Discussion
I think the chance of you not being penalised by Google is extremely low.
Look at http://www.100sof.com/shops/item?i=684m8c3_d2013_0... - ignoring the fact the images don't load (lets assume thats a launch issue and will be fixed), you provide very little value to users that isn't elsewhere on the net.
Then you've got a description from a feed or scraped from elsewhere, used in thousands of other websites - http://www.google.co.uk/search?site=&source=hp...
If you're going to have a page of thin, duplicate content for every one of thousands of items then a Google penalty seems a near certainty. I think you're a good 5 years too late with this business model unfortunately.
Look at http://www.100sof.com/shops/item?i=684m8c3_d2013_0... - ignoring the fact the images don't load (lets assume thats a launch issue and will be fixed), you provide very little value to users that isn't elsewhere on the net.
Then you've got a description from a feed or scraped from elsewhere, used in thousands of other websites - http://www.google.co.uk/search?site=&source=hp...
If you're going to have a page of thin, duplicate content for every one of thousands of items then a Google penalty seems a near certainty. I think you're a good 5 years too late with this business model unfortunately.
KFC said:
I think the chance of you not being penalised by Google is extremely low.
Look at http://www.100sof.com/shops/item?i=684m8c3_d2013_0... - ignoring the fact the images don't load (lets assume thats a launch issue and will be fixed), you provide very little value to users that isn't elsewhere on the net.
Then you've got a description from a feed or scraped from elsewhere, used in thousands of other websites - http://www.google.co.uk/search?site=&source=hp...
If you're going to have a page of thin, duplicate content for every one of thousands of items then a Google penalty seems a near certainty. I think you're a good 5 years too late with this business model unfortunately.
This is what I've always wondered - there are so many sites out there that do this - how do they not get penalised?!Look at http://www.100sof.com/shops/item?i=684m8c3_d2013_0... - ignoring the fact the images don't load (lets assume thats a launch issue and will be fixed), you provide very little value to users that isn't elsewhere on the net.
Then you've got a description from a feed or scraped from elsewhere, used in thousands of other websites - http://www.google.co.uk/search?site=&source=hp...
If you're going to have a page of thin, duplicate content for every one of thousands of items then a Google penalty seems a near certainty. I think you're a good 5 years too late with this business model unfortunately.
The Moose said:
This is what I've always wondered - there are so many sites out there that do this - how do they not get penalised?!
The ones that are run by tv stations, newspapers, have VC backing and so on manage to gather enough publicity that they survive. The ones ran by a bloke in his shed get no links, no user metrics, and no quality signals for search engines to see and ultimately end up in the toilet.KFC said:
I think the chance of you not being penalised by Google is extremely low.
Yep, considering you now have to use Per Per Click biding to get on Google Shopping they don't want anyone else taking that traffic.However, the social aspect is interesting - maybe if you work on integration (e.g. ask your Facebook friends 'Which of these sneakers look best?') and try towards a buy out. Twitter especially would love to have something more than 'we're going to stick adverts on the page'.
esvcg said:
Personally i'm in the view that google are gonna bring me visitors, but over the years i've learnt that google are not the be-and-end-all. A good site with good links from lots of varied sources should do well, and im not going to lose sleep over 1 search site
Google have a 90% market share of search engine traffic in UK - they pretty much are the be all and end all of UK internet. Unless you have a legitimate ecosystem outside of Google like owning Twitter or Facebook. esvcg said:
Additionally I follow the google webmaster and SEO guidelines as much as is possible too, and if webmaster tools do show issues, i fix them asap.
imo this is an extremely naive viewpoint. You won't be able to fix them at all, never mind asap, if Googles problem is your core business model. If Google tell you you have loads of low quality pages where the content exists elsewhere, how is that fixable? I would say that given your current business model, it isn't.I've just lost enough money on a Google penalty that I could have bought an Aventador - and I'm not talking vague future profits... I'm talking actual cash from my own pocket that I sunk into something to start it up. Its getting brutal out there.... and imo your site is not even anywhere close to being acceptable. Sorry if that sounds harsh but I'd rather upset someone than see them lose their shirt.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


