Who is at fault in this accident?
Who is at fault in this accident?
Author
Discussion

MMT

Original Poster:

598 posts

217 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all


Car A approaches mini roundabout on unlabelled road from bottom of photo and stops at the white lines to give way to
Car B approaching from opposite direction labelled Peveril Road indicating Right and turns onto Highfield Lane.
A taxi approaches Mini Roundabout from Highfield Lane indicating right to turn onto unlabelled Road.
At the same time Car C approaches from Peveril Road with no indicators.
Taxi waits and gives way to Car A which isn't indicating as going straight across. Car A pulls off and Car C, without indication turns right, and Car A and Car C collide. Car A middle of front bumper and Car C front passenger corner.

Car A claims Car C wasn't indicating and as such thought it was going straight on down the unlabelled road. At first the driver of Car C claimed he was indicating right and Car A is at fault. However, the taxi driver also claims Car C wasn't indicating and just cut straight in front of Car A.
As soon as Car C is aware of taxi drivers claim he changes story and says that he obviously wasn't indicating. Car C smells or alcohol so police are called and breath test reads 20 so under the limit. Police officer issues both parties with the others insurance details and in front of everybody said that Car C had admitted he wasn't indicating and accepts full responsibility for the accident. Taxi driver leaves details with Car A and is prepared to be a witness.

I know this seems a bit long winded but, would anybody (Loon etc) who is experienced in this field please give your thoughts on the possible/probable outcome.

Thanks in advance.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Sorry, I struggled to keep the vehicle references straight in my mind, but failed [the few glasses of Merlot I had with lunch might have contributed to this situation]. Red and green lines might have helped me.

In consequence, I will content myself with the following basic statements:

1) The vehicle established on a roundabout has right of way over vehicles joining from the left (reinforced, or changed, by give way lines/signs).

2) Indicating (or not) should not be taken as any indication [sorry!] of the driver's intention.

Streaky

motco

17,670 posts

277 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Is this not similar to a car waiting to emerge from a side road to turn right, and seeing a car approach from the right with left indicator operating, proceeds to turn only to be hit by the car that was indicating - spuriously, as it happens? I believe there is precedent that puts the blame on the wrongly indicating car even though it was nominally on the major road and could (without the indication) proceed without giving way to the emerging car.

Edit: Have googled a bit and cannot find reference to the incident I describe - it'll probably end up as fault of the car entering the roundabout (A?) I suspect. Verbal admissions are often retracted - people lie, sadly.

Edited by motco on Saturday 28th September 17:20

MMT

Original Poster:

598 posts

217 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for your reply. I will try and simplify the photo with some lines later if I can.
My daughter was driving Car A and believes that she entered the roundabout at the same time as the Car C coming from the opposite direction. Car C then cut across the middle of the painted roundabout straight into her path. The Taxi driver has confirmed this series of events.
I wonder how much weight him admitting liability actually carries? The police officer seemed to think the fact he'd accepted responsibility in a statement to him it would be cut and dry.

Grandad Gaz

5,284 posts

277 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
A similar thing happened to my brother in laws' wife. She pulled out and hit a car which was indicating to turn left but didn't.

She was found to be at fault, although this was some years ago. Things may have changed since then.

swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
As a cynic, I would say that everyone concerned will bail out of what they said at the time and it will probably end up being knock-for-knock between the insurance companies.

Hope it doesn't work out that way. The bottom line is he pulled across her path and she should hammer that point home and not get caught up in who entered the roundabout before who.

sbird

325 posts

209 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
These kind of accidents would probably happen less if drivers turning right just drove straight over the centre of the roundabout. There's one near me that's shaped like that, but the centre of the mini-roundabout is raised.

The common-sense (non-legal) answer is that driver A is at fault.

PV7998

405 posts

165 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
I'm no expert but my guess based on my experience with the few insurance claims I've any knowledge of are that the insurers will give a fair bit of weight to the evidence of the independent witness. Without the witness I would anticipate 50/50 although I'd love to be proved wrong about that because there is a very similar roundabout just up the road from me where, owing to its layout and poor visibility etc, drivers going straight on (as car A was) are often confronted by drivers turning right (as car C was) and about 3 times in the last year I've had a close call, so I'll be interested to see how this goes for you - good luck.

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
As a cynic, I would say that everyone concerned will bail out of what they said at the time and it will probably end up being knock-for-knock between the insurance companies.

Hope it doesn't work out that way. The bottom line is he pulled across her path and she should hammer that point home and not get caught up in who entered the roundabout before who.
Well it's a pretty important part of it as far as the rules for roundabouts are concerned (more so than the former).

R0G

5,037 posts

186 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
The car that was not indicating and turned right was at fault BUT the car it hit was also not driving well because they assumed that another would not go across their path when the speed of the car that hit them could do just that

Never proceed onto a mini when the speed of an another coming from ahead could mean they might turn across your path - that has served me well for years


agtlaw

7,441 posts

237 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Both at fault.

