Is my landlord trying to rip me off (key cutting)
Is my landlord trying to rip me off (key cutting)
Author
Discussion

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi all,

Lost my keys to my rented flat, one is a "Mul-T-Lock" thing which requires you to show a card to the locksmith before they will cut your keys for you. I just found this out when I went to the locksmith, and he said it would cost £12.

I then rang my landlord to get the card and he said that he would "have to get it cut at his locksmith" and that it would cost £20. I am sure he is making a nice profit doing this.

Is the landlord allowed to stipulate that he provides cut keys? Am I allowed to demand the card so I can get the keys cut?

It's not the price difference that is particularly annoying (although I am a cash-strapped student), but more the fact I think the landlord is trying to make some extra £ from me.

My tenancy agreement says this:

5.7 - Not to alter or change or install any locks on any doors or windows in or about the Property or have any additional keys made for any locks without the prior written consent of the Landlord, such consent not to be unreasonably withheld, and the cost of providing a set of keys for the Landlord to be met by the Tenant

Cheers,

22s

Edited by 22s on Monday 16th September 11:26

UpTheIron

4,058 posts

299 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
£8 for your Landlord to spend his time finding the card and taking it to his locksmith and getting a key cut. Hardly profiteering.

Alternatively he could give you that card and you get an extra copy cut so you can let yourself in next year and steal a load of stuff from the next tenant... not suggesting you would but the purpose of the card and the security key is to stop duplicates being cut so easily.

Tampon

4,637 posts

256 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
No.

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
UpTheIron said:
£8 for your Landlord to spend his time finding the card and taking it to his locksmith and getting a key cut. Hardly profiteering.

Alternatively he could give you that card and you get an extra copy cut so you can let yourself in next year and steal a load of stuff from the next tenant... not suggesting you would but the purpose of the card and the security key is to stop duplicates being cut so easily.
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.

Anyway, enough digression - I'm questioning why he should charge extra at all. The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues, so I doubt he's jumping in the car to get the key cut himself.

P.S. charging a 66% margin for something which a tenant requires is what I would class as profiteering.

insurance_jon

4,099 posts

277 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
it will take about an hour out of his life to sort. working for £8 an hour is hardly profiteering.

Especially if given the volume of properties he is getting daily requests for these.


moustachebandit

1,336 posts

174 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
You lost the keys - so I dont think you can complain. £8 extra ... big deal - hardly exploitation. Why should he be out of pocket replacing something you lost?

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Okay thanks for the replies, opinions duly noted.

Edited by 22s on Monday 16th September 12:37

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Okay thanks for the replies, opinions duly noted.

Edited by 22s on Monday 16th September 12:37

Odie

4,187 posts

213 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
If I lost my keys Id want a new lock put on tbh.

pincher

10,647 posts

248 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
22s said:
The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues
This seems like the crucial part - it's a business for him, so I'd say he was reasonably justified in charging you more than it will actually cost to get done.

As a (rather poor) comparison, I'm sure Audi don't pay their 'technicians' £100-odd an hour to service a car...........

michael1987

42 posts

167 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
22s said:
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.

Anyway, enough digression - I'm questioning why he should charge extra at all. The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues, so I doubt he's jumping in the car to get the key cut himself.

P.S. charging a 66% margin for something which a tenant requires is what I would class as profiteering.
if the key can only be cut by producing this card the LL will know exactly who has keys and who hands them back and who looses them therefore you plan is stupidly flawed.

count yourself lucky its only £20.00.....

SpeckledJim

34,633 posts

284 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Odie said:
If I lost my keys Id want a new lock put on tbh.
At whose cost?

98elise

32,896 posts

192 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
22s said:
UpTheIron said:
I'm questioning why he should charge extra at all. The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues, so I doubt he's jumping in the car to get the key cut himself.

P.S. charging a 66% margin for something which a tenant requires is what I would class as profiteering.
In that case its very cheap. He has to employ a maintenance team to deal with things like this. They definately want paying for their time. Its not all included in your rent.

If he was a landlord with one or two properties, then I can see that he might do it for free, but as a business no way.

The % is nothing to do with it. Its the time and materials he's billing for, not just the materials.

£8 is very reasonable for the time element. If it was an agent they would probably be charging you something like £50-£100!

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
michael1987 said:
22s said:
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.

Anyway, enough digression - I'm questioning why he should charge extra at all. The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues, so I doubt he's jumping in the car to get the key cut himself.

P.S. charging a 66% margin for something which a tenant requires is what I would class as profiteering.
if the key can only be cut by producing this card the LL will know exactly who has keys and who hands them back and who looses them therefore you plan is stupidly flawed.

count yourself lucky its only £20.00.....
No I think you have misunderstood my "stupidly flawed" plan.

The quotation marks around 'lose' were supposed to indicate that I would pretend to lose the keys (i.e. just tell my landlord I had lost them when in fact I still had them). He would then cut me a new set, I give that new set back when I leave and keep the old set.



Odie said:
If I lost my keys Id want a new lock put on tbh.
I dropped them down the drain in the middle of London and there are no identifying features on them so I don't think it's a problem ha.

22s

Original Poster:

6,553 posts

247 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
98elise said:
In that case its very cheap. He has to employ a maintenance team to deal with things like this. They definately want paying for their time. Its not all included in your rent.

If he was a landlord with one or two properties, then I can see that he might do it for free, but as a business no way.

The % is nothing to do with it. Its the time and materials he's billing for, not just the materials.

£8 is very reasonable for the time element. If it was an agent they would probably be charging you something like £50-£100!
Yep, fair point. Think I was just annoyed at the whole situation more than anything.

I see I was being unreasonable.

Thanks everyone.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
22s said:
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.
Hence i'd change the locks when moving in. You can always change them back when you move on smile

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
22s said:
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.
Hence i'd change the locks when moving in. You can always change them back when you move on smile
I can see why, but you'd almost certainly be in breach of your tenancy agreement.

mcflurry

9,192 posts

284 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
Inkyfingers said:
I can see why, but you'd almost certainly be in breach of your tenancy agreement.
How would the LL know? Unless it's an emergency, they've got no reason to test the locks wink

Perec

28,176 posts

253 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
mcflurry said:
Inkyfingers said:
I can see why, but you'd almost certainly be in breach of your tenancy agreement.
How would the LL know? Unless it's an emergency, they've got no reason to test the locks wink
Routine inspections, fire system maintenance and of course emergencies. Most tenancy agreements contain a condition about not changing locks, tenants that ignore it are almost without exception worth getting rid of at the earliest opportunity because they tend to be bolshy smart-arses who consider themselves to be above the contract they have signed. Invariably they are also rather more enthusiastic about their rights than their responsibilities.

I am pleased to see that the OP has now understood that he is not being fleeced. Some tenants never do and apparently believe that when they mess up everyone around them should rush about resolving the situation for them on a pro bono basis.



chr15b

3,467 posts

221 months

Monday 16th September 2013
quotequote all
22s said:
Or alternatively I can "lose" my keys a week before I leave, ask for a new key to be cut, hand in the new set upon leaving the property and keep the old set. Hardly a foolproof system.

Anyway, enough digression - I'm questioning why he should charge extra at all. The guy owns hundreds of properties and has a whole office/maintenance team to deal with these issues, so I doubt he's jumping in the car to get the key cut himself.

P.S. charging a 66% margin for something which a tenant requires is what I would class as profiteering.
what course are you taking at uni, Daily Mail editing?

£8 as a premium, service charge, whatever you want to call it doesn't sound that bad... but 66% makes it sound like a huge amount.