How much below advertised price is acceptable to offer?
Discussion
I'm not sure why this is asked so often (or variants of this question, someone currently asking it in the homes forum too).
Its like everyone just expects a discount. Nobody can say 'offer x less' without seeing the item in question. It might be stupidly over priced, it might have dubious history, or it might be a perfect example priced to sell already.
Post a link to a specific car if you're really looking to buy and someone who knows Ferraris will tell you if its likely a good buy or not.
Its like everyone just expects a discount. Nobody can say 'offer x less' without seeing the item in question. It might be stupidly over priced, it might have dubious history, or it might be a perfect example priced to sell already.
Post a link to a specific car if you're really looking to buy and someone who knows Ferraris will tell you if its likely a good buy or not.
How many threads are there here from people saying 'he made me an insulting offer so I put the phone down' ?
If you can't afford a car do yourself a favour and don't waste your own emotional energy on everything you need to do before making an offer in the way of viewing and assessing
If you can't afford a car do yourself a favour and don't waste your own emotional energy on everything you need to do before making an offer in the way of viewing and assessing
I believe the offer is related to your ability to psychologically manage the purchase process, read the seller and control the operation.
However the variation between max and min acceptable price is probably not very broad.
Normally the seller has a "no less than" price in mind, I know I do.
However saying that, the longer it sits around the more likely that price will get revised. Demand and supply etc.
Go and read up on game theory too..
However the variation between max and min acceptable price is probably not very broad.
Normally the seller has a "no less than" price in mind, I know I do.
However saying that, the longer it sits around the more likely that price will get revised. Demand and supply etc.
Go and read up on game theory too..
Thanks for the reply guys. It's just from reading lots and lots of threads here it seemed that not many people had paid asking price and I just wanted to know was asking price definitely expected or was it more like an offers arround type of arrangement usually.
As you said it probably depends on a number of factors.
As you said it probably depends on a number of factors.
foreverfalling said:
Thanks for the reply guys. It's just from reading lots and lots of threads here it seemed that not many people had paid asking price and I just wanted to know was asking price definitely expected or was it more like an offers arround type of arrangement usually.
As you said it probably depends on a number of factors.
You can offer what you like, it's the seller perogative to say no.As you said it probably depends on a number of factors.
It's just whether you want to be grouped with the people who offer £30k under asking via text without viewing the car......
Without knowing the specifics of the cars you are looking at, in general for used cars like the ones you're looking at, only a mug pays asking. Discount is expected and sellers know this. However... the scale of discount can be huge - anything from a token £500 to a few £k. That is down to how closely the condition of the car matches description, demand for similar cars at the time, sellers motivation to get rid, and how good the buyer is at negotiation. A wise and respected colleague once told me that a good deal is one where both the buyer and the seller feel an equal amount of (mild) discomfort. Find that balance and the price is likely to be reasonably fair to all.
Good luck with your search!
Good luck with your search!
Depends on the car. If it's the cheapest advertised then you are unlikely to get a deal, whereas if its mid or high priced compared to others on the market you are more likely to be able to get some sort of deal on the price and dealers will be expecting bids.
I change cars far too often and in the £60-100k range I've paid full sticker price on some and got as much as £13k off another.
A well priced 430 is unlikely to get much off the sticker as it will probably sell for that, but if you think its over priced then don't be afraid to make a low offer.
I change cars far too often and in the £60-100k range I've paid full sticker price on some and got as much as £13k off another.
A well priced 430 is unlikely to get much off the sticker as it will probably sell for that, but if you think its over priced then don't be afraid to make a low offer.
Forget the Alan Sugar school of negotiation. The best deals are those where both buyer and seller win. And if you see something you really like, and the price is fair, don't nickel and dime, just pay the price, whether cars, houses, whatever. If the price asked is massively inflated you will have already walked away long before emotion takes over.
10 years ago I advertised my 550 to sell. Fortunately I didn't sell it. She is more beautiful than ever.
But I'll never forget the prat who spent nearly 20 minutes on the phone to me telling why I was going to sell my first Ferrari to him, for peanuts. He must have thought he had special hypnotic powers, so convinced was he I would sell him my car. Why did I spend 20 minutes listening to his drivel? Because I was pissing my pants. At the end of the conversation he became angry when I refused to take his phone number. Hilarious.
10 years ago I advertised my 550 to sell. Fortunately I didn't sell it. She is more beautiful than ever.
But I'll never forget the prat who spent nearly 20 minutes on the phone to me telling why I was going to sell my first Ferrari to him, for peanuts. He must have thought he had special hypnotic powers, so convinced was he I would sell him my car. Why did I spend 20 minutes listening to his drivel? Because I was pissing my pants. At the end of the conversation he became angry when I refused to take his phone number. Hilarious.
I usually ask "what would buy the car" to get a feeling of where it's going before we start kicking tyres. People are normally honest and tell you what they expect if they are keen to sell. However every car I have bought (6 this year) varied, some had zero negotiation others I haggled plenty off, if it helps 5% off is nice 10% is very nice, i'm probably thinking about private sales rather than dealers.
Sarnie said:
You can offer what you like, it's the seller perogative to say no.
But it's the wasting of the vendor's time if you have no intention of payinganywhere near a fair market value, that would be annoying.
