Advice needed - Administrators and disputed invoice
Advice needed - Administrators and disputed invoice
Author
Discussion

Robatr0n

Original Poster:

12,362 posts

247 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi all,

I'm after a bit of advice.

Earlier in the year we had a breakdown on one of our machines so we called in a company who are(were!) very experienced with this particular type of machinery to carry a repair. Upon inspection, it was obvious that there was a problem with the main shaft which was taken away for repair at their factory in Manchester.

Some time later, the main shaft was returned to us and re-installed. It was pretty obvious from the off that the repair was not satisfactory and that they had claimed they'd carried out far more work than what was actually completed on the repair. This was confirmed by their guy who both disassembled and reassembled the item of machinery on our premises and he even went further to explain that his good friend carried out the work for us in their factory and was told to re-use old items (bearings, etc..).

Upon receiving their invoice we weren't particularly surprised to see that they had massively overcharged us by attempting to fool us that new parts had been used when they hadn't. There was also associated labour charges involved with replacing these parts, too. They had claimed that their engineer had travelled from Manchester to London to visit us and then had driven straight back to Manchester and had charged us for a very expensive overnight stay and associated food and drink costs. We know for a fact that when the engineer left our premises, he then drove straight to the coast to visit another customer of theirs. Now whilst we're liable for travel expenses, they were once again dishonest and we felt it was too much money to be considered fair.

Their invoice made it very clear that should we have any queries or if we'd like to raise a dispute that we'd have to do so within 14 days. So within the 14 days, we sent them their (now amended) invoice with what we felt was a fair amount to pay for the work carried out (taking into consideration they had wrecked the gearbox when reinstalling the shaft) and we even spoke to the MD telling him very clearly that a dispute had been raised.

Roll forward several months and we've just received a letter from the administrators telling us that the company has gone into administration and that they are pursuing payment for the full invoice which they originally sent us. We called the administrators and told them that the invoice was under dispute and that their MD had been informed and was going to investigate our amendments to their invoice and would get back to us. We were basically told that it's our tough luck and they will be pursuing us for the full amount of monies owed and that if they don't receive the money within 14 days that will pursue the money through the courts.

Can anyone offer any advice on our next course of action?

Apologies for the long post!

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Keep all your evidence and let them take you to court. If you can back up what you're saying and have evidence to "prove" it, you'll be OK.

Or you could pay what you feel is owed, and tell them to do one for the balance, with a coherent explanation of why you're only paying what you're paying.

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
This is what I would do. Chances are if the company has gone pop, there are very few people remaining to verify what's gone on. The administrators have come in, looked at the outstanding sales ledger & are now cranking up the pressure to retrieve as much revenue as they can, which to be fair is their duty.

Stick to your guns, tell them to do one & if necessary sit in front of a judge & explain why you're there. Been there a few times before & have learnt that administrators can be like dodgy bailiffs trying it on when they want to turn the heat up. Equally though, you have a debt so if a sniff of a percentage in the pound comes along as final settlement, be ready to do that too - you may end up better off than if you had dealt with the original firm. It's all about finding a way, but don't be intimidated by threats from accountants!

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Nasty lot - accountants.

Justin Cyder

12,624 posts

180 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Nah. Some of them are just dullards. biggrin

Wacky Racer

41,426 posts

278 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
mondeoman said:
Keep all your evidence and let them take you to court. If you can back up what you're saying and have evidence to "prove" it, you'll be OK.

Or you could pay what you feel is owed, and tell them to do one for the balance, with a coherent explanation of why you're only paying what you're paying.
This.

Then if it does go to court (doubtful) the judge will (hopefully) see you have been reasonable, rather than trying to get out of paying the full invoice.

kowalski655

15,237 posts

174 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Make an offer or payment of what you think is fair.And if they do go legal,get an order for security for your costs,as the company is in administration,so wont have any spare to pay you if they lose.

Robatr0n

Original Poster:

12,362 posts

247 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Thank you all for taking the time to reply. We will just stick to our guns!

