TV licence prosecutions total more that 10% of court cases
TV licence prosecutions total more that 10% of court cases
Author
Discussion

streaky

Original Poster:

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
News report said:
The BBC was responsible for more than one in 10 criminal prosecutions last year as the number of people taken to court for non-payment of their television licence reached a new high.

More than 180,000 people — almost 3,500 a week — appeared before the magistrates’ courts, accused of watching television without a valid £145.50 annual licence.

The figure, an increase of 15,000 prosecutions on the previous year, has been steadily rising as TV Licensing, which is responsible for catching and prosecuting non-payers, improves its ability to identify those responsible.

But with magistrates handling a total of 1.48 million cases last year, it means that around 12 per cent of their workload is being made up of television licensing offences.

The rise in prosecutions comes against the backdrop of the BBC executive pay-off scandal, which saw the corporation pay £60 million in severance deals — enough to pay more than 412,000 licences.

Anyone who watches television as it is being broadcast must have a licence for their home, even if they view programmes on the internet.

It is possible for a viewer to claim an exemption if it can be demonstrated that they only watch programmes via an online catch-up system, such as the BBC’s iPlayer.

The figures, which emerged during a parliamentary question from Lord Laird, show that last year a total of 155,000 people were convicted and fined for not having a valid licence, suggesting that cases against 25,000 people were unsuccessful.

Unlike the non-payment of utility bills and parking tickets, which are treated as civil matters, those who refuse to pay the television licence receive a criminal record.

The maximum penalty for non-payment is a £1,000 fine, but anyone who refuses or is unable to pay the fine can end up in prison.

In recent years, at least 70 people have been jailed for non-payment of fines associated with television licensing offences. There are growing calls for licensing issues to be dealt with as civil prosecutions in order to free up the courts to handle more serious matters.

Lord Pearson, the UK Independence Party leader in the House of Lords, is sponsoring a Bill to de-criminalise the non-payment of the licence fee.

He said: “It is outrageous that so many people are brought in to the criminal justice system through this means. I believe that non-payment should be treated in the way that parking tickets are. It is absurd that the courts are being clogged up by such a minor offence.”

While BBC services remain popular, there is mounting anger over the cost of the licence measured against financial waste at the corporation.

Steve Barclay, the Tory MP and member of the public accounts select committee, which has scrutinised BBC spending, said: “It is interesting to look at these figures against the backdrop of the recent vast pay-offs made to BBC executives.

“Meanwhile, you have hard-working people being taken to court and given criminal records for non-payment of their licence fee.”

A spokesman for TV Licensing said: “We have a duty to enforce the law on behalf of the 95 per cent of people who pay. TV licence evasion cases take up a small proportion of court time as they are dealt with in bulk in dedicated sessions and very few people attend court.”

Regarding the number of viewers who watch online catch-up television, the spokesman added: “Well under two per cent of adults only consume catch-up TV in a typical week, although over the course of a year may watch some live TV and therefore still need a licence.”

In 2012, more than 400,000 households informed the BBC that they did not need a television licence. Many homeowners who do not own a television have complained of receiving letters erroneously informing them of the need to purchase a licence.
Editorial comment said:
Figures from the Ministry of Justice show, staggeringly, that nearly one in 10 prosecutions brought before the magistrates’ courts in England and Wales last year was for non-payment of the TV licence fee. Around 180,000 people received a criminal record for this offence, which carries a maximum fine of £1,000. It appears to be the most common crime dealt with by JPs. This is madness – not least at a time when the Government is anxious to reduce court costs.

Why should failure to pay this particular charge – currently £145.50 – attract a criminal penalty, unlike, for instance, a gas or electricity bill? It should be a matter for civil disposal, by way of a fixed-penalty notice. Even “real” crimes such as shoplifting goods up to the value of £200 and vandalism of up to £500 are now dealt with in this way. True, it is an offence not to pay a tax; but the BBC has always denied that the licence fee is a tax, so that won’t wash either.

The Magistrates’ Association has been pressing successive governments for years to decriminalise non-payment, and it is hard to understand why the existing state of affairs has been allowed to continue. Whenever such a change is suggested, however, the BBC objects in the strongest terms. But why should the corporation be allowed to dictate the law of the land? Evidently, it fears that if non-payment is decriminalised then the number of people refusing to cough up will grow rapidly – and this may well be right, given public anger over the way the BBC has spent so much paying its own executives and building new media centres.

The truth is that, in a digital age, no one entertainment provider enjoys a monopoly on our viewing habits worthy of exclusive subsidy – and it is hard to justify a compulsory charge for owning a television set when people now use it to do many more things than just watch the BBC live. The levy is unique in the civilised world and the paternalistic justification used by Sir John Reith for imposing it no longer applies. The BBC’s claim to the fee can be substantiated only if it informs, educates and entertains at a higher level than would be possible if it were a commercial enterprise. Once the corporation began routinely to make the same sort of demotic programmes as its rivals, the proposition that this should be underpinned by a national levy became hard to defend.

Even if no political party has the courage to challenge the BBC and insist that it should be subsidised in future by subscription, the very least that ministers should do is to end the criminalisation of thousands of people for not paying the licence fee.
That sums it up well, IMO. It's (long past) time that Auntie was forced into commercial reality.

Streaky

Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
The BBC with the help of Capita will cause their own downfall. More and more people will stop paying the tv tax, more will get taken to court if they let them into their homes. It's time for a change, I think the best way now that digital is up and running is a pay for tv type box.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Before condemning the BBC, take a look at the US and Canada where there are adverts on TV every 10 minutes.
Take a look at New Zealand who threw away their equivalent and now regret it.