Sarnie said:
It's just whether you want to be grouped with the people who offer £30k under asking via text without viewing the car......
About a year ago I went to see a classic car on sale at a well respectedmarque specialist; the asking price @ £125K was way above the market value.
In the first instance I phoned them and asked if it was their stock, or being sold by them on commission - I said that if it was their stock, I wouldn't waste my time or theirs coming to see it and besmirch their good reputation by making an offer way under the asking price that they probably wouldn't accept.
They replied that it was on commission and that they would be happy to go over the car with me in detail.
They were very helpful on the day and I liked the car, the only trouble was that
it was probably worth about £80K (which I suspected before I made the journey).
My offer of around that figure was rejected out of hand;
the car is still for sale today and I discovered that it had been for sale for almost two years before I saw it
.ETA. I was selling a used item and had it advertised at £1600 (actually I would have taken a near offer).
I received an email with just one question "Can you do a better price?"
"Yes" I replied, "£1700."
Edited by Elderly on Thursday 12th September 17:18
andysv said:
I usually ask "what would buy the car" to get a feeling of where it's going before we start kicking tyres. People are normally honest and tell you what they expect if they are keen to sell. However every car I have bought (6 this year) varied, some had zero negotiation others I haggled plenty off, if it helps 5% off is nice 10% is very nice, i'm probably thinking about private sales rather than dealers.
Thanks for that very informative post. I was kind of thinking between 5-10% below for first offer...Elderly said:
About a year ago I went to see a classic car on sale at a well respected
marque specialist; the asking price @ £125K was way above the market value.
In the first instance I phoned them and asked if it was their stock, or being sold by them on commission - I said that if it was their stock, I wouldn't waste my time or theirs coming to see it and besmirch their good reputation by making an offer way under the asking price that they probably wouldn't accept.
They replied that it was on commission and that they would be happy to go over the car with me in detail.
They were very helpful on the day and I liked the car, the only trouble was that
it was probably worth about £80K (which I suspected before I made the journey).
My offer of around that figure was rejected out of hand;
the car is still for sale today and I discovered that it had been for sale for almost two years before I saw it
.
So I guess its best not to go to see a car thats well overpriced?marque specialist; the asking price @ £125K was way above the market value.
In the first instance I phoned them and asked if it was their stock, or being sold by them on commission - I said that if it was their stock, I wouldn't waste my time or theirs coming to see it and besmirch their good reputation by making an offer way under the asking price that they probably wouldn't accept.
They replied that it was on commission and that they would be happy to go over the car with me in detail.
They were very helpful on the day and I liked the car, the only trouble was that
it was probably worth about £80K (which I suspected before I made the journey).
My offer of around that figure was rejected out of hand;
the car is still for sale today and I discovered that it had been for sale for almost two years before I saw it
.What would dealers expect to see offered (obviously its car dependant) but would 5%-10% be an acceptable offer at a dealers or offensive?
foreverfalling said:
So I guess its best not to go to see a car thats well overpriced?
What would dealers expect to see offered (obviously its car dependant) but would 5%-10% be an acceptable offer at a dealers or offensive?
If you start asking for a discount on a fairly priced car before you've even seen it you're just going to be treated like a joker, not given the time of day, and probably laughed at if/when the dealer posts about it on piston heads What would dealers expect to see offered (obviously its car dependant) but would 5%-10% be an acceptable offer at a dealers or offensive?

If the car is genuinely overpriced then I don't see the problem in phoning the dealer, expressing interest but making it clear you don't want to waste either of your time - is the price negotiable, and if not there is no need to bother coming in to see it.
foreverfalling said:
Thanks for that very informative post. I was kind of thinking between 5-10% below for first offer...
To the OP. My best freind is getting married next year and he's asked me to help him look for a photographer. Your website portfolio looks great. How about £1,665 for the gig? 
I'm currently selling my F430 and some of the emails I've had are hilarious.
I've had a 'very good, won't find better' trade bid for £17,000 less than the advertised price and also a trade bit of only £4,500 less than the trade price.
As others have said, it really depends on the car, how others are priced in the market and where it sits in relation to the other cars for sale.
Personally I've paid full price for cars knowing that the asking price was a very good deal anyway, others have needed a discount to become a viable option. Each car is individual and needs to be treated that way.
Also don't fool yourself into thinking that because you negotiated 10-15% off a car that you're getting a bargain. As somebody else has said, generally those who buy cheap buy twice.....
I've had a 'very good, won't find better' trade bid for £17,000 less than the advertised price and also a trade bit of only £4,500 less than the trade price.
As others have said, it really depends on the car, how others are priced in the market and where it sits in relation to the other cars for sale.
Personally I've paid full price for cars knowing that the asking price was a very good deal anyway, others have needed a discount to become a viable option. Each car is individual and needs to be treated that way.
Also don't fool yourself into thinking that because you negotiated 10-15% off a car that you're getting a bargain. As somebody else has said, generally those who buy cheap buy twice.....
MogulBoy said:
To the OP. My best freind is getting married next year and he's asked me to help him look for a photographer. Your website portfolio looks great. How about £1,665 for the gig? 
We are used to people trying to get money off our work, but we don't get offended. We meet them and have to try convince people we are worth our price.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