As it happens, we still have the contact details for the engineer so we'll give him a ring and see if he is still willing to back up our version of events.

kowalski655 said:
Make an offer or payment of what you think is fair.And if they do go legal,get an order for security for your costs,as the company is in administration,so wont have any spare to pay you if they lose.
As part of our dispute, we amended their invoice to what we felt was a fair and correct amount to pay them. This will have to be changed now that it's become evident that they damaged the gearbox on the reinstallation. We've had an independent inspection carried out on the gearbox which also confirms this so we would be looking for cost of a repair/rebuild to be taken into account too.

jamoor

14,506 posts

246 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
What's the value?

Tell them to crack on and pursue it in the court if they don't listen.

mondeoman

11,430 posts

297 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Robatr0n said:
As part of our dispute, we amended their invoice to what we felt was a fair and correct amount to pay them. This will have to be changed now that it's become evident that they damaged the gearbox on the reinstallation. We've had an independent inspection carried out on the gearbox which also confirms this so we would be looking for cost of a repair/rebuild to be taken into account too.
There's your out - assuming you have proof (it all comes down to that afterall), wing them back the final revised invoice, with explanation and engineers report. You might even get to them owing you money wink

951TSE

600 posts

188 months

Wednesday 4th September 2013
quotequote all
Totally off the wall suggestion, and it's probably not your core business, but would you be in a position to offer to buy up the company in administration. That way you'd get your shaft fixed to a standard that you required and you would be able to supply parts for the machinery of other users.

southendpier

6,244 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th September 2013
quotequote all
Make a counterclaim to cover the damage they've done.

ModernAndy

2,094 posts

166 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Don't worry about administrators too much. I don't know how much you need off the invoice but the chances are they'll settle for that discount regardless of the circumstances unless its more than 50% then it will be a little more difficult.

Had this experience earlier in the year and managed to negotiate more than £3k better terms than we legally deserved because the administrators were desperate to claw the money back.

Robatr0n

Original Poster:

12,362 posts

247 months

Wednesday 11th September 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies.

We've spoken to the engineer and he is quite happen that our version of events are true and correct and is happy to stand by us. The chap who carried out the work on the shaft is also quite happy to confirm that he only carried out minimal work and re-used old parts whilst the company are adamant that new parts were used and have billed us for them, along with a considerable labour charge.

It's also been established that the director of the company is drinking buddies with the administrators and this is just an attempt to draw in all monies owed and they will drop any debt of their own and start afresh. It's completely immoral but in this instance it's not really any of our business and nor is it something we'd mention in court. We're just keen to pay what is a fair and true cost for the work they carried out, less the cost of repair / replacement for our damaged gearbox.

If they were to become really awkward, we could invoice them for our own time spent helping their engineer stripping the machine down to access the shaft and loading it into his van (That would be two members of staff over 3 days). It was at the very least a 2 man job and they sent the engineer to us on his own with a lack of tools and lifting equipment. We were, fortunately, able to scrounge trolleys / hoists / stands, etc. from local companies who were happy to help us.


Cyberprog

2,326 posts

214 months

Wednesday 11th September 2013
quotequote all
Robatr0n said:
If they were to become really awkward, we could invoice them for our own time spent helping their engineer stripping the machine down to access the shaft and loading it into his van (That would be two members of staff over 3 days). It was at the very least a 2 man job and they sent the engineer to us on his own with a lack of tools and lifting equipment. We were, fortunately, able to scrounge trolleys / hoists / stands, etc. from local companies who were happy to help us.
This should have been the clue that the company behind it all were useless wink I take a good deal of my gut instinct of a company from how they treat their staff... Dumping a job like that on the chap on his own is a bit unreasonable on it's own!

Robatr0n

Original Poster:

12,362 posts

247 months

Wednesday 11th September 2013
quotequote all
In hindsight, yes you're quite right. We were willing to overlook this because we were desperate to get the machine back up and running (as work was building up and we were renting another machine at a different facility to complete work) and because they were regarded as the best in the industry.

I'm not sure how they became so highly acclaimed to be honest!

sleepezy

2,145 posts

265 months

Thursday 12th September 2013
quotequote all
ModernAndy said:
... because the administrators were desperate to claw the money back.
It's not just because they are desperate to claw in cash, it is also because they have to balance the value of pursing a claim against the (significant) additional costs involved in doing so when considering their time required in preparing the claim, possibly starting from scratch.