Used car dealer and small claims - help please...
Discussion
Hoping for a bit of advice from the legal guys on here if possible...?
Apologies for the long post but I want to get all the info in.
In May this year I was in the market for a new daily car for general commuting and filling up with DIY junk. I found what looked like a really nice Audi A4 Avant at a dealer not too far from me. Anyway I range the dealer up, the guy seemed nice and genuine and gave me a good verbal description of the vehicle and promised to send me through some pictures . Rather than send the pictures to me directly he ended up putting them up on Autotrader. Anyway, I saw the pics and phoned him back to get a duller description and the car sounded perfect (1 owner, Full ASH etc).
This was all on the Friday afternoon and I knew I wouldn't be able to get over to him until Saturday so he said if I was serious to give him a £500 deposit via CCard and he'd hold the car for me. If when I saw the car it wasn't as described then he would refund it. Again, stupidly, all over the phone and nothing it writing.
So I turned up on Saturday morning and the car was an absolute dog. Damage to every panel, it didn't drive straight. The dealer admitted to some of the bodywork damage which I pointed out but wouldn't budge on getting it repaired. Went back to check all the pictures and the damage was not visible in any of them and he had never mentioned any of it. He also refused to accompany me on a test drive so I could show him how far out the tracking was (he sent me out with the non english speaking car washer....).
I decided the car was nothing like as described and I wasn't prepared to buy it. I politely told him this and he said I'd lose my deposit then. Had a bit of argument but in the end I left. Later that day I requested the deposit refund in writing (stating all the defects and reason for refund request). He declined to refund it.
Since then I have tried to get help from my credit card company who, as the description was verbal, were not really much help.
So I have now started proceedings in the small claims court to which he has issued a defence. Now this is where my two big questions come..
1. In the defence it states they will be applying for the claim to be struck out? Is there anything I need to do to counter this, I can't seem to find the process for this anywhere.
2. The defence has some blatent lies in it for which I have proof against. i.e. he says the deposit was never refundable where as I have an email from him stating that the deposit is refundable if the vehicle was not as described. Do I just issue this evidence for use in the hearing and then discuss it then or can I prove his defence is false before then.
My concern is he will apply to get the case struck out with a false defence when I can prove his defence is false!
Any help would be very much appreciated!
And yes I know it's stupid to leave a deposit on a car without seeing but I can't go back and change that now, I just want to maximise my chances in the small claims process.
Apologies for the long post but I want to get all the info in.
In May this year I was in the market for a new daily car for general commuting and filling up with DIY junk. I found what looked like a really nice Audi A4 Avant at a dealer not too far from me. Anyway I range the dealer up, the guy seemed nice and genuine and gave me a good verbal description of the vehicle and promised to send me through some pictures . Rather than send the pictures to me directly he ended up putting them up on Autotrader. Anyway, I saw the pics and phoned him back to get a duller description and the car sounded perfect (1 owner, Full ASH etc).
This was all on the Friday afternoon and I knew I wouldn't be able to get over to him until Saturday so he said if I was serious to give him a £500 deposit via CCard and he'd hold the car for me. If when I saw the car it wasn't as described then he would refund it. Again, stupidly, all over the phone and nothing it writing.
So I turned up on Saturday morning and the car was an absolute dog. Damage to every panel, it didn't drive straight. The dealer admitted to some of the bodywork damage which I pointed out but wouldn't budge on getting it repaired. Went back to check all the pictures and the damage was not visible in any of them and he had never mentioned any of it. He also refused to accompany me on a test drive so I could show him how far out the tracking was (he sent me out with the non english speaking car washer....).
I decided the car was nothing like as described and I wasn't prepared to buy it. I politely told him this and he said I'd lose my deposit then. Had a bit of argument but in the end I left. Later that day I requested the deposit refund in writing (stating all the defects and reason for refund request). He declined to refund it.
Since then I have tried to get help from my credit card company who, as the description was verbal, were not really much help.
So I have now started proceedings in the small claims court to which he has issued a defence. Now this is where my two big questions come..
1. In the defence it states they will be applying for the claim to be struck out? Is there anything I need to do to counter this, I can't seem to find the process for this anywhere.
2. The defence has some blatent lies in it for which I have proof against. i.e. he says the deposit was never refundable where as I have an email from him stating that the deposit is refundable if the vehicle was not as described. Do I just issue this evidence for use in the hearing and then discuss it then or can I prove his defence is false before then.
My concern is he will apply to get the case struck out with a false defence when I can prove his defence is false!
Any help would be very much appreciated!
And yes I know it's stupid to leave a deposit on a car without seeing but I can't go back and change that now, I just want to maximise my chances in the small claims process.