Gwagon111

4,422 posts

192 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
The insurance companies will take care of their own liabilities, like when there's a 'caterpillar' smash, on a motorway, or maybe a bridge in kent scratchchin.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
sbird said:
These kind of accidents would probably happen less if drivers turning right just drove straight over the centre of the roundabout.
Thereby potentially committing an offence and landing themselves in greater trouble.

There is a mini-roundabout not far from me that is offset from the centreline of the major road (it's a 'T' junction). Needless to say, a large number of drivers straightline it, with the centreline of their vehicles passing to the right of the centre of the bullseye.

Streaky

MMT

Original Poster:

598 posts

217 months

Saturday 28th September 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for all your replies. thumbup I have a few more facts.
My daughter has just started work in Newark, about 50 miles from home and has rented a place close to work which she plans to stay in part of the week and was due to move in tomorrow. So this couldn't have happened at a worse time.
As a result of this crash I've taken her to work early this morning and picked her up again this evening.
Talking to her some more about this on the drive home, she believes she entered the roundabout first but did so cautiously because she was conscious the Taxi driver may pull out. She reckons the car that hit her was still only approaching the roundabout at this point. This is actually quite a tight roundabout and you need to be travelling fairly slowly to go round it properly. According to my daughter he didn't appear to slow that much and then drove straight over the roundabout, which isn't much more than a white painted circle, rather than go round it.
This does fit in with the taxi drivers account. He said he was waiting because it was my daughter right of way and he was in prime location to witness the whole event.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

182 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
My guess would be 50:50.
Even on a small roundabout there's normally space to see other cars and brake.

Car C at fault for not signalling
Car A at fault for not giving way to traffic on roundabout.

It sounds like car A gave way to car B that went straight on, then pulled out assuming car c would follow car b.
(I think I have my car letters correct.).

It's as close to 50:50 S it needs to be.

As an aside, it's things like this that make me prefer the North American 4 way stop system. You all stop - then take it in turns to go.
There's no silly dice roll of priority like we have on mini roundabouts here when all entrances are full.

Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
MMT said:
Car C then cut across the middle of the painted roundabout straight into her path. The Taxi driver has confirmed this series of events.
This needs to be emphasised to the insurance company. It would be interesing to see the exact point of inmpact for the vehicles on the may. The arrows made it mandatory to go around the painted button.

If it is the case that Car C cut the roundabout them it could easily be argued that it was on the wrong side of the road and a reasonable driver would not have done or expected another to do this. Th

Futuramic

1,763 posts

236 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
I was almost involved in an identical collision a couple of years ago. Although in my case I reacted by flooring it and somehow steering round the front of the other car. The circumstances were the same, I intended to go straight on and the approaching car wasn't signalling. It suddenly turned right - but I avoided it rather than crashing.

It sucks - because you feel that you've done nothing wrong. But you have, legally, if you've failed to give way to the right. Indication doesn't necessarily mean anything; if I recall correctly. In this example Car C, even though it didn't indicate, could legitimately expect Car A to yield and allow it to turn right. The driver of Car A assumed it would go straight ahead, reasonably in my opinion, however the driver did assume - which means she was partially at fault for the crash as she reacted wrongly to the situation.

I know that most of us, me included, would have done the same. However if it went to court a decent solicitor would argue that Car A should have assessed the situation and concluded there were two possible outcomes. Either Car C went straight ahead, or it would turn right. At the time Car C wasn't indicating; so either outcome was possible. The absolutely correct thing to do was stop and wait to see what Car C did.

However....

You say that Car C cut across the front of Car A. You need to consider the fact that IF Car A had already entered the roundabout; Car C should have stopped. All traffic, regardless of priority, must give way to cars already on the roundabout. So if Car A was already committed to the manouevre before Car C entered the roundabout then Car C is totally at fault. I'd suggest pursuing that line; otherwise it will go fifty fifty; or even completely against the driver of Car A if they argue in the way I suggested earlier.

swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Well it now appears car A was the first on the roundabout so that car C is more at fault. All it needs is the taxi driver to say so.

MMT

Original Poster:

598 posts

217 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
Thanks again for all the comments. She is adamant she was on the roundabout first. She uses this roundabout many times a week and did so when she was having lessons. When the accident happened my daughter was really upset and the guy came across opened her door and was shouting that he was indicating right. She was frightened by this and didn't want to argue that he wasn't indicating so slammed the door and locked it and phoned her Mum as we only live just round the corner. When we arrived a few minutes later the first thing the guy said to me was that he was indicating. Then the taxi driver came across with his name and number on a piece of paper and said he'd seen it all and that the guy didn't indicate. I rang the Taxi driver later and he's happy to be a witness and it would seem his account of what happened is how my daughter saw it. I have printed off some Google maps of the area and made some notes of what happened. Also, based on advice in a few post, I've high lighted the fact she had entered the roundabout first, she was indicating properly in accordance with the Highway Code and that the other driver wasn't.
I'll feed back as things progress.

Sargeant Orange

3,207 posts

178 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
MMT said:
Car A middle of front bumper and Car C front passenger corner.
I was going to say 50/50 until this point. From this I would take the view that Car C was established on the roundabout and Car A should not have proceeded.