Commuting Dilemma
Author
Discussion

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Looked up the price of train season tickets today. I have a 50 mile each way commute, and currently lift share for the second half of the journey so average about 320 miles per week getting to work and back. Now, if I started getting the train to work it would save me about £850 in fuel alone, not including tyres, servicing, maintenance, insurance etc. I can cycle to the station so no parking fees to worry about, might get wet now and then but not fussed about that. Adds about 10-20 mins onto the journey time.

My commute is mind numbingly dull, along the M2 from medway to thanet and back, so it's not as if it's a particularly enjoyable drive. But getting a train isn't much fun either.

So, in this situation, would you continue driving or bite the bullet and commit to getting the train?

Man maths tells me that the reduced milage I would be doing means I could sell the Passat and buy an M5 or something. But not sure my wife would see it that way laugh


Aftershox

397 posts

188 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Saving £850 a month? It's a no brainer for me atleast! Get the train, get a paper and it will be enjoyable!

anonymous-user

84 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
£850 a year presumably? Buy an ipad or something and fill it with films, tv shows etc and watch the commute fly by!

I love my car, but that's far too big a saving to ignore!

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Aftershox said:
Saving £850 a month? It's a no brainer for me atleast! Get the train, get a paper and it will be enjoyable!
Sorry £850/year, about £70 per month.

Crusoe

4,124 posts

261 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Try it for a week and see; you might not get a seat, train might be late or unreliable, might not fit in with your schedule if you don't work set hours, you might miss being able to drive to go out for lunch etc. Sounds like a decent saving though so got to be worth a try.

jdw1234

6,021 posts

245 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
How much does £70 per month mean to you?

Can you do any work on the train to maximise your time?


lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
jdw1234 said:
How much does £70 per month mean to you?

Can you do any work on the train to maximise your time?
£70 isn't a huge amount but I'd much rather spend it on a nice meal out with Mrs. Lufbramatt than giving it to the oil companies and the tax man.

Can't really work anywhere outside my office due to software licenses etc. But I can't work while I'm driving either. Shops are only a 5 min walk from work so don't bother taking the car if I go out at lunch anyway. I think I'll try it for a week, see how it works. My boss seems open to adjusting my hours to work around the train timetable.

Edited by lufbramatt on Tuesday 1st October 13:23

Engineer1

10,486 posts

239 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Even at £70 a month get a kindle / tablet or an iPod fill it with books, films, audio books etc and use the time on the train as chill time.

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Once you figure in 15000 miles worth of wear of a set of tyres (0.75*£280) then it makes the annual saving over a grand.

Snowboy

8,028 posts

181 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Get the train.
But, reserve the right to drive occasionally if the situation or whether makes it a better choice.

I guess it depends on the season ticket train price.

MX7

7,902 posts

204 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
I don't mind trains as long as I have something to read and the radio. Take into account car maintenance, and you're probably closer to £1k.

MonkeyDust

77 posts

164 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Take the train and buy a sports car. Motorway commutes can suck the will to live out of anyone.

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

209 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Move house, get another job, or give up work entirely and sponge off the rest of us

No amount of money is worth sharing a big metal tube with other stinky humans every day

THP150

355 posts

181 months

Tuesday 1st October 2013
quotequote all
Going that way i.e. not to London should be not to busy, but depends on time of day.

lufbramatt

Original Poster:

5,689 posts

164 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
Got a weekly ticket on Monday to see if it would work or not, result is, wish I had started doing this ages ago.

The train is half empty as I'm going away from London in the morning, gets a bit busier towards the end of the journey as the college kids get on 2 stops before I get off but they seem ok, good banter with them actually. Enjoying doing more cycling, about 9 miles per day to and from the stations. Having to get up half hour earlier, but means I get to work 20 mins earlier and can sit and have breakfast on the train. Only getting home 10 mins later as well. Going to be getting through lots of books :-)

Main thing is I'm finding I'm a hell of a lot less stressed when I get in! The fact I'm saving money is a welcome bonus too.

Krikkit

27,938 posts

211 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
Nice, lots more relaxation to be had on the train if you can do it - catch up on a bit of sleep, read a book, enjoy a TV series etc. Much better than horrid motorways anyway!

Craikeybaby

12,152 posts

255 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
Result! I love cars/driving, but hate commuting, I'm now walking to work, it takes a bit longer and I may get wet if it rains, but I'm saving money and its good to clear my head before/work.

MX7

7,902 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
Sounds far better.

Enjoy the M5. smile

creampuff

6,511 posts

173 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
If it were me, it would go like this:

Start off driving. Get pissed off with driving.

Buy monthly ticket on train. Get pissed off with train being late and overcrowed.

Drive. Pissed off with driving.

Train. Pissed off with train.

You get the picture biggrin

HeWhoDaresRoy

513 posts

246 months

Thursday 10th October 2013
quotequote all
I do Margate to Lewisham everyday in the car - A2-M2-A2......boring, but is about 30-40 minutes quicker than taking the train.

I tend to chose my method of commute by how long it takes, so for me it would depend on whether saving £70 a month was worth 'losing' 20-40 minutes a day, in your case.