If the defendant wants to apply to have the claim struck out they need to make a separate application to the court, which will normally list a hearing where both sides get to put their point to a Judge who then makes a decision. It's not supposed to be a trial of the evidence but a hearing where a Judge decides whether there's a genuine claim or defence that may succeed if there is a trial. Sometimes these applications are decided without a hearing.
If it goes to a trial both sides will need to produce witness statements that include copies of all documents, emails, etc and it's partly on that evidence that a Judge decides who is right or wrong.
If it goes to a trial both sides will need to produce witness statements that include copies of all documents, emails, etc and it's partly on that evidence that a Judge decides who is right or wrong.
I assume the OP is in England (and the references below are to the English position). The position is different in Scotland and NI.
The CPR is available here: http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...
If the defendant wishes to apply to strike your claim out, he will have to make an application supported by evidence (which he will need to serve on you). You can file evidence in opposition. The Court will (usually) list a hearing of the application, at which it will hear from the parties, and the district judge will decide whether the case should be allowed to go to a final hearing or not. The relevant rules are: (1) CPR, rule 3.4(2) (the general power to strike out), (2) CPR, part 24 and its accompanying practice direction (summary judgment), and (3) Part 23 (applictions generally).
As for the Defence filed, given there are matters you take issue with, you should probably file and serve a Reply (CPR, rules 15.8 and 16.7). This should deal with the Defence on a point-by-point basis. There are 3 ways to respond to an allegation: (1) admit it, (2) deny it - in which case, you need to say why you deny it, or (3) require the other party to prove it, where you cannot admit or deny the allegation (for example, because the fact in question is beyond your knowledge).
The guidance in the rules as to how to write a statement of case (such as a Defence or Reply) is pretty vague. Although it does not apply directly to the small claims track, the guidance in Appendix 2 to the Chancery Division guide is useful, and you would do well to follow it.
The Chancery Guide can be downloaded here:
http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/rcj-rolls-buildin...
Finally, the Reply needs to have a statement of truth at the end.
[edited to correct typos]
The CPR is available here: http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/procedure-rules/c...
If the defendant wishes to apply to strike your claim out, he will have to make an application supported by evidence (which he will need to serve on you). You can file evidence in opposition. The Court will (usually) list a hearing of the application, at which it will hear from the parties, and the district judge will decide whether the case should be allowed to go to a final hearing or not. The relevant rules are: (1) CPR, rule 3.4(2) (the general power to strike out), (2) CPR, part 24 and its accompanying practice direction (summary judgment), and (3) Part 23 (applictions generally).
As for the Defence filed, given there are matters you take issue with, you should probably file and serve a Reply (CPR, rules 15.8 and 16.7). This should deal with the Defence on a point-by-point basis. There are 3 ways to respond to an allegation: (1) admit it, (2) deny it - in which case, you need to say why you deny it, or (3) require the other party to prove it, where you cannot admit or deny the allegation (for example, because the fact in question is beyond your knowledge).
The guidance in the rules as to how to write a statement of case (such as a Defence or Reply) is pretty vague. Although it does not apply directly to the small claims track, the guidance in Appendix 2 to the Chancery Division guide is useful, and you would do well to follow it.
The Chancery Guide can be downloaded here:
http://www.justice.gov.uk/courts/rcj-rolls-buildin...
Finally, the Reply needs to have a statement of truth at the end.
[edited to correct typos]
Thanks very much for the quick replies guys - very useful and very helpful and clear.
Andy - Ah perfect, The process in plain English. Thank you that's a big help! I was concerned it could just be a case of it getting struck out without me getting any input.
Soovy - Very annoyed with the CC company, won't be using them anymore. And, yes good idea, I will send him a copy of his own email proving his false defence - I had not really considered going directly to him to remind him of it but I guess there's no reason why not.
EW109 - Yes, I am in England so that info is great. Thanks
Andy - Ah perfect, The process in plain English. Thank you that's a big help! I was concerned it could just be a case of it getting struck out without me getting any input.
Soovy - Very annoyed with the CC company, won't be using them anymore. And, yes good idea, I will send him a copy of his own email proving his false defence - I had not really considered going directly to him to remind him of it but I guess there's no reason why not.
EW109 - Yes, I am in England so that info is great. Thanks
NightDriver said:
Thanks very much for the quick replies guys - very useful and very helpful and clear.
Andy - Ah perfect, The process in plain English. Thank you that's a big help! I was concerned it could just be a case of it getting struck out without me getting any input.
Soovy - Very annoyed with the CC company, won't be using them anymore. And, yes good idea, I will send him a copy of his own email proving his false defence - I had not really considered going directly to him to remind him of it but I guess there's no reason why not.
