Ed Miliband's Energy Price Freeze
Discussion
I'm interested in finding out what the views are on this policy from business owners. I think I'm blinded by having too much knowledge of energy prices and how the industry works.
If you missed it. Ed Miliband said that he will freeze energy prices from July 2015 to March 2017 i.e. 20 months. So far he has given no more detail as to how he will achieve this and also what he means by "freeze" and what he means by "energy prices". He has however said it will apply to Consumers AND Business.
To me it seems a pointless policy. If you are worried that prices will rise continually until March 2017 then you can already take out a "fix to March 2017" with nPower for consumers (currently rated by moneysavingexpert.com as the cheapest long term fix) or with any of the energy companies if you are a business. This is normal and hence his policy already exists in the market place for those who want to freeze how much they pay.
However on the flipside 77% of tenants (I don't know the percentage for business) have never switched provider per an OFGEM report in September 2013 and if they did they would save an average of £190 whereas Ed is only suggesting you would save £120 over that specific 20 month period.
So to me it seems that the energy market isn't broken it's the consumer/business's that need educating on how to switch supplier. Uswitch, comparethesoddingmeerkat, gocompare etc all spend millions encouraging you to switch supplier yet 77% remain where they are paying over the odds.
So what were your initial thoughts on hearing the announcement and what if any effect will it have on you personally and in business?
If you missed it. Ed Miliband said that he will freeze energy prices from July 2015 to March 2017 i.e. 20 months. So far he has given no more detail as to how he will achieve this and also what he means by "freeze" and what he means by "energy prices". He has however said it will apply to Consumers AND Business.
To me it seems a pointless policy. If you are worried that prices will rise continually until March 2017 then you can already take out a "fix to March 2017" with nPower for consumers (currently rated by moneysavingexpert.com as the cheapest long term fix) or with any of the energy companies if you are a business. This is normal and hence his policy already exists in the market place for those who want to freeze how much they pay.
However on the flipside 77% of tenants (I don't know the percentage for business) have never switched provider per an OFGEM report in September 2013 and if they did they would save an average of £190 whereas Ed is only suggesting you would save £120 over that specific 20 month period.
So to me it seems that the energy market isn't broken it's the consumer/business's that need educating on how to switch supplier. Uswitch, comparethesoddingmeerkat, gocompare etc all spend millions encouraging you to switch supplier yet 77% remain where they are paying over the odds.
So what were your initial thoughts on hearing the announcement and what if any effect will it have on you personally and in business?
I can't see how it can be done.
Wherever fuel has to be bought in, it's got to be sold at a profit. If they don't make a profit for however many months then the cost is going to rise even more sharply once the 'freeze' ends.
I'd have more faith if he'd suggested capping the profits or margins in some way.
It'll be interesting to see who believes that he can pull it off. Certainly the few interviews I saw many of the general public were somewhat dubious. Retired minors around here obviously will, because it's Labour.
Wherever fuel has to be bought in, it's got to be sold at a profit. If they don't make a profit for however many months then the cost is going to rise even more sharply once the 'freeze' ends.
I'd have more faith if he'd suggested capping the profits or margins in some way.
It'll be interesting to see who believes that he can pull it off. Certainly the few interviews I saw many of the general public were somewhat dubious. Retired minors around here obviously will, because it's Labour.
I expect it went something like this:
Labour think-tank: 'We have no ideas. Let's go and ask the public what issues are important to them'.
Labour canvasser: 'Hello passing voter, what issues are important to you?'
Passing voter: 'Well I mean blimey guv'nor the energy prices are going up something chronic and all that'
Labour canvasser: 'Top hole, wait until I get this back to the boys'.
Labour think-tank: 'Top hole, feedback from da streets. Wallace Milliband has to go for this one'.
Milliband: 'We'll freeze energy prices'.
Bingo.
Labour think-tank: 'We have no ideas. Let's go and ask the public what issues are important to them'.
Labour canvasser: 'Hello passing voter, what issues are important to you?'
Passing voter: 'Well I mean blimey guv'nor the energy prices are going up something chronic and all that'
Labour canvasser: 'Top hole, wait until I get this back to the boys'.
Labour think-tank: 'Top hole, feedback from da streets. Wallace Milliband has to go for this one'.
Milliband: 'We'll freeze energy prices'.
Bingo.
There are a number of questions that need to be answered:
• When will prices be frozen?
