Brake pads discs ploy

Poll: Brake pads discs ploy

Total Members Polled: 169

I agreed but dont know if they needed change: 1
I agreed, but I'm sure they didnt: 1
The discs/ pads really did need changing: 13
No I said I've only just done them : 13
I said no and checked later: 80
[blank]: 18
Not happened to me: 39
I dont do polls: 12
They didnt say & warn light soon came on: 0
Author
Discussion

saaby93

Original Poster:

32,038 posts

209 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Following on from another thread

'Just a call to let you know your discs are rusty and your pads are worn
As your car's in for service we can change them for you now. They're in stock
It'll save you coming in again'

B'stard Child

31,168 posts

277 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
I guess if you don't maintain your own car - most of the above could apply and you wouldn't be any wiser

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Tell him to text you a photo of them.

Patrick Bateman

13,211 posts

205 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Discs go rusty, that's what they do.

iva cosworth

44,044 posts

194 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Always remember that all parts removed from your car are YOUR property.

So ask for the removed discs and pads to be put in a bag for you to inspect when you get home.

Yes they could just give you someone elses knackered parts but that would be naughty....nono

Shaw Tarse

31,903 posts

234 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Patrick Bateman said:
Discs go rusty, that's what they do.
How do I remove this rust? confused

C. Grimsley

1,381 posts

226 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
iva cosworth said:
Always remember that all parts removed from your car are YOUR property.

So ask for the removed discs and pads to be put in a bag for you to inspect when you get home.


Yes they could just give you someone elses knackered parts but that would be naughty....nono
As a garage owner myself, we always show the customer the parts we remove and should they want to they can take them, most of our customers are repeat ones and trust us but you do get the odd one who wants to see what's what.

Carl

Patrick Bateman

13,211 posts

205 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
How do I remove this rust? confused
An Italian tune-up should do the trick.

Howard-

4,964 posts

233 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Shaw Tarse said:
How do I remove this rust? confused
You drive and apply the brakes a couple of times.



A garage once told me that my pads were "70% worn". I said "Cool, plenty of time before they'll need doing then. Thanks for checking smile" I think the girl on the desk was a bit perplexed.

Mound Dawg

1,931 posts

205 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
I had the opposite with my Punto when it belonged to the wife. Local Fiat Dealer handed the car back after its 20k service and told us that it would need front pads at the next service 10k/1 year later.

The following week I decided to swap the wheels front to rear to equalise the tyre wear and discovered the front pads had 1mm left on them.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Luckily I have never lied to myself about my discs and pads being worn when I service the car.

Herman Toothrot

6,702 posts

229 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
I've had an Audi Independant tell me all discs and pads needed replacing - rear pads yes, rear discs no,Bit worn but still fine. Fronts, absolutely not as I'd replaced discs and pads about 6000miles previously.

ohtari

805 posts

175 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
I work on my own cars, that way I've only my schizophrenia to argue with...

yes

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
To fail a mot the discs have got to be badly corroded to the state that they could brake up or that thin that they could fall apart

Most manufactures have a minimum width which in most cases is over the top

In my experience if the pads are low and you don't think there last till the car comes back in ill change them
Disc wise if there see the new pads our why change them

J4CKO

47,024 posts

231 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
ohtari said:
I work on my own cars, that way I've only my schizophrenia to argue with...

yes
Brakes are a piece of piss on most cars, I dont think any car I could buy would cost me more than £200 to replace all disks and pads, and probably do the fluid as well in that.

stick100

7,017 posts

199 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Brakes are a piece of piss on most cars, I dont think any car I could buy would cost me more than £200 to replace all disks and pads, and probably do the fluid as well in that.
When I was younger my dad used to do his own repairs the same as most other people my dads age at the end of the day it's just nuts and bolts its a shame that more of the modern car enthusiast do at least try I think it's all part of it

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
I do everything on my cars, have been spannering for years. Sadly, anything to do with tyres has to be reluctantly farmed out to a local monkey sanctuary, which I dread.