EW109 - Yes, I am in England so that info is great. Thanks
No problem mate.Andy - Ah perfect, The process in plain English. Thank you that's a big help! I was concerned it could just be a case of it getting struck out without me getting any input.
Soovy - Very annoyed with the CC company, won't be using them anymore. And, yes good idea, I will send him a copy of his own email proving his false defence - I had not really considered going directly to him to remind him of it but I guess there's no reason why not.
EW109 - Yes, I am in England so that info is great. Thanks
If he has an ounce of brain he will realise that if you can show he is lying with written evidence then he is bound to lose, and may take a different view.
If you need more help then PM me.
Just an update on this, the infor I received last time was a great help!
I sent a copy of the email where he states 'the deposit is refundable' to him along with a copy of his defence stating the deposit was never refundable. Never heard anything back.
Small claims process has been progressing. I was issued an allocation questionnaire which I submitted to the courts and to the defendant. The defendant never submitted an allocation questionnaire. I then received a court hearing date and a deadline for submitting all evidence and witness statements. I submitted a rather comprehensive package of evidence and witness statement to both the courts and the defendant. The defendant has never submitted any evidence or witness statements, the deadline was 24th December.
So, what is likely to happen? I doubt he defendant will bother even turning up on the day, but if he does I assume he's not going to have an easy time for not submitting the allocation questionnaire or any evidence/statements?
My main concern is that they have actually submitted these items to the court, but just haven't bothered sending me copies. Is there anything I can do regarding this i.e. informing the court I have not received anything?
Any help greatly appreciated!
I sent a copy of the email where he states 'the deposit is refundable' to him along with a copy of his defence stating the deposit was never refundable. Never heard anything back.
Small claims process has been progressing. I was issued an allocation questionnaire which I submitted to the courts and to the defendant. The defendant never submitted an allocation questionnaire. I then received a court hearing date and a deadline for submitting all evidence and witness statements. I submitted a rather comprehensive package of evidence and witness statement to both the courts and the defendant. The defendant has never submitted any evidence or witness statements, the deadline was 24th December.
So, what is likely to happen? I doubt he defendant will bother even turning up on the day, but if he does I assume he's not going to have an easy time for not submitting the allocation questionnaire or any evidence/statements?
My main concern is that they have actually submitted these items to the court, but just haven't bothered sending me copies. Is there anything I can do regarding this i.e. informing the court I have not received anything?
Any help greatly appreciated!
Credit Card companies are jointly and severally responsible.
This means you can pursue either the CC company or the seller or both are responsible and you can pursue at your discretion.
Phone them back and demand a refund under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit act. If they resist escalate the call until you get satisfaction.
http://www.money.co.uk/article/1003471-how-section...
This means you can pursue either the CC company or the seller or both are responsible and you can pursue at your discretion.
Phone them back and demand a refund under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit act. If they resist escalate the call until you get satisfaction.
http://www.money.co.uk/article/1003471-how-section...
Edited by Martin4x4 on Tuesday 14th January 22:33
You'll get sent a hearing date, at which point you will have to prepare a pack with ALL the information in it and submit a copy to the courts and a copy to the defendant.
Then you turn up at the court at the prescribed date and time and have it out in front of the judge. Assuming all your evidence is in order and you can demonstrate that he was going to give you your deposit back if you weren't satisfied with the car when you saw it (which, with your email from him stating that, should be a slam dunk), you win and can claim costs. If not, you lose your £500 notes and have to pay his costs.
Good Luck!
Then you turn up at the court at the prescribed date and time and have it out in front of the judge. Assuming all your evidence is in order and you can demonstrate that he was going to give you your deposit back if you weren't satisfied with the car when you saw it (which, with your email from him stating that, should be a slam dunk), you win and can claim costs. If not, you lose your £500 notes and have to pay his costs.
Good Luck!
Then, after you win, as you almost surely will, you will have the interesting task of actually getting the payment owed. In the end you might have to brief bailiffs, who will add their costs to be paid by the losing defendant. The defendant will deny that he owns any of the stock or assets. He will be 'selling the stock on behalf of others'.
Sorry to be pessimistic, but that what can happen.
Sorry to be pessimistic, but that what can happen.
NightDriver said:
So, what is likely to happen? I doubt he defendant will bother even turning up on the day, but if he does I assume he's not going to have an easy time for not submitting the allocation questionnaire or any evidence/statements?
My main concern is that they have actually submitted these items to the court, but just haven't bothered sending me copies. Is there anything I can do regarding this i.e. informing the court I have not received anything?
Any help greatly appreciated!
