United Airlines.... how poor?
United Airlines.... how poor?
Author
Discussion

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
So we are going on holiday soon, starting in San Francisco. We are flying from LHR on a United 747-400. We booked the whole trip through dial-a-flight who, I have to be honest, have been really good. Nothing was too much trouble. So hats off to those guys.

Anyway, they got us on a United flight and to be honest, I never gave it a second thought. Its an american carrier, nearly all of them hover around the same low bar so I guessed it didn't really matter who we flew with. We're a good way in to the second decade of the 21st century so surely it can't be that bad and all the usual amenities one comes to expect on a long haul flight will be present and correct.

WRONG. (it seems)

I thought Delta Airlines were pretty bad, but at least they give you a seat back TV for your cramped 11 hour flight to wherever. On this United flight we'll have to spend 11 hours staring at a manky piece of cloth on the seat in front (1st world problems eh?). I have read reviews and quotes like:

"Entertainment hasn't been update since the mid 90's" and "the audio programs a very bad, with lots of variation in country and western music and bad plugs for products you always knew you never wanted". In reference to Delta, one reviewer said "Could be worse, you could be on United". I have just read as well that, on some aircraft, those in first class may get a 12 inch TV, but not video on demanand...instead films come on video cassettes!!


These things don't fill me with much hope of being able to stave off discomfort with visual distraction. I read that they show 2 films on a loop on the overhead projector and one passenger said they showed 2 films for the whole flight with 9 hours of nothing in between!

What is more, no free booze and with a non-US credit card that'll be $20 a time for beer and because you can't buy more than one beer at a time, its $20 every time (due to some crazy $13 charge for using a non US card). That is worse than when a posh NYC club served me a small glass of Newcastle Brown and charged $10! Premium imported ale they said....If only they knew.

Worrying me now is that if the cabin is a time warp back to the early 90's, what are the seats going to be like? Im 6ft 3 and have long legs. As a precaution I have upgraded our seats to Premium Economy, which from the sounds of it, gives you the same leg room as every other carriers (who have up to date kit) standard economy. Here's hoping I can channel some of the Irish charm off a friend and get upped to business! (currently completely empty on this flight).

I have only experienced this once previously in recent years. Christmas 2010 and my £1000 air line ticket got me a seat on a Martin Air 767 replete with 14 inch CRTs that dropped from the ceiling and for lucky those bulk head passengers, new newfangled LCD things about the size of a postage stamp. 90 year old air stewardesses, crippling 31 inch seat pitch and the cheek to charge you a good £40 for an iPad knock off full of old films if you didn't want the horrid stitching pattern of the seat in front burnt into your retinas. I needed a hospital after that flight.

Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Thursday 3rd October 13:44

outnumbered

4,894 posts

265 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
United Economy is truly dire. Shocking food, minimal in-flight entertainment on some of the fleet, cabin staff who generally do not seem to be having fun.

The 777s they used previously LHR-SFO had seat-back video and 9 channels, which was OK - the current 747s seem to have a single video screen in the front of the cabin just like they did in the 1980s.

You can usually pay a fifty quid or so at the airport and get an exit row seat, or upgrade to Economy Plus which will give you more legroom, but the same basic type of seat.

I'd recommend taking your own food and entertainment... On the positive side, it's only 10-11 hours, but it will feel like twice that !



miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
I always point people to United when they have a go at Delta (which on most LHR routes is now pretty good) - I sympathise with you OP. Is there a possibility of changing the routing to get on one of United's 777 routes? (I don't think they fly the 787 transatlantic...)

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
I always point people to United when they have a go at Delta (which on most LHR routes is now pretty good) - I sympathise with you OP. Is there a possibility of changing the routing to get on one of United's 777 routes? (I don't think they fly the 787 transatlantic...)
United 787s are operating Houston-Heathrow,Lagos and Amsterdam.

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
I always point people to United when they have a go at Delta (which on most LHR routes is now pretty good) - I sympathise with you OP. Is there a possibility of changing the routing to get on one of United's 777 routes? (I don't think they fly the 787 transatlantic...)
think it is a bit late in the day for switching things now. Bed made.

The way back is even more hilarious. A domestic to Chicago (which has Direct TV! which is like Sky TV) and then a decrepit 767-300ER with te same 90's interior back to LHR. Looks like I'll be forking out for premium econ again there because thats a night flight and I WILL need to get some shut eye.

Apparently at Chicago, even though we are connecting to an international flight and the bags will be transfered for us, we still have to exit the terminal, re-enter and re-check in so that they do your green card right and then the US won't think you've been cheeky and stayed in the country (even though you went home). They have some interesting decisions in that country.

miln0039

2,013 posts

189 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
el stovey said:
United 787s are operating Houston-Heathrow,Lagos and Amsterdam.
Then I would suggest OP tries to route via Houston....or a 777 operated route (LAX?)

Bill

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Presumably you can use cash for booze? Then get a pair of in car DVD players (ours were £89 from Argos) and you're sorted.

LimaDelta

8,532 posts

249 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Flew Brussels-Newark with United. Only time ever with that airline and inexplicably was upgraded to First. No better than Business on most airlines but not bad.

