least admitted it is faulty (not always straightforward!!!), I think pursuing the SOGA from the off, possibly with help from Citizens Advice Bureau, will probably be the easiest and least stressful option.
If you have sound, trustworthy, preferably written, legal advice already, you could mention it to the dealer as a final opportunity for them.
The warranty is through Mondial. They paid up no problem for the master cylinder but I don't expect them to if the clutch is worn. The situation you describe is what I want to avoid, car goes in for diagnosis and I get left with 50% of the bill to get my car back.
My "legal advice" is a helpline I get with my bank account, but they advise the next step is a "letter before action". The dealership stopped returning my calls and won't speak to me after they made their initial 50% offer. I complained to Merc UK about this, nothing happened.
My "legal advice" is a helpline I get with my bank account, but they advise the next step is a "letter before action". The dealership stopped returning my calls and won't speak to me after they made their initial 50% offer. I complained to Merc UK about this, nothing happened.
Why not get a quote for a new clutch from them at reduced labour rates and parts at cost and go 50-50?
At least the problems sorted and you'll have a new clutch that will last for a good while.
You've already mentioned that the problem was hard to trace/diagnose so the dealer isn't really at fault.
At least the problems sorted and you'll have a new clutch that will last for a good while.
You've already mentioned that the problem was hard to trace/diagnose so the dealer isn't really at fault.
Sorry, but I think you are being a bit unreasonable.
Clutches wear down, it's a fact.... just like brake shoes and tyres, it isn't as though the car has only done 10,000 miles.
Replacement clutches for a "C" class can't be THAT expensive, especially if you are only paying 50%.
Hope you get it sorted anyhow....The "C" class is a fine car.
Clutches wear down, it's a fact.... just like brake shoes and tyres, it isn't as though the car has only done 10,000 miles.
Replacement clutches for a "C" class can't be THAT expensive, especially if you are only paying 50%.
Hope you get it sorted anyhow....The "C" class is a fine car.
It's very disappointing when they resort to "brick wall" behavior - I've been in situations like this before, but fortunately dialogue never broke down, and all was resolved.
I think the final letter, giving them one mor opportunity, is a good next option. I believe the law is with you, and there are processes in place to allow you to pursue action easily - hopefully the dealer knows this and will choose to fix the fault before it gets that far. (Of course - give them a reasonable deadline in the letter so they don't just continue the silence approach).
Oh - and I don't think it is at all fair to pay in this repair - the garage shouldn't have sold a faulty car. No, the failure does not smack you in the face as soon as you drive off. But if the dealer chooses not to test cars when they are fully warmed through to save time/costs, then they have to accept the risk and the occasional expenditure when this practice fails to protect the customer.
I think the final letter, giving them one mor opportunity, is a good next option. I believe the law is with you, and there are processes in place to allow you to pursue action easily - hopefully the dealer knows this and will choose to fix the fault before it gets that far. (Of course - give them a reasonable deadline in the letter so they don't just continue the silence approach).
Oh - and I don't think it is at all fair to pay in this repair - the garage shouldn't have sold a faulty car. No, the failure does not smack you in the face as soon as you drive off. But if the dealer chooses not to test cars when they are fully warmed through to save time/costs, then they have to accept the risk and the occasional expenditure when this practice fails to protect the customer.
3Dee said:
Think I would pick a busy time for the Showroom (say Saturday mid morning) and have a conversation (you speak loudly don't you?) with the Sales Team, making sure you don't lose your temper, but stating the facts as you see it so others can hear, and refuse to leave or go into one of those little private rooms until it's is sorted out.
There is a good chance they will fall over themselves to be helpful, if they know that other visitors are earwigging!
Or not.There is a good chance they will fall over themselves to be helpful, if they know that other visitors are earwigging!

nipsips said:
Take a step back here... How many of you would think it is reasonable to expect a vehicle to need a new clutch just after purchase. 15k isnt a cheap car and should be expected to work for a reasonable period i.e until the warranty expiry without major flaw.
Quite. In fact last year I bought a very cheap Lexus GS430. Within a couple of months the starter motor had gone as had the bonnet catch. After some negotiation the dealer recovered the car, (dealer was 60 miles away) and rectified the faults. FOC.
So if I spent £15K on a motor that with in a matter of weeks had a dodgy clutch, I would expect a loan car and flowers for SWMBO, whilst they fixed it FOC.
nipsips said:
Take a step back here... How many of you would think it is reasonable to expect a vehicle to need a new clutch just after purchase. 15k isnt a cheap car and should be expected to work for a reasonable period i.e until the warranty expiry without major flaw.
Quite. In fact last year I bought a very cheap Lexus GS430. Within a couple of months the starter motor had gone as had the bonnet catch. After some negotiation the dealer recovered the car, (dealer was 60 miles away) and rectified the faults. FOC.
So if I spent £15K on a motor that with in a matter of weeks had a dodgy clutch, I would expect a loan car and flowers for SWMBO, whilst they fixed it FOC.
nipsips said:
Take a step back here... How many of you would think it is reasonable to expect a vehicle to need a new clutch just after purchase. 15k isnt a cheap car and should be expected to work for a reasonable period i.e until the warranty expiry without major flaw.
I know when I used to work in a Volvo dealer they'd pay for this sort of thing as a percentage of 100k miles, so a 50k car got 50% paid. Sounds like the OP isn't getting too bad a deal to me.Mind you, what sort of clutch wears out that quick? is it a known fault on these cars or was it owned by a mong who couldn't drive properly?
Im no lawyer and Im amazed at people saying you should pay,no way you should be paying anything after 6 weeks on a 15k car.I'd send them a letter giving them 14 days to rectify at their cost,stating that if nothing is done you'll get the work done at an independant and bill them the full cost via small claims.Thats what I'd do anyway.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