• What mechanism will be used to set the price?
• What happens to the spot market?
• What happens to renewables and carbon reduction incentives?
• What will happen with planned transmission, distribution taxes and levy increases?
It just isn't likely to work though...
For a start gas prices have a large impact on electricity prices and the gas price is set on the world market, the only way you could freeze prices is to do it at a significantly high level to ensure gas could always be bought lower and then supplier risk premiums would have to be built in on top.
Also, a main driver for recent price increases has been Governament policy, which is set to increase prices even further.
'If' the price freeze impacts on suppliers profits, this means there will be less investment in new generation by suppliers leading to extended Government funding.
Obviously just a few main reasons, in my opinion.
One last thing to note is that the market hasn't reacted to the suggestion so shows that the general view is that it won't work.
• When will prices be frozen?
• What mechanism will be used to set the price?
• What happens to the spot market?
• What happens to renewables and carbon reduction incentives?
• What will happen with planned transmission, distribution taxes and levy increases?
It just isn't likely to work though...
For a start gas prices have a large impact on electricity prices and the gas price is set on the world market, the only way you could freeze prices is to do it at a significantly high level to ensure gas could always be bought lower and then supplier risk premiums would have to be built in on top.
Also, a main driver for recent price increases has been Governament policy, which is set to increase prices even further.
'If' the price freeze impacts on suppliers profits, this means there will be less investment in new generation by suppliers leading to extended Government funding.
Obviously just a few main reasons, in my opinion.
One last thing to note is that the market hasn't reacted to the suggestion so shows that the general view is that it won't work.
iacabu said:
There are a number of questions that need to be answered:
When will prices be frozen?
What mechanism will be used to set the price?
What happens to the spot market?
What happens to renewables and carbon reduction incentives?
What will happen with planned transmission, distribution taxes and levy increases?
It just isn't likely to work though...
More fundamentally, what about: what happens when wholesale prices exceed the retail price cap?When will prices be frozen?
What mechanism will be used to set the price?
What happens to the spot market?
What happens to renewables and carbon reduction incentives?
What will happen with planned transmission, distribution taxes and levy increases?
It just isn't likely to work though...
LooneyTunes said:
More fundamentally, what about: what happens when wholesale prices exceed the retail price cap?
yep. makes you wonder if Miliband understands anything about the way the wholesale power market works?oh hang on he was Minister for Energy so you would have thought he must know something about it.
Clearly he never bothered understanding that bit of the job
So one way in which I think he can fulfill his election promise without having to alter how the energy market works in anyway is to simply require the Energy Companies (particularly the Big 6) to offer exactly what they already offer and that is fixed price tariffs with a fixed length period. i.e. if he makes them all offer an extra tariff in their range of tariffs at whatever the then current market price is for the period Aug-15 to Mar-17 (his 20 months as promised). He then just has to announce that he has frozen energy prices and all you have to do Mr Consumer is to switch to the new "Red Ed" tariff that's now available to all customers.
He hasn't promised to lower prices - so there will still be cheaper tariffs I would expect.
He hasn't promsied a universal price - so if your current deal at the time is cheaper then stick with that.
He hasn't promised to lower prices - so there will still be cheaper tariffs I would expect.
He hasn't promsied a universal price - so if your current deal at the time is cheaper then stick with that.
It's probably the wrong solution to a real problem.
In lord knows how many years since it was privatised the promised competitiveness hasn't come, not enough consumers are switching suppliers - prices 'rise like a rocket and fall like a feather' and energy companies margins rise constantly. I wouldn't be a surprise if there is a far too pally relationship between them.
A freeze is just pointless though, they'll more than likely set their prices at the limit, remove all the extras like Nectar points and the like and effectively kill the market - the point of switching be reduced to choosing your favourite colour of bill.
In lord knows how many years since it was privatised the promised competitiveness hasn't come, not enough consumers are switching suppliers - prices 'rise like a rocket and fall like a feather' and energy companies margins rise constantly. I wouldn't be a surprise if there is a far too pally relationship between them.
A freeze is just pointless though, they'll more than likely set their prices at the limit, remove all the extras like Nectar points and the like and effectively kill the market - the point of switching be reduced to choosing your favourite colour of bill.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



king idiotic politician leading a pathetic party of champagne socialists, who are trying to make the self-entitled losers of this country get more for doing LESS.