There's a number of possibilities:My main concern is that they have actually submitted these items to the court, but just haven't bothered sending me copies. Is there anything I can do regarding this i.e. informing the court I have not received anything?
Any help greatly appreciated!
If the defendant doesn't turn up and hasn't filed any evidence you still need to satisfy the Judge that you're owed the money and this will be on the basis of your documents.
If the defendant has filed evidence but not served it and doesn't turn up the court can consider their evidence but the defendant should have given you notice of this further to CPR27.9 (google is your friend here) and if not the court shouldn't look at it. If this is the case you must make it plain to the Judge that you've had neither notice nor documents (if that is the case).
If the defendant sends you their evidence at the last minute and turns up you can make a fuss about it at court for not having had time to consider it but unless it's something that's mind-glowingly complicated or have been given to you at court on the morning of the hearing the Judge is unlikely to take much issue with it and will just let the matter proceed.
If the defendant turns up not having filed or served anything then that's down to the Judge. Often the directions for the final hearing will say witness statements must be served, but sometimes all they refer to is documents being served. I have had Judges refuse to let parties give evidence orally if they've not complied with directions, or allow them to speak but in their judgment say they've given little weight to their submissions because of the lack of statements / documents.
The point raised about the credit card company also being liable is with pursuing if you've problems getting payment. Whilst you could issue a claim against them I would suggest that, if you win, providing them with a copy of the particulars of claim, claim form, judgment and enough detail of the transaction itself for them to be able to identify it (card number, date of transaction, name of defendant's business) might be enough to prompt payment - if what you've said is correct then they'd not be able to defend a claim against them and hopefully would see that without you needing to issue proceedings.
OP - are you sure he is still trading under the same name?
If so when this gets to court and you are awarded the claim in his absence tell the 'judge' you fear he intends not to pay you and that you want the case escalated to the High Court baliffs as soon as his time runs out to pay.
These boys don't mess around and WILL seize goods to the value of your claim plus costs
If so when this gets to court and you are awarded the claim in his absence tell the 'judge' you fear he intends not to pay you and that you want the case escalated to the High Court baliffs as soon as his time runs out to pay.
These boys don't mess around and WILL seize goods to the value of your claim plus costs
elanfan said:
OP - are you sure he is still trading under the same name?
If so when this gets to court and you are awarded the claim in his absence tell the 'judge' you fear he intends not to pay you and that you want the case escalated to the High Court baliffs as soon as his time runs out to pay.
These boys don't mess around and WILL seize goods to the value of your claim plus costs
Good advice ref the high court bailiffs....will cost you £60 to move it up to them....total amount awarded has to be £600 or more.If so when this gets to court and you are awarded the claim in his absence tell the 'judge' you fear he intends not to pay you and that you want the case escalated to the High Court baliffs as soon as his time runs out to pay.
These boys don't mess around and WILL seize goods to the value of your claim plus costs
Dealer has zero chance of winning the case by the looks of it....I would think if you get heavy woth the credit card provider they will refund you though, they often take pushing to do what they are legally obliged to do.
Thanks all! Great advice from everyone as always.
In hindsight I should perhaps have pursued the CC company harder, but after about 10+ letters backwards and a failed chargeback (it had been defended and rejected by the car dealers bank) it looked unlikely to be a very fruitful route. The sticking point was that I could not prove the description of the vehicle as the significant differences were verbal and so they weren't prepared to do a Section 75 claim. To be honest it seemed the whole case was too complex for the CC company to bother trying to work out. I have however complained to them about their approach and they are actually now offering some assistance, albeit a bit late now!
Andy - Thanks for the info regarding the possible outcomes, really useful. I've tried to be as open and clear with all evidence and statements, the case is very well laid out on paper and so my hope is I won't need to do much talking to convince the judge. It's more about the defendant trying to, well, defend!
They are still operating under the same company and have been for a few years. But I'm pretty much positive that the he will not pay even if I do win, so the CC route after a ruling may be a good one. However, they a pretty good amount lot of stock (maybe none is actually there's...) but also workshop on site.
Total claim is over £600 with fees added. If I do win then I will follow the advice here and go down the high court sheriff route asap as the first port of call.
Court date is set for March so just a case of waiting now I guess.
In hindsight I should perhaps have pursued the CC company harder, but after about 10+ letters backwards and a failed chargeback (it had been defended and rejected by the car dealers bank) it looked unlikely to be a very fruitful route. The sticking point was that I could not prove the description of the vehicle as the significant differences were verbal and so they weren't prepared to do a Section 75 claim. To be honest it seemed the whole case was too complex for the CC company to bother trying to work out. I have however complained to them about their approach and they are actually now offering some assistance, albeit a bit late now!