Take a look at the BBC content that is not biased based on advertising revenue or private ownership, compare it to FOX news.

Look at the BBC radio stations without adverts, and look at the free music events they stage every year.

Look at all the interesting small TV shows they fund every year.
The BBC makes entertainment for the same of entertainment.
Every other media company is in the business of selling advertising.

I like the BBC.
It does good things.

Frix

678 posts

222 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
I think fondly of the BBC because of the broad range of services that it offers. I am afraid that is no longer the case that the BBC reports impartially. Lack of bias is not achieved by a willingness to run stories on itself but by truly impartial reporting of it. I don't think they do that any more. They are not as bad as most and I would like to see the BBC continue. Which leaves us with the method of public funding. I'm not sure if it is possible but if we wait long enough for when TV is delivered in a Sky/Virgin style would it not be feasible to turn off the service to those that do not pay the licence?

DeadPrez

140 posts

162 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
[redacted]

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
With the BBC being biased.
I have heard that it's Biased for the Tories one week and the Labour the next week.
One week it's pro environmental extremist, the next week it's sod the whales.

Individual stories, articles and editorials might be biased; but as a whole it's pretty fair.


0000

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
The system's definitely broken if we're making 180000 people a year criminals for watching TV, that's ridiculous. There must be 101 ways to fix that without offending the BBC lovers.

While we're at it, VED from fuel duty?

Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
It's the way that's the licence is worded, to receive live tv broadcasts, it doesn't just say to fund and watch the BBC. They try to rose tint it by saying it helps the BBC fund new drama, exciting documentaries, free concerts etc. the whole idea of digital tv is to get tv to the masses in a clearer better looking format with more channels. ITV, C4 and C5 all win awards for their programmes and news reporting, they are advert funded. Sky has won awards and brings new programmes, yes you have to pay, but its a choice. It all needs to be rolled into a pay as you want package, you advise your supplier that you want the BBC package and you pay the £147.50, simple. They need to trial it for 24 months, the technology is there, just see what happens, they bleat on about fairness all the time.

Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
[redacted]

3Dee

3,206 posts

252 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
......Or call it STATE Television! Because given there is no real justification any more for calling it anything else, coupled with the draconian methods of enforcement of payment collection, it is a tax!

Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
[redacted]

Kozy

3,169 posts

249 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
So 155,000 people didn't realise that you can simply tell them to go away at the door?

Jazzy Jefferson

728 posts

172 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
So 155,000 people didn't realise that you can simply tell them to go away at the door?
Even that can be avoided. Simply call them up, and let them know you do not watch or receive live broadcasts. I've not had a TV licence for years, and they don't come knocking smile

Fozziebear

1,840 posts

171 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Kozy said:
So 155,000 people didn't realise that you can simply tell them to go away at the door?
It'll be pubs, cafes, chip shops, newsagents and no working mums that get caught out. It's a case of being able to see the tv on and working. Every place visited has a simple statement taken, then an offer to set up a payment method for the customer, if they refuse or fail the payments it gets took to court. I'd say 155,000 is a 1/4 of the people they could have took to court.

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Before condemning the BBC, take a look at the US and Canada where there are adverts on TV every 10 minutes.
Take a look at New Zealand who threw away their equivalent and now regret it.

Take a look at the BBC content that is not biased based on advertising revenue or private ownership, compare it to FOX news.

Look at the BBC radio stations without adverts, and look at the free music events they stage every year.

Look at all the interesting small TV shows they fund every year.
The BBC makes entertainment for the same of entertainment.
Every other media company is in the business of selling advertising.

I like the BBC.
It does good things.
I agree.

Most of the stuff I watch and listen too is on the BBC.

Laurel Green

31,324 posts

263 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
Before condemning the BBC, take a look at the US and Canada where there are adverts on TV every 10 minutes.
Take a look at New Zealand who threw away their equivalent and now regret it.

Take a look at the BBC content that is not biased based on advertising revenue or private ownership, compare it to FOX news.

Look at the BBC radio stations without adverts, and look at the free music events they stage every year.

Look at all the interesting small TV shows they fund every year.
The BBC makes entertainment for the same of entertainment.
Every other media company is in the business of selling advertising.

I like the BBC.
It does good things.
Entirely agree!

Devil2575

13,400 posts

219 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Snowboy said:
With the BBC being biased.
I have heard that it's Biased for the Tories one week and the Labour the next week.
One week it's pro environmental extremist, the next week it's sod the whales.

Individual stories, articles and editorials might be biased; but as a whole it's pretty fair.
And again, I agree.

The people who complain most about bias tend to be those with extreme views themselves who can't cope when another perspective is given air time.

Art0ir

9,423 posts

201 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
[redacted]

CrutyRammers

13,735 posts

229 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Laurel Green said:
Snowboy said:
Before condemning the BBC, take a look at the US and Canada where there are adverts on TV every 10 minutes.
Take a look at New Zealand who threw away their equivalent and now regret it.

Take a look at the BBC content that is not biased based on advertising revenue or private ownership, compare it to FOX news.

Look at the BBC radio stations without adverts, and look at the free music events they stage every year.

Look at all the interesting small TV shows they fund every year.
The BBC makes entertainment for the same of entertainment.
Every other media company is in the business of selling advertising.

I like the BBC.
It does good things.
Entirely agree!
Good for you. I almost never watch it myself. Are there any more of your hobbies you'd like me to subsidise?

aizvara

2,067 posts

198 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
CrutyRammers said:
Good for you. I almost never watch it myself. Are there any more of your hobbies you'd like me to subsidise?
It is your choice to subsidise his "hobby".