Leasing a car from my own company...
Leasing a car from my own company...
Author
Discussion

Ultraviolet

Original Poster:

625 posts

247 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi

Quick bit of advice needed... Appreciate I can get a company car and pay BIK on the new price of the car - however i am looking at second hand so this doesn't seem to make sense. I could get a personal car and claim back the business mileage (about 5000 business miles a year) which is what I do currently.

However is it possible to buy a car within my limited company (which is for IT contracting) and for me to then lease it from my limited company, paying these lease costs from my net personal income? This will enable me to avoid taking money out of the company for a deposit on the car - company takes a hit on the deposit, company owns the car, I take money of the company in the form of dividends or salary, pay the company a lease for use of the car out of this net income and I'm not hit for BIK.

Appreciate I will be having to pay myself more to cover the additional amount I then pay back to the company for the lease of the car, but this will be more palatable for me as I can keep the deposit and balloon payment within the company and smooth out the increase in income tax I am paying whilst also avoiding any BIK liabilities. Is this possible? And, more importantly, is it advisable?

Cheers,
UV


xaby82

87 posts

171 months

Saturday 7th September 2013
quotequote all
I'm no expert but I would assume you would have to pay corporation tax on the money you've taken out of the company then put back in as payment for leasing the car. (thus paying ct twice effectively)

Kudos

2,674 posts

205 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
xaby82 said:
I'm no expert
correct, your info is wrong. I'll not answer as I don't know, but corp tax x 2 is not correct

xaby82

87 posts

171 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Money paid into the company for the lease would be profit though would it not? Thus liable for ct.

xaby82

87 posts

171 months

Sunday 8th September 2013
quotequote all
Money paid into the company for the lease would be profit though would it not? Thus liable for ct.

Kudos

2,674 posts

205 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
xaby82 said:
Money paid into the company for the lease would be profit though would it not? Thus liable for ct.
The profit bit yes, but not taking it out in the first place (which you said in original post)

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Company buys car.

Company claims Capital Allowances on car - but being a car the Capital Allowances will not be very good, so the Corporation Tax relief that the company receives on the car will not be great.

Company leases car to director. Company therefore will pay Corporation Tax on the profits generated by its new lease income.

If the director/employee is paying the full market rate for the lease, he will NOT be subject to a tax Benefit in Kind charge on the vehicle as he is not receiving any taxable benefit. Obviously, if the company lease charges are less than the full market value, then he will be receiving a benefit and will pay tax on it. The company would also have to pay Class 1A NI on the value of the benefit too.

If the director has to receive more in the way of salary or dividends to be able to afford the lease repayments to the company, he will, of course, have to pay additional Income Tax (and NI on salaries) on his increased income.

The company will receive Corporation Tax relief on any additional salaries paid to the director.

Because the whole transaction is linked to a director, disclosure notes will need to be included in the annual accounts.

Ultraviolet

Original Poster:

625 posts

247 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Company buys car.

Company claims Capital Allowances on car - but being a car the Capital Allowances will not be very good, so the Corporation Tax relief that the company receives on the car will not be great.

Company leases car to director. Company therefore will pay Corporation Tax on the profits generated by its new lease income.

If the director/employee is paying the full market rate for the lease, he will NOT be subject to a tax Benefit in Kind charge on the vehicle as he is not receiving any taxable benefit. Obviously, if the company lease charges are less than the full market value, then he will be receiving a benefit and will pay tax on it. The company would also have to pay Class 1A NI on the value of the benefit too.

If the director has to receive more in the way of salary or dividends to be able to afford the lease repayments to the company, he will, of course, have to pay additional Income Tax (and NI on salaries) on his increased income.

The company will receive Corporation Tax relief on any additional salaries paid to the director.

Because the whole transaction is linked to a director, disclosure notes will need to be included in the annual accounts.
Thanks, that's pretty much what I thought... The challenge will be in getting to a full market value for the lease from the company. Lease costs are normally based (as I understand it) on the depreciation of the car plus back office costs and a margin for the leasing company. So a £20,000 worth, say, 50% less after three years would incur total lease costs paid over 3 years of around £10k. However, I'm looking to buy a used car which I don't expect (hopefully) to depreciate. So, say it keeps its £20k value after 3 years, what would be a fair lease amount for 3 years use?

