106 GTi Replacement.
Author
Discussion

rossnunn

Original Poster:

4 posts

158 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Hi guys & girls.

I currently own a 106 Gti that's been played with so it lowered & had a few cosmetic changes so it could be classed as near full on boy racer.
However age of both it & me have caught up & with 130k on the clock I'm starting to think its time to let it go. I'm finding more & more bits are starting to break & the ride is too hard for the local back roads.
The trouble is what to replace it with?
The GTi maybe considered abit slow these days but to me the on-cam performance still makes me smile.
What ever I replace it with would need to be as new as possible minimum age would be 2001 & it still needs to be fun - as I do the odd track day.
The other problem is I have this stupid rule that you should always buy the top of the range of that particular model. So for example if your in the market for a petrol 3 door BMW 3 series & don't buy the M3.......
Finally the budget. No more than £2k - impossible??

I'd love your feedback.

tailspin

5 posts

171 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Clio 172/182 should fit the bill

Bisonhead

1,598 posts

220 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
rossnunn said:
Hi guys & girls.

I currently own a 106 Gti that's been played with so it lowered & had a few cosmetic changes so it could be classed as near full on boy racer.
However age of both it & me have caught up & with 130k on the clock I'm starting to think its time to let it go. I'm finding more & more bits are starting to break & the ride is too hard for the local back roads.
The trouble is what to replace it with?
The GTi maybe considered abit slow these days but to me the on-cam performance still makes me smile.
What ever I replace it with would need to be as new as possible minimum age would be 2001 & it still needs to be fun - as I do the odd track day.
The other problem is I have this stupid rule that you should always buy the top of the range of that particular model. So for example if your in the market for a petrol 3 door BMW 3 series & don't buy the M3.......
Finally the budget. No more than £2k - impossible??

I'd love your feedback.
Welcome to the forums!

I had a 106 GTi as my first car. They are a great introduction into the world of performance motoring IMO and do still feel pretty nimble, even by todays standards. Thank the light weight for this!

I would suggest a Clio sport of some kind, similar car but slightly faster and 'newer'. Should find a good un for £2000.

Similarly, a SEAT Leon Cupra will be in your range.

If you fancy taking a chance I think Imprezas are now dipping into that money. See also Celica GT4s et al.

Alternatively, a Volvo R or T5 model will easily come into this price bracket.

My left field car of choice would be a Jag XJR.

Granted, some of these wont meet your post-2001 tick box but at this price range you might need to rethink the age and by on condition.

HTH



k-ink

9,070 posts

210 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Very strange suggestions so far!

Having owned a 106 GTI back when they were new I also have fond memories of them. The best thing about those cars was the kart like steering and handling. Sadly most cars aside from the Elise or Caterhams will be left somewhat lacking in compsrison. The closest thing in a normal car would be a DC2 Integra, T190 Celica, not much else. Many other cars will feel like huge wallowing lumps in comparison.

andymc

7,626 posts

238 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
172 cup?

Baryonyx

18,292 posts

190 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
That is true, they are some of the very best handling cars around and offer great feedback (even moreso in the Rallyes), so most things will feel a bit 'soft' afterwards!

k-ink

9,070 posts

210 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Indded. When I bought a new 111R Elise back in the day I said to myself; "This is the best handling car I have owned since my 106 GTI".

Suggestions of fat family wagons and rep mobiles will only end in vast dissapointment. There is so much more to fun driving than BHP alone. Lightweight is the holy grail, it really is.

Buff Mchugelarge

3,316 posts

181 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
k-ink said:
Indded. When I bought a new 111R Elise back in the day I said to myself; "This is the best handling car I have owned since my 106 GTI".

Suggestions of fat family wagons and rep mobiles will only end in vast dissapointment. There is so much more to fun driving than BHP alone. Lightweight is the holy grail, it really is.
Amen brother!

WillG

87 posts

222 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
I had a 106 S2 Rallye and went to a 172 cup, the cup is a great car but does lack the ultimate involment of the 106, as most things do though.

If you want a slightly more grown up 106, you could consider a 306 gti /rallye. Pushing your age criteria, but £2k will get a very good one, slower than the cup but with familiar pug involvement. I brought one as a cheap run around, enjoyed it so much kept it for nearly 5 years, and only sold it when I got a Caterham!