Andy - Thanks for the info regarding the possible outcomes, really useful. I've tried to be as open and clear with all evidence and statements, the case is very well laid out on paper and so my hope is I won't need to do much talking to convince the judge. It's more about the defendant trying to, well, defend!
They are still operating under the same company and have been for a few years. But I'm pretty much positive that the he will not pay even if I do win, so the CC route after a ruling may be a good one. However, they a pretty good amount lot of stock (maybe none is actually there's...) but also workshop on site.
Total claim is over £600 with fees added. If I do win then I will follow the advice here and go down the high court sheriff route asap as the first port of call.
Court date is set for March so just a case of waiting now I guess.
Just thought I would update this thread for anyone who's interested.
Just got back from my day in court, and I won!
Due in at 10 but didn't get called until nearly 11 which didn't help the nerves! I outlined my case first and went through all the details of the condition of the car and the description etc. Then the defendant got a telling off from the judge for not submitting any witness statements or any information as per the court directions. The judge then immediately picked up on my point of the DSRs applying in which he agreed fully and got the details of the payment from the defendant which confirmed it was a distance transaction. He then let the defendant speak (or dig himself a hole as it turned out) and try to counter my arguments, although rather poorly. When he'd finished the judge simply said, the condition of the ca is actually irrelevant. The DSRs apply, I cancelled as I should have done and the defendant did not follow the regulations. Therefore full payment and costs awarded to me!
The claim started at £500 and is now up to £670 so a lesson learnt from him I guess. Was never really about the money (I'd written it off) but the principal of it all.
Glad I self represented and took it all the way to the court. Very happy with my mornings work.
Just got back from my day in court, and I won!
Due in at 10 but didn't get called until nearly 11 which didn't help the nerves! I outlined my case first and went through all the details of the condition of the car and the description etc. Then the defendant got a telling off from the judge for not submitting any witness statements or any information as per the court directions. The judge then immediately picked up on my point of the DSRs applying in which he agreed fully and got the details of the payment from the defendant which confirmed it was a distance transaction. He then let the defendant speak (or dig himself a hole as it turned out) and try to counter my arguments, although rather poorly. When he'd finished the judge simply said, the condition of the ca is actually irrelevant. The DSRs apply, I cancelled as I should have done and the defendant did not follow the regulations. Therefore full payment and costs awarded to me!
The claim started at £500 and is now up to £670 so a lesson learnt from him I guess. Was never really about the money (I'd written it off) but the principal of it all.
Glad I self represented and took it all the way to the court. Very happy with my mornings work.
NightDriver said:
Just thought I would update this thread for anyone who's interested.
Just got back from my day in court, and I won!
Due in at 10 but didn't get called until nearly 11 which didn't help the nerves! I outlined my case first and went through all the details of the condition of the car and the description etc. Then the defendant got a telling off from the judge for not submitting any witness statements or any information as per the court directions. The judge then immediately picked up on my point of the DSRs applying in which he agreed fully and got the details of the payment from the defendant which confirmed it was a distance transaction. He then let the defendant speak (or dig himself a hole as it turned out) and try to counter my arguments, although rather poorly. When he'd finished the judge simply said, the condition of the ca is actually irrelevant. The DSRs apply, I cancelled as I should have done and the defendant did not follow the regulations. Therefore full payment and costs awarded to me!
The claim started at £500 and is now up to £670 so a lesson learnt from him I guess. Was never really about the money (I'd written it off) but the principal of it all.
Glad I self represented and took it all the way to the court. Very happy with my mornings work.
Well done, that must have been very satisfying (if a complete waste of time for you).Just got back from my day in court, and I won!
Due in at 10 but didn't get called until nearly 11 which didn't help the nerves! I outlined my case first and went through all the details of the condition of the car and the description etc. Then the defendant got a telling off from the judge for not submitting any witness statements or any information as per the court directions. The judge then immediately picked up on my point of the DSRs applying in which he agreed fully and got the details of the payment from the defendant which confirmed it was a distance transaction. He then let the defendant speak (or dig himself a hole as it turned out) and try to counter my arguments, although rather poorly. When he'd finished the judge simply said, the condition of the ca is actually irrelevant. The DSRs apply, I cancelled as I should have done and the defendant did not follow the regulations. Therefore full payment and costs awarded to me!
The claim started at £500 and is now up to £670 so a lesson learnt from him I guess. Was never really about the money (I'd written it off) but the principal of it all.
Glad I self represented and took it all the way to the court. Very happy with my mornings work.
Have you had the money yet? If not, that can be the real test where you actually win or lose.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


