Defrauded - what to do?
Defrauded - what to do?
Author
Discussion

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Chaps

I was approached a number of times by a telemarketing company who you pay a fixed fee for them to get you a number of appointments with prospective clients.

Eventually I decided to give it a go so their salesman sends me the contract and invoice with an extra discount for paying in advance ( I know now!!) - the company appeared reputable having checked their record at Companies House and speaking to a couple of testimonials so I paid.

Three weeks later I have heard nothing so I ring them and am told that the salesman has left, they have no record of me and the bank details on the invoice were the salesman's account and not the company's.

I have spoken to a a Director twice and they asked me to report this to the Police (I have) and that they would honour the contract I had - whilst I had reservations, I thought the company is also a victim here so gave them the go ahead.

We are now 2 weeks later and nothing - no contact, no feedback and no sales appointments.

So what do you recommend?

Can I sue the company for a repayment even if they didn't receive the funds, as the contract term I paid for has now ended?

David

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
How much did you pay them? Only that will decide if this is worth pursuing.

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Inkyfingers said:
How much did you pay them? Only that will decide if this is worth pursuing.
£1k + VAT so £1200

The Moose

23,710 posts

240 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
And what type of payment did you make to them?

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
My general motto - never, ever respond positively to ANY approach made by an outside entity.

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
The Moose said:
And what type of payment did you make to them?
Faster payment via the internet - no recourse according to the bank as I have asked.

David

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
My general motto - never, ever respond positively to ANY approach made by an outside entity.
I don't as a rule - but they do have reputable testimonials.

So any advice how to get the money back?

David

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
I think the pertinent question has already been asked. How much is involved?

That will determine whether pursuing the money is worth it.

If the amount IS sizable, I would also investigate to find out if any other customers of this organisation had a similar experience. You may not be the only one.

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I think the pertinent question has already been asked. How much is involved?

That will determine whether pursuing the money is worth it.

If the amount IS sizable, I would also investigate to find out if any other customers of this organisation had a similar experience. You may not be the only one.
I was told by the Director that there were several others, though I have no way of finding out who they are.

Re the quantum, I answered that above: £1000 + VAT

David

Eric Mc

125,980 posts

296 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
That is big enough to chase further - I agree.

I would do an internet search on some accounting type forums to find out if there others in the same boat as you.

I am not one hundred percent convinced by the explanation the company has given you. Did they give you the name of the person you dealt with i.e. the person they claim was the fraudster?

If not, why not?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Have you chased the company up during the 2 weeks since you spoke to the director? It might be that they are just incompetent, rather than dishonest.

Or it may be that the mystery employee pocketed a larger number of customers money that the company realised and now they aren't as keen to honour them all...

The absolute key thing to start with is to make sure you keep records of all communications and make a note of what was said during any phone conversations.

For £1000 it's worth pursuing, but I can't help but feel in the end your going to have to just chalk this down to experience.

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
That is big enough to chase further - I agree.

I would do an internet search on some accounting type forums to find out if there others in the same boat as you.

I am not one hundred percent convinced by the explanation the company has given you. Did they give you the name of the person you dealt with i.e. the person they claim was the fraudster?

If not, why not?
I know his name and the Director.

I recognise that they all may be in collusion on this - just trying to give the benefit but the lack of any action doesn't look good.

David

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
I think the question I need an answer to is this:

Can I sue for recovery if they didn't receive the original payment (allegedly)?

After all, it was made in good faith on an invoice using their letterhead, calls were to their office or the salesman's work mobile etc.

David

sideways sid

1,467 posts

246 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
With a couple of extra details we can deduce that this is a problem for the company, not you.

You received the contract from the salesman. From a company email address, or fax machine ideally. Hopefully not a hard copy signed in a coffee shop or sent from the salesman's Gmail account.

You returned the signed contract. Presumably you emailed it back to the company, faxed it back, &/or posted to their address.

The company has acknowledged that the salesman was employed by them at the time.

So it seems like you entered lawfully into a contract with the company and their staff stole the money.

What you really want is the leads that were promised, so perhaps the best approach is to ask the company to honour the contract and provide the leads.

If they will not, you are due a refund. It is up to the company to pursue their former employee, although in practice they would probably just write off the amount.

If they do not deliver leads or a refund, you can pursue the company in the usual ways for not performing the terms of the contract.

sumo69

Original Poster:

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
sideways sid said:
With a couple of extra details we can deduce that this is a problem for the company, not you.

You received the contract from the salesman. From a company email address, or fax machine ideally. Hopefully not a hard copy signed in a coffee shop or sent from the salesman's Gmail account.

You returned the signed contract. Presumably you emailed it back to the company, faxed it back, &/or posted to their address.

The company has acknowledged that the salesman was employed by them at the time.

So it seems like you entered lawfully into a contract with the company and their staff stole the money.

What you really want is the leads that were promised, so perhaps the best approach is to ask the company to honour the contract and provide the leads.

If they will not, you are due a refund. It is up to the company to pursue their former employee, although in practice they would probably just write off the amount.

If they do not deliver leads or a refund, you can pursue the company in the usual ways for not performing the terms of the contract.
Yes - e-mails from company address and contract posted back to their office.

Thanks - your analysis is what I thought but obviously preferred it confirmed.

David

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
My general motto - never, ever respond positively to ANY approach made by an outside entity.
Just as an aside, how do you expect businesses to generate business if everyone had that attitude?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
Just as an aside, how do you expect businesses to generate business if everyone had that attitude?
I 'Think' he means ones you have to pay.

For example my Firm has never and, so long as I have a say in it, will never, pay anyone to provide us with 'leads' or 'potential clients' or even ready to run cases.

FWIW we don't advertise for business either. There are a couple of local teams wearing strips or who have a board with our name on it but that isn't about the advertising (we have no idea, nor care how much, if any, business that generates on its own) but a good way to put something back into the local community with the branding being incidental.

C Lee Farquar

4,240 posts

247 months

Thursday 22nd August 2013
quotequote all
Presumably there is some VAT fraud here too if the salesman took the money? I would check that the VAT number on the invoice relates to the Company, it may give you a little more leverage with them. I doubt many Company owners want a VAT inspection.

4lf4-155

700 posts

274 months

Sunday 25th August 2013
quotequote all
sumo69 said:
I think the question I need an answer to is this:

Can I sue for recovery if they didn't receive the original payment (allegedly)?

After all, it was made in good faith on an invoice using their letterhead, calls were to their office or the salesman's work mobile etc.

David
If you sent a faster payment to them quoting the company name as the account holder then its highly unlikely / near impossible that the money ended up in the 'rogue' salesman's account.

Faster payments is predicated on the basis of name and account details matching, being verified by a computer prior to the payment veing intiated and needing no human involvement to process.

If it was their account number and his name you would not have been able to send the money from your end.

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Sunday 25th August 2013
quotequote all
4lf4-155 said:
If you sent a faster payment to them quoting the company name as the account holder then its highly unlikely / near impossible that the money ended up in the 'rogue' salesman's account.

Faster payments is predicated on the basis of name and account details matching, being verified by a computer prior to the payment veing intiated and needing no human involvement to process.

If it was their account number and his name you would not have been able to send the money from your end.
Doesn't happen in my experience.