Pay by results SEO
Author
Discussion

Alec

Original Poster:

333 posts

257 months

Friday 30th August 2013
quotequote all
Not sure if I'm imaging things but does someone on here run a pay by results SEO firm?

Thanks

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Friday 30th August 2013
quotequote all
That would seem a mad way to run a SEO business!

Pappa Lurve

3,827 posts

313 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Used to be involved in SEO. Never yet found a good company that would charge by results! It rather assumes that the company does exactly as needed, that competitor firms don;t also use SEO which could require a change of approach if they do well with it, it can require constant attention and different results, time scales, costs etc depending on the client. We charged a flat hourly rate. Look at it this way, why should we have based it directly on results when there are far too many variables that were totally beyond ur control. If the client didn't follow our advice then they could argue we didn't hit the results and not pay despite the failure being theirs. Every so often a compy would crop up and offer that but I didn;t see any that lasted teribly long. I am a few years out of date though but I tthink that all still holds true.

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Pappa Lurve said:
Used to be involved in SEO. Never yet found a good company that would charge by results! It rather assumes that the company does exactly as needed, that competitor firms don;t also use SEO which could require a change of approach if they do well with it, it can require constant attention and different results, time scales, costs etc depending on the client. We charged a flat hourly rate. Look at it this way, why should we have based it directly on results when there are far too many variables that were totally beyond ur control. If the client didn't follow our advice then they could argue we didn't hit the results and not pay despite the failure being theirs. Every so often a compy would crop up and offer that but I didn;t see any that lasted teribly long. I am a few years out of date though but I tthink that all still holds true.
How did you make the move from SEO to your current area of work?

Frimley111R

19,436 posts

265 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Define: 'Results'. How high up the search rankings they get? Or how many people visited the site based on 'non brand' search terms? In my experience few clients understand SEO in enough detail to request it on this basis.

burwoodman

18,718 posts

277 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Frimley111R said:
Define: 'Results'. How high up the search rankings they get? Or how many people visited the site based on 'non brand' search terms? In my experience few clients understand SEO in enough detail to request it on this basis.
Few understand is exactly how 99% of SEO supplying companies sell snake oil. Adwords are a better return on investment for the simple reason no SEO is enduring and to do well is very expensive. The minute you stop the results are lost. Pay by results wouldn't work because the same SEO companies want to milk the cash cow for a year before the client gets fed up and cancels.

bigweb

833 posts

259 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Isnt Pay by results basically PPC in everything but name?

I run PPC campaigns for SMB's by the way ;-)

Google hate SEO and are doing their bast to eradicate it.

I had a meeting with a large SEO firm last week who concede that their industry is being pushed out at a rate of knots and are looking ahead 5 years where they think they would be out of business if they don't diversify.

5 Years seems like a long time to me...

@burwoodman Do you run your own PPC account? If so how are you finding enhanced campaigns for the furniture business? taking longer to administer? better results?


Edited by bigweb on Tuesday 3rd September 12:40

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
bigweb said:
Isnt Pay by results basically PPC in everything but name?
No

bigweb said:
Google hate SEO and are doing their bast to eradicate it.
No, they don't like people trying to game the system by using techniques that add nothing to their users. They do like it when SEOs help to make sites more usable and easier for Google to crawl. They also like when SEOs produce quality content that Google can index and then deliver back to users.

The reason they don't hate SEO is that they don't really care that much about it. The money is made on adwords etc and as long as everything else isn't too much of a mess, they really don't care.

What big agency were you talking to? They must be doing something really badly as all the ones I know are doing a roaring trade!

bigweb

833 posts

259 months

Tuesday 3rd September 2013
quotequote all
Andrew[MG] said:
bigweb said:
Isnt Pay by results basically PPC in everything but name?
No

bigweb said:
Google hate SEO and are doing their bast to eradicate it.
No, they don't like people trying to game the system by using techniques that add nothing to their users. They do like it when SEOs help to make sites more usable and easier for Google to crawl. They also like when SEOs produce quality content that Google can index and then deliver back to users.

The reason they don't hate SEO is that they don't really care that much about it. The money is made on adwords etc and as long as everything else isn't too much of a mess, they really don't care.

What big agency were you talking to? They must be doing something really badly as all the ones I know are doing a roaring trade!
A pay by results SEO strategy suggests to me that a company would pay a company when and only when they had managed to get them onto page 1 of SERP.
A company pays me to do pretty much the same job via PPC. If nobody sees their Ad then they can't click on it and therefore don't pay a penny....

The particular SEO company is doing great at the moment but can see the way things are going. Google is killing traditional methods of SEO with each algorithm update and grey hat becomes black hat etc.
We white label this particular company's PPC for them and they gave me a pretty damning rundown of what is going on in the industry from their point of view.