Goodwill purchased - how long to write off?
Discussion
Client has stumped me with accountancy questions - he seems sure that he can reduce his p&l by the cost of a business purchase costs in 2 years. I'm not so sure, but don't have any expertise in this - just seems a bit fishy.
Company A purchases a service business from person B for £100. The business is essentially goodwill in person B, and the value to company A is that person B is under a restrictive covenant for 2 years to only work through Company A.
In very basic terms, can Company A write off the cost of purchasing the goodwill over the 2 years (i.e. can it reduce it's p&l by £50 each year), or does it need a longer period? Are there any minimum/maximum periods for writing off the purchase cost or would it be dependent on the length and enforceability of the restrictive covenants?
I appreciate it's always more complicated than it first seems and will be pushing the client to get proper advice, but need to understand the basics myself.
Thanks in advance.
Company A purchases a service business from person B for £100. The business is essentially goodwill in person B, and the value to company A is that person B is under a restrictive covenant for 2 years to only work through Company A.
In very basic terms, can Company A write off the cost of purchasing the goodwill over the 2 years (i.e. can it reduce it's p&l by £50 each year), or does it need a longer period? Are there any minimum/maximum periods for writing off the purchase cost or would it be dependent on the length and enforceability of the restrictive covenants?
I appreciate it's always more complicated than it first seems and will be pushing the client to get proper advice, but need to understand the basics myself.
Thanks in advance.
So company A pays company B for a service/asset. What is the value of that asset after year 1/2/. I think that should define the writedown model. If B is restricted for 2 years, then wouldn't it be a case of no writedown until the restriction is lifted.
I wonder how party B runs this through their books?
All sounds very fishy. How does goodwill and restriction fit together? I think tax man would frown on this?
I wonder how party B runs this through their books?
All sounds very fishy. How does goodwill and restriction fit together? I think tax man would frown on this?
Told you it sounded fishy!
B is a sole trader and is selling his business to company A. He will then work for A and is also subject to the restrictive covenant.
Presumably B will pay cgt on the sale of the business and income tax etc on earnings.
A wants to reduce profits so wants to write off the goodwill element over the two years. They seem to think it is all figured out - my role is just to document the sale so not really an issue for me, but want to understand it all a bit better as I'd rather let them know now if it is likely to cause problems.
B is a sole trader and is selling his business to company A. He will then work for A and is also subject to the restrictive covenant.
Presumably B will pay cgt on the sale of the business and income tax etc on earnings.
A wants to reduce profits so wants to write off the goodwill element over the two years. They seem to think it is all figured out - my role is just to document the sale so not really an issue for me, but want to understand it all a bit better as I'd rather let them know now if it is likely to cause problems.
HMRC allows the writing off (amortisation) of GENUINE Goodwill created on the purchase of a business over a reasonable period of time.
In order to be allowable, the Goodwill -
i) has to have been created by a genuine sale of the business (on which the recipient of the proceeds of the sale of goodwill may have been subject to Capital Gains Tax).
ii) set at a reasonable market value
iii) and the amortisation again also needs to be written off over a REASONABLE period of time. 2 years sounds a little ambitious to me. I would suggest 5 to 10 years is more likely to NOT arouse HMRC into asking questions
In order to be allowable, the Goodwill -
i) has to have been created by a genuine sale of the business (on which the recipient of the proceeds of the sale of goodwill may have been subject to Capital Gains Tax).
ii) set at a reasonable market value
iii) and the amortisation again also needs to be written off over a REASONABLE period of time. 2 years sounds a little ambitious to me. I would suggest 5 to 10 years is more likely to NOT arouse HMRC into asking questions
The amortisation/write off needs to be over the goodwill's 'useful economic life' ("UEL"). Are you saying that the business purchased will no longer be generating income/value/benefits/whatever you purchased it for after two years? Goodwill UEL's are normally at least 5 years and up to 20 years. UK accounting standards uses a maximum of 20 years.
Essentially the business being purchased is a one-man band service industry, so (according to their reasoning) if he leaves after 2 years, then the goodwill (i.e. his reputation) bought will no longer have any life left in it.
I think it is essentially an accounting issue, but I've no doubt that they are doing it so as to try to minimise tax on their p&l.
Obviously I steer clear of all this sort of thing and leave it to you practitioners of the dark arts - us lawyers simply write stuff down. I'm just intrigued as to whether they are right because I've never come across this before.
Thanks for the input so far - I'm going to have a proper read on HMRC's site this weekend when my insomnia kicks in.
I think it is essentially an accounting issue, but I've no doubt that they are doing it so as to try to minimise tax on their p&l.
Obviously I steer clear of all this sort of thing and leave it to you practitioners of the dark arts - us lawyers simply write stuff down. I'm just intrigued as to whether they are right because I've never come across this before.
Thanks for the input so far - I'm going to have a proper read on HMRC's site this weekend when my insomnia kicks in.
HMRC does not have a set "rate" of amortisation of Goodwill. It follows what the accountant has provided in the accounts - so it is both an accounting and a tax issue.
HMRC CAN ask for the commercial justification for the rate of amortisation chosen and they may not agree that 2 years is OK.
HMRC CAN ask for the commercial justification for the rate of amortisation chosen and they may not agree that 2 years is OK.
Goodwill usually involves a trading name/brand and a client list/contracts. Is that the case here? What is expected to happen to the seller after the 2 years are up? Is it agreed that he will definitely leave, or is there the possibility for him to continue? Is it really just his expertise that they are buying, and is that expected to be transferred? Or are they expecting to continue working in this field after the seller leaves?
There are a few exam questions here that are being confused.
For the accounts of the company, goodwill is fine if it has a recoverable value at the balance sheet date. The two years is sensible and prudent, as many companies and auditors are becoming cautious of these kind of assets and the impact they have on the balance sheet.
Nobody has mentioned other factors in the balance sheet that may make the accounting scrutiny more risky, eg, does the goodwill amortisation policy switch between a positive or negative balance sheet, and then in turn the impact on any dependancies such as loan covenants etc.
I suspect that accounts are not audited, but nonetheless, the preparing accountant and the director as signatory of the balance sheet should be prudent if this isn't something they see often.
Accounting allowances do not always equal tax allowance, though again depending on the tax status of the company there could be other factors that would make HMRC more cautious.
I would have thought that 10 years is a little long still, and again a good accountant will help with this.
For the accounts of the company, goodwill is fine if it has a recoverable value at the balance sheet date. The two years is sensible and prudent, as many companies and auditors are becoming cautious of these kind of assets and the impact they have on the balance sheet.
Nobody has mentioned other factors in the balance sheet that may make the accounting scrutiny more risky, eg, does the goodwill amortisation policy switch between a positive or negative balance sheet, and then in turn the impact on any dependancies such as loan covenants etc.
I suspect that accounts are not audited, but nonetheless, the preparing accountant and the director as signatory of the balance sheet should be prudent if this isn't something they see often.
Accounting allowances do not always equal tax allowance, though again depending on the tax status of the company there could be other factors that would make HMRC more cautious.
I would have thought that 10 years is a little long still, and again a good accountant will help with this.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