Or you try something mid-engined like a mk3 MR2?

rallycross

13,758 posts

268 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Great little cars - could you just keep it and buy something cheap for running around in like a 6 cylinder big mileage BMW, and use the 106 Gti for weekend blasts and track days. Your £2k won't get you anything decent that will feel more fun than the 106 Gti.

deltashad

6,731 posts

228 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Agree with most comments, have you thought about spending as few quid on the Pug and making it look standard, then upgrade the performance a little? Maybe put the standard shocks and springs back on.

I really like these little cars. My cousin had an early 106xsi back in the day, it was great fun to drive!

pti

1,866 posts

175 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
What about it's big brother? In Rallye guise. Doesn't satisfy your age criteria but as another poster said, at your budget I'd be buying on condition rather than age.

Matt UK

18,084 posts

231 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
tailspin said:
Clio 172/182 should fit the bill
My thoughts exactly

Freddy88FM

474 posts

165 months

Sunday 29th September 2013
quotequote all
Had my 106 for seven years and still going strong (albeit with a lot of help from my wallet). Good luck finding something equally able put a smile on your face - it will exist but I'm not sure where!

However, on another note - what's happening to your current car? Would you be willing to sell a few bits and bobs from it?

rossnunn

Original Poster:

4 posts

158 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
Well I have to admit I wasn't expecting that. - to keep the 106.
The problem I have with it is just the amount it would need to have spent on it.
Because the roads are just so bad round here, it really needs raising back up & I'd like to replace every bush & joint in the suspension, front & rear while it's apart.
Even when it's done it's still a old car now so it squeaks & rattles like a told tin can - things I put up with, even appealed to me when I first got it, but now just annoys me.
The trouble is I used to drive much newer vans for work & even them feel better built. It's not until you get in something new you suddenly realise how far the came had moved on.
I understand I'll loose some of the precision in the handling department but also a enthusiastic driver - I'm now Jenson Button.

TankRizzo

8,028 posts

224 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/h...

What about an EP3 CTR? Around the £2k mark now.

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
WillG said:
If you want a slightly more grown up 106, you could consider a 306 gti /rallye. Pushing your age criteria, but £2k will get a very good one, slower than the cup but with familiar pug involvement.
Is that still the case? Prices for the good ones seemed to be rising at an alarming rate last time I looked.

Curious to hear the GTi vs Clio comparisons. I've driven most of the other quick Pugs, but not the 106 GTi.

Only driven a 182 briefly, but it struck me a as a really good hot hatch. And the fact that some people claim remarkably good economy figures from the 182 (40+ mpg on the motorway) would sway it in the Clio's favour for me as a daily driver.

ETA Maybe the GTi6s hadn't gone up quite as I suspected. Sounds like a pretty honest example for £1.5k: http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/p...

Edited by Chris71 on Monday 30th September 14:24

chevronb37

6,472 posts

217 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
Vote for the 306 Rallye here. Much more fun and playful to drive than an EP3.

Krikkit

27,938 posts

212 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
rossnunn said:
Well I have to admit I wasn't expecting that. - to keep the 106.
The problem I have with it is just the amount it would need to have spent on it.
Because the roads are just so bad round here, it really needs raising back up & I'd like to replace every bush & joint in the suspension, front & rear while it's apart.
Even when it's done it's still a old car now so it squeaks & rattles like a told tin can - things I put up with, even appealed to me when I first got it, but now just annoys me.
The trouble is I used to drive much newer vans for work & even them feel better built. It's not until you get in something new you suddenly realise how far the came had moved on.
I understand I'll loose some of the precision in the handling department but also a enthusiastic driver - I'm now Jenson Button.
Shocks, springs, bushes and steering bits can all be done in a couple of days of slow home-tinkering, or a day in a garage. Decent pattern parts are out there for peanuts these days. The difference between tired and fresh is immense too.

k-ink

9,070 posts

210 months

Monday 30th September 2013
quotequote all
If you get a type r it really has to be an old proper one. Those EP3 have zero steering feel.