One of my Michelin Pilot Sports developed a slow leak the other week. I took the wheel off and inspected the tyre thoroughly, and found no puncture. I replaced the valve core, and checked everything I could to no avail, so concluded that it must be leaking from the bead.

I called the nearest monkey sanctuary, and they were fairly quiet and told me to 'come on down.'

When one of the apes was free, he wheeled my car in. First, I had to school him in the jacking point, because as usual they don't know about the fact that you cannot jack Skoda Octavias on the sill (it is not load bearing and it just crushes them) and directed him to the jacking point on a chassis rail underneath.
He grunted that he'd never had to do this on any other car, so without my direction, I would have been one crushed sill down on the deal already.

Once the wheel was off, he took one look at at and said 'oh, sorry - I can't to anything to this tyre anyway - it's illegal I'm afraid.'

I am normally terminally patient with the animals, but on this occasion even I had to splutter 'bwa-ha-haa, what? There's about 3mm left on there, look, it's not even down to the wear bars!'

He actually looked at me like I had just raped his children, and said 'u wot mate? Look, I know what I am talking about, and that is an illegal tyre...'

I just laughed again, shook my head and said 'well, if you're gonna argue the toss, then don't worry about it - just put the wheel back on and I'll go elsewhere.'


He got up, and without a word went off to his toolbox, bringing back a depth gauge. Once inserted into the tyre (and he was very thorough - checking every single bit of tread all the way across rolleyes ) the gauge resolutely failed to show anything less than 3mm hehe

He mumbled something that sounded like 'humph, it looked worse than that' and got on with the job.

He sprayed some soapy water around the bead, and sure enough we saw some small bubbles emanating from the joint.

I then had to interject again, once he had removed the tyre on the machine and was about to paint some beadseal around the rim, that it 'might be an idea to clean up the bead seats with a wire brush, no?' As it was clear to me that there was some wheel corrosion that was probably causing the issue...

Again, this was done with a grudging grunt, and another child / rape withering stare.



Such pain, effort and disappointment for something so trivial. He just wanted to sell me new tyres to replace a pair of perfectly good ones, and not have to faff about with doing some actual mechanical troubleshooting...

It annoys me to think about the amount of Joe Punters who would have just accepted this and spent £300 on new tyres for no need.



(Note: I know exactly how all the tyres are looking, and have a plan to replace these rears at the end of next month, once they are nearer 2mm, and before the bad weather sets in. But then again, I and I guess most people on here are switched on when it comes to our cars, and think about these things all the time...)



Oldsparkplug

10,203 posts

159 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
stick100 said:
When I was younger my dad used to do his own repairs the same as most other people my dads age at the end of the day it's just nuts and bolts its a shame that more of the modern car enthusiast do at least try I think it's all part of it
Your Dad should have shown you what punctuation marks look like and how to use them instead of fiddling with his car.
Personally I do my job then pay someone who is qualified to do theirs...

Ray Luxury-Yacht

8,918 posts

247 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Oldsparkplug said:
stick100 said:
When I was younger my dad used to do his own repairs the same as most other people my dads age at the end of the day it's just nuts and bolts its a shame that more of the modern car enthusiast do at least try I think it's all part of it
Your Dad should have shown you what punctuation marks look like and how to use them instead of fiddling with his car.
Personally I do my job then pay someone who is qualified to do theirs...
Bit harsh from a newbie biggrin

Yes, we endorse and encourage quality in our presentation on this site - but it's not always easy to do so, when posting from a mobile device...



ohtari

805 posts

175 months

Friday 13th September 2013
quotequote all
Oldsparkplug said:
Your Dad should have shown you what punctuation marks look like and how to use them instead of fiddling with his car.
Personally I do my job then pay someone who is qualified to do theirs...
I think every man and petrol head should know how his auto-mobile's flux capacitor conbobulates megawatts into rainbow-pulsion.

I guess that makes you a bit of a sissy.

Also, I don't like your tweed Sir!