Comfy, cheap, reliable mile muncher?
Comfy, cheap, reliable mile muncher?
Author
Discussion

bildo

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Regretfully, the M3 has gone and it's time to start looking at something a little more sensible for the journey's I do.

Had nothing but bad luck with my last two cars, and due to a change in circumstances I could do without it to say the least!

I'm covering about 10-15k miles a year, a lot of them being done on the motorway.

Looking for a car in the £4-8k price bracket and preferably a diesel.

A few have popped up so far that have been tempting:
Mondeo TDCI
Audi A4
Seat Exeo
VW Passat
Honda Civic
Mazda 6

The Mazda 6 seems the best value for money all round, can get a 10 plate on 60-odd-k miles for the upper bracket of my price range. I like the look of it and seems to have a lot of decent equipment as standard.

Willing to listen to any advice/recommendations that people may have before I embark on a massive lump of regret once again!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
A friend has an 09 Mazda 6 2.2d. It's great at munching miles (he does Liverpool to Suffolk every weekend), it gets 50-odd mpg everywhere. But it's one seriously boring car. Sitting in it, you could be in any jap car from the last 10 years. It's got iPod connection, climate etc, so it's very good VFM, but it's in Securicor Blue and, again, it's a bit dull for that sort of money IMO. Be interesting with a remap though.

I think a Ford or something German may be a nicer place to be. Or what about a diesel saab 9-5 for reliable comfortable mile munching? (I may be biased) Or a Volvo?

ETA yum
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...

Edited by OpulentBob on Tuesday 10th September 22:11

T1547

1,247 posts

165 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Going be a very boring journey in any of those after the m3!

Not considered a 330d coupe (e46)? At the top of your budget but I sold my e60 525d m sport with 84k on the clock for around £8.5k a couple of months back. 230bhp mapped and lovely on the motorway.

Of course if you a have a weekend toy then ignore all the above.... smile

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
bildo said:
Regretfully, the M3 has gone and it's time to start looking at something a little more sensible for the journey's I do.

Had nothing but bad luck with my last two cars, and due to a change in circumstances I could do without it to say the least!

I'm covering about 10-15k miles a year, a lot of them being done on the motorway.

Looking for a car in the £4-8k price bracket and preferably a diesel.

A few have popped up so far that have been tempting:
Mondeo TDCI
Audi A4
Seat Exeo
VW Passat
Honda Civic
Mazda 6

The Mazda 6 seems the best value for money all round, can get a 10 plate on 60-odd-k miles for the upper bracket of my price range. I like the look of it and seems to have a lot of decent equipment as standard.

Willing to listen to any advice/recommendations that people may have before I embark on a massive lump of regret once again!
Passat. All day long.

Dull as dishwater but designed for big miles.

Jasandjules

72,680 posts

260 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
daemon said:
Passat. All day long.

Dull as dishwater but designed for big miles.
Yep.

Ours will comfortably cruise 4-5 hours each day if needs be.

Get a 130/140bhp Sport and it is enough power to get overtakes done as well.

Debaser

8,636 posts

292 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
I had similar requirements to you (but with a higher annual mileage) and went for a petrol Passat.

It was thousands of pounds less than an equivalent diesel, and thousands of pounds pays for a lot of petrol.

George111

6,930 posts

282 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Volvo S60 D5 . . . not too dull, very, very comfortable, practical and very safe. Cheap to service and run and manual cars will do 40-50 mpg.

H_Kan

4,942 posts

230 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
OpulentBob said:
A friend has an 09 Mazda 6 2.2d. It's great at munching miles (he does Liverpool to Suffolk every weekend), it gets 50-odd mpg everywhere. But it's one seriously boring car. Sitting in it, you could be in any jap car from the last 10 years. It's got iPod connection, climate etc, so it's very good VFM, but it's in Securicor Blue and, again, it's a bit dull for that sort of money IMO. Be interesting with a remap though.

I think a Ford or something German may be a nicer place to be. Or what about a diesel saab 9-5 for reliable comfortable mile munching? (I may be biased) Or a Volvo?

ETA yum
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2012...

Edited by OpulentBob on Tuesday 10th September 22:11
Chap at work has a derv Mazda 6, decent enough car and he gets 45mpg or so with largely town driving.

George111

6,930 posts

282 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Volvo S60 D5 . . . not too dull, very, very comfortable, practical and very safe. Cheap to service and run and manual cars will do 40-50 mpg.

TinyCappo

2,106 posts

184 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
E39 523i? Boring, bombproof, V-comfortable, motorways will see 40mpg and sub £1k Just binned y last one as it had gearbox failure at 235,000 miles get some with sub 150k and it will last you at least another 75 with regular servicing.

£3k for a toy?

confused_buyer

7,143 posts

212 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Agree with posts above - S60 D5 SE Manual ticks every box.

Passats are OK but they don't have the seats, the stereo, the spec, the extra cylinder, the performance and barely match the Volvo on economy. Only bad point against it is rear seat space isn't great.

vexed

403 posts

202 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
I've just bought an Octavia VRS diesel for £5.5k which seems comfortable and pleasant enough, reasonably economical and has some useful torque for a surprising spurt of speed for an overtake. Never going to set the world on fire with blistering pace or exquisite handling though.

ETA: massive boot, if that makes any difference to you.

vexed

403 posts

202 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
I've just bought an Octavia VRS diesel for £5.5k which seems comfortable and pleasant enough, reasonably economical and has some useful torque for a surprising spurt of speed for an overtake. Never going to set the world on fire with blistering pace or exquisite handling though.

ETA: massive boot, if that makes any difference to you.

Edited by vexed on Tuesday 10th September 23:31

mywifeshusband

607 posts

229 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
In your position I'd be tempted by a VW Phaeton, just to be different in a subtle way.

tgr

1,256 posts

202 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
SAAB 9-3 td would be very cheap and comfortable

V8Wagon

1,707 posts

191 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Honda Accord.....very underrated cars imo. I'd go petrol personally but the Honda diesel engine is very well regarded and the spec on the Accord's particularly the EX model is fantastic.


Dan_1981

18,124 posts

230 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Just picked up an 08 plate saab 9-3 for much closer to the bottom of your budget than the top.

Returning 50mpg on the motorway at 75.

Heated leather, cruise, decent stereo, really comfortable - I'm impressed so far.

bildo

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all the recommendations so far, some interesting stuff I really hadn't considered.

Looked at that reliability website too, which was interesting.

The Saab, Volvo and 5 series BMW seem to have the worst ratings on there!

Of all the things the Mazda 6 and the Mondeo had the highest!

Apart from bland interior etc, can anyone tell me the downsides to a Mazda 6 over some of the other recommendations?

Got a 2011 2.2 diesel with 44k on the clock at my local Mazda dealership with full warranty for £10k. Seems like a really good deal to me considering the amount of extras you get as standard etc?

vexed

403 posts

202 months

Tuesday 10th September 2013
quotequote all
I've just bought an Octavia VRS diesel for £5.5k which seems comfortable and pleasant enough, reasonably economical and has some useful torque for a surprising spurt of speed for an overtake. Never going to set the world on fire with blistering pace or exquisite handling though.

james280779

1,931 posts

260 months

Wednesday 11th September 2013
quotequote all
daemon said:
Passat. All day long.

Dull as dishwater but designed for big miles.
mine is a W8 with 305 bhp, not that boring and fantastic for long distances wink