Station parking ticket
Author
Discussion

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
I'd like some advice, please.

I park in a station car park operated by APCOA. I have a current season ticket.

When I was away on holiday, my car was taken into the local dealer. The nanny removed the parking permit in case I would need it for another car when I returned. I did not realise this and parked for a while in the car park without a valid permit (the old one was still in the car).

I inevitably got a ticket.

I appealed by letter, saying I had a valid permit and rather assumed the ticket would be cancelled - I have paid after all. I simply stated I had a valid permit. They just wrote back to say that they were throwing out my appeal and offering three options.
1. Pay up (£50)
2. Appeal to "Parking on Private Land Appeals" (POPLA) - in which case the potential fine goes to £75
3. Do nothing and they will "seek to recover the monies owed to us via our debt recovery procedures and may take Court action against you"

Considering that I have paid to park, I am not minded to pay a fine.

What would my best course of action be from here?

lbc

3,340 posts

248 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
I would guess the terms and conditions of parking state a valid permit must be displayed?

As you did not display a valid ticket the fine is applicable.

Not much different for failing to display valid road fund licence, even though you may have one.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
I would be inclined to ignore it. A court will only find for them if they have suffered a loss. In your case there is no loss as you have paid.

TheBear

1,940 posts

277 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
If the permit states that you must display it when parking then you're stuffed really as it would be a black and white ruling.

If that is the case then don't waste money fighting it.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
lbc said:
I would guess the terms and conditions of parking state a valid permit must be displayed?

As you did not display a valid ticket the fine is applicable.

Not much different for failing to display valid road fund licence, even though you may have one.
This is not the police or local authority. Companies cannot issue fines.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Who issued the parking season ticket?

Streaky

TheBear

1,940 posts

277 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
This is not the police or local authority. Companies cannot issue fines.
It reads that he already has a contract with the parking company and has a permit as a result of that. If one of the conditions is to display it then surely ignoring the fine would be a very bad thing to do?

Maybe need to clear up who has given him the season ticket.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
TheBear said:
If the permit states that you must display it when parking then you're stuffed really as it would be a black and white ruling.

If that is the case then don't waste money fighting it.
Yes but to win in Court the company would need to show a loss. As I said they cannot 'fine' anybody.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
bad company said:
TheBear said:
If the permit states that you must display it when parking then you're stuffed really as it would be a black and white ruling.

If that is the case then don't waste money fighting it.
Yes but to win in Court the company would need to show a loss. As I said they cannot 'fine' anybody.
You are of course in principle correct, However the terms and conditions may allow additional charges if no ticket is displayed. In the circumstances the company could sue for breach of the terms and conditions I suspect. And I think they would then be entitled to charge although again that might depend on the T&C. Up to the OP. I might pay up because the OP clearly admits not displaying the ticket. The OP could try a polite written explanation enclosing a copy of the permit, first. They might rescind the charge, They might not.

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
streaky said:
Who issued the parking season ticket?
APCOA

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Steffan said:
You are of course in principle correct, However the terms and conditions may allow additional charges if no ticket is displayed. In the circumstances the company could sue for breach of the terms and conditions I suspect. And I think they would then be entitled to charge although again that might depend on the T&C. Up to the OP. I might pay up because the OP clearly admits not displaying the ticket. The OP could try a polite written explanation enclosing a copy of the permit, first. They might rescind the charge, They might not.
I have already tried a polite letter pointing out that I had a permit. This enclosed a copy of the valid permit. I didn't give reasons as I didn't want to give them evidence that I wasn't displaying a valid permit. They have a photo of the old permit being displayed.



Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
AstonZagato said:
Steffan said:
You are of course in principle correct, However the terms and conditions may allow additional charges if no ticket is displayed. In the circumstances the company could sue for breach of the terms and conditions I suspect. And I think they would then be entitled to charge although again that might depend on the T&C. Up to the OP. I might pay up because the OP clearly admits not displaying the ticket. The OP could try a polite written explanation enclosing a copy of the permit, first. They might rescind the charge, They might not.
I have already tried a polite letter pointing out that I had a permit. This enclosed a copy of the valid permit. I didn't give reasons as I didn't want to give them evidence that I wasn't displaying a valid permit. They have a photo of the old permit being displayed.
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.

blueg33

46,991 posts

255 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
If terms and conditions cause a penalty then as I understand it the contract is not valid, you cannot have a penalty clause in a contr5act.

APCOA have suffered no loss

They tried to fine me after I parked with a valid ticket outside a marked space at Gloucester station. I caused no obstruction at all.

I ignored all the letters including the fake debt recovery ones. After 6 months they moved on to more gullible folk.

I say ignore. As others have said they cannot prove a loss except (potentially admin charges). They also have to act in a way to minimise the OP's loss so can't keep piling charges on.

Shame op responded to them in the first place

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
Shame op responded to them in the first place
For future reference, how would this help me?
Surely I have some contract with them as I bought a season ticket?

AstonZagato

Original Poster:

14,296 posts

241 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Steffan said:
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.
Any point chancing an appeal to POPLA?

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
If terms and conditions cause a penalty then as I understand it the contract is not valid, you cannot have a penalty clause in a contr5act.

APCOA have suffered no loss

They tried to fine me after I parked with a valid ticket outside a marked space at Gloucester station. I caused no obstruction at all.

I ignored all the letters including the fake debt recovery ones. After 6 months they moved on to more gullible folk.

I say ignore. As others have said they cannot prove a loss except (potentially admin charges). They also have to act in a way to minimise the OP's loss so can't keep piling charges on.

Shame op responded to them in the first place
An alternative view and quite possibly very valid. Without the details of the T&C's I doubt anyone can be absolutely definitive. Up to the OP. I would pay because my secretary would constantly bring this unpaid bill up as instructed by me to do so. I prefer is peaceful if somewhat poorer life and I cannot alter my business standing orders because all bills are examined monthly. By me. Withhout exception. Keeps the ship just above the water of business life. I do think I would pay it: my secretary is very good at admonishion on unpaid bills. By order. That is why I employ her. I need an organiser!

kiethton

14,669 posts

211 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
AstonZagato said:
Steffan said:
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.
Any point chancing an appeal to POPLA?
Yes!

Costs them to defend anything whilst the result is not in any way binding on you so you're free to continue ignoring

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
kiethton said:
AstonZagato said:
Steffan said:
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.
Any point chancing an appeal to POPLA?
Yes!

Costs them to defend anything whilst the result is not in any way binding on you so you're free to continue ignoring
Could you please explain how the negative results of a court case would not be binding on the registered keeper/owner/defendant?

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
Steffan said:
kiethton said:
AstonZagato said:
Steffan said:
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.
Any point chancing an appeal to POPLA?
Yes!

Costs them to defend anything whilst the result is not in any way binding on you so you're free to continue ignoring
Could you please explain how the negative results of a court case would not be binding on the registered keeper/owner/defendant?
It's not a court case wink & smile .

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 26th September 2013
quotequote all
aw51 121565 said:
Steffan said:
kiethton said:
AstonZagato said:
Steffan said:
I presume from this that the company have declined your request, In which case I think you have a problem with non compliance with the T&C's. In which case if the T&C's allow such a charge I would pay it. It is clearly a breach. However the company cannot fine you but they can and probably will enforce their T&C's.
Any point chancing an appeal to POPLA?
Yes!

Costs them to defend anything whilst the result is not in any way binding on you so you're free to continue ignoring
Could you please explain how the negative results of a court case would not be binding on the registered keeper/owner/defendant?
It's not a court case wink & smile .
If the parking co sue the op under their T&C's it would seem it will be a court case to me. I appreciate ignoring the letters is an option but if litigation follows from the parking co I cannot see a contractual defence to failing to comply with the terms. If the terms are reasonable and contain a financial remedy for such a transgression of the terms I can see the OP having a problem. In court very possibly.