,any tha ks,

Uv

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
The number crunching required to work out how beneficial any of this "plan" is actually very complex by the time you factor in the multiple variables that are in the mix -

whether you as an individual are a higher rate taxpayer

what rates of Corporation Tax your company pays

the actual types of Capital Allowances or other tax reliefs that might be available on the vehicle chosen ( some vehicles have very poor reliefs, some have very good reliefs)

whether the company buys the vehicle outright or buys it through a finance deal of some sort

the actual amounts being paid by the company in respect of any such finance deal and the type of tax reliefs (if any) available - they are different if the vehicle is bought outright, bought under a bank loan, bought using an HP or acquired using a lease arrangement

whether you as an individual will suffer any taxable BIK charge

At the end of the day, is it worth the effort?

Can't you just take a bigger dividend and pay for it personally out of the funds derived through the dividend and then just claim mileage?






Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Personal lease on a fuel efficient car is the best way to go - they work out free upto 10k miles a year.

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Free in what way?

Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Free as in you claim back 45p a mile. wink

We have a ds3 for running about in the figures 'roughly' for an example to help the OP based on 10k miles a year;

6 + 23 payments @ £188.00 a month gives £ 5452.00 total lease over 2 years so £ 2726.00 per annum
Insurance £285.00 per year

Say the car does a true 55mpg @ 1.40 per litre = £1157.16 for fuel
Claim back 10000 miles at 45p gives £4500.00

So you get £4500.00 minus your costs of
£2726.00 + £285.00 (3011)leaves £1489.00

I understand 5k miles would work differently but a real world eg to start from.

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Are you factoring in the company's costs and allowance claims?

Are you factoring in the Taxable Benefit in Kind implications?

Are you factoring in the different tax treatment for business when they run owned cars as opposed to leased cars?

Or are you purely looking on the situation as an employee?

Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Personal lease vat included in all figures

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
But are you taking into account absolutely every aspect of all these transactions for all parties concerned - the employee/director, the employer/business etc?

Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Eric are you not reading what I'm writing? Personal lease. I take it you understand what that is?

Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Double post

Edited by Broccers on Monday 9th September 22:04

Ultraviolet

Original Poster:

625 posts

247 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
W
Broccers said:
Personal lease vat included in all figures
Yep, personal lease is what I currently do.

There's a couple of things I'm trying to avoid:
1. Taking a lump sum out of my company as a dividend to pay for the upfront lease amount e.g.6 months on a 36 month contract
2. Paying for depreciation on the car
3. Not covering the costs of the car, given my business miles is only 100 miles a week, and I'm looking for a 'fun' car.

Assuming I stick with my plan.
1. I buy an oldish GT car* in my company for £25k which cost £60k when new
2. I lease the car from my company for, say, £300 / month
3. I claim back my business mileage; the company claims a capital allowance for the car
4. After 3 years, the company sells the car for £22k
5. I then pay myself back (as a dividend) the amount my company made from leasing the car to me.

This seems like a massively more economical option than a 'regular' lease on a new car - I can even get the lease costs back (minus any income tax payable) by paying myself an extra dividend

Apart from the issue of establishing a market rate for leasing a used car from my company, and the added complexity from an accounting perspective, doesn't seem to be any drawbacks to me - and seems to save 000's over the three years (assuming the car doesn't depreciate significantly).

Uv

  • I won't mention a specific make and model so we don't get o/t, but assume its a car I have researched and don't believe will depreciate over the time period.
Edited by Ultraviolet on Monday 9th September 17:20

Broccers

3,237 posts

284 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Directors loan to buy it?

I don't know, what I do know is you'll have the likes of Eric saying NO YOU MUST PAY TAX.

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 9th September 2013
quotequote all
Broccers said:
Eric are you not reading what I'm writing? Personal lease. I take it you understand what that is?
Sorry - but I was too busy to take time out to read through all the details you provided.

You are leasing the car yourself and claiming 45p per mile from your employer?