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Bill said:
Presumably you can use cash for booze? Then get a pair of in car DVD players (ours were £89 from Argos) and you're sorted.
Im making a list of films and looking at portable chargers/storage. Its only 16gb, but I reckon if I can remove a lot of the apps and just keep the essentials and then do some re-encoding, I can get a decent set of films and tv shows on there. Things like family guy, american dad and futurama only take 100-150 mb per episode and can be half that without noticing a drop in quality. Unfortunately alot of the iTunes downloadable copy films are massive! Star Trek Into Darkness is nearly 5gb, though the quality is very good.

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
LimaDelta said:
Flew Brussels-Newark with United. Only time ever with that airline and inexplicably was upgraded to First. No better than Business on most airlines but not bad.
Apparently, they like to keep the posh seats with bums in them so if they're empty, you have a chance of an upgrade.

Bill

58,913 posts

286 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
That's why I suggested a DVD player - ripping your own legitimate DVDs is more trouble than it's worth ime, and certainly harder than downloading illegal ones rolleyes

Wolff

413 posts

246 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Bill said:
Presumably you can use cash for booze? Then get a pair of in car DVD players (ours were £89 from Argos) and you're sorted.
No... you would think so... but no. Card only for in-flight purchases. Don't get caught out like I did and end up bringing a small amount of dollars back to the UK assuming I could buy beer on the plane! IIRC, a beer is about $6, a vodka/spirit is $7.

We flew United only a couple of weeks ago, 777 to LAX. To be honest, it was perfectly fine. Legroom on a par with Virgin (but not BA, with whom I had an extra inch or two), seatback TV, and apart from one stewardess a friendly crew. And the food was more than edible too - although if asleep on the way home you will miss out on an ice cream sandwich.

Would I fly with them again? If they were the only choice I had, I wouldn't be too disheartened. If I could fly BA/Virgin instead, there's no contest.

bestinshow

521 posts

252 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
We flew with United to New York a couple of years ago and they were dreadful.

Tatty cabin, no screen, rude staff ( when asked if I wanted a hot drink or a can of coke, I had the audacity to ask if I could have both, the look I was given was bordering on hateful )

If I had the choice, never again.

bestinshow

521 posts

252 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
We flew with United to New York a couple of years ago and they were dreadful.

Tatty cabin, no screen, rude staff ( when asked if I wanted a hot drink or a can of coke, I had the audacity to ask if I could have both, the look I was given was bordering on hateful )

If I had the choice, never again.

Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
Wolff said:
Bill said:
Presumably you can use cash for booze? Then get a pair of in car DVD players (ours were £89 from Argos) and you're sorted.
No... you would think so... but no. Card only for in-flight purchases. Don't get caught out like I did and end up bringing a small amount of dollars back to the UK assuming I could buy beer on the plane! IIRC, a beer is about $6, a vodka/spirit is $7.

We flew United only a couple of weeks ago, 777 to LAX. To be honest, it was perfectly fine. Legroom on a par with Virgin (but not BA, with whom I had an extra inch or two), seatback TV, and apart from one stewardess a friendly crew. And the food was more than edible too - although if asleep on the way home you will miss out on an ice cream sandwich.

Would I fly with them again? If they were the only choice I had, I wouldn't be too disheartened. If I could fly BA/Virgin instead, there's no contest.
How many meals do they serve? Is it 2 + a snack?

Edit: think its 1.5 meals .... Bit stingy for a 12 hour flight.


Also, interestingly, United have outfitted about half their 747 fleet with wifi and a feature of this wifi is the ability to stream inflight movies. So rather than a seat back option they're going with a bring your own screen and we'll feed you the content. Seems like a decent half way house IMO, especially as most of this fleet is quite old. No point in going for a blow out refit if the aircraft is going to be retired not long after. They left it a bit late in the day for such refits. I'll load up the ipad none the less but the option of some inflight streaming sounds reasonable to me. Let's face it, most tablets will have a far better screen than fitted to most seat back tvs. Only problem is no power sockets so once your batt is dead, that is it!

Edit 2: the aircraft currently flying the lhr-sfo route has wifi!
Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Thursday 3rd October 23:08


Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Thursday 3rd October 23:09

22s

6,551 posts

247 months

Thursday 3rd October 2013
quotequote all
United are ste.

I flew to Dallas earlier this year and nearly missed my flight because they cancelled my original booking 12 hours before, switched it to another around that departed 20 minutes later than the original, and told me it flew from the same gate when actually it was from a different terminal. Obviously received no apology.

When I got on the plane (after running to the gate), it became clear why the first flight was cancelled. There were literally 30 people on a 200 seat plane! Which was amazing for me as I could stretch out and put my stuff everywhere. The only problems were that the food was ste, as was the entertainment, and the hostesses were all about 60 years-old and deaf.

Have fun! smile

Wolff

413 posts

246 months

Friday 4th October 2013
quotequote all
Otispunkmeyer said:
How many meals do they serve? Is it 2 + a snack?

Edit: think its 1.5 meals .... Bit stingy for a 12 hour flight.


Also, interestingly, United have outfitted about half their 747 fleet with wifi and a feature of this wifi is the ability to stream inflight movies. So rather than a seat back option they're going with a bring your own screen and we'll feed you the content. Seems like a decent half way house IMO, especially as most of this fleet is quite old. No point in going for a blow out refit if the aircraft is going to be retired not long after. They left it a bit late in the day for such refits. I'll load up the ipad none the less but the option of some inflight streaming sounds reasonable to me. Let's face it, most tablets will have a far better screen than fitted to most seat back tvs. Only problem is no power sockets so once your batt is dead, that is it!

Edit 2: the aircraft currently flying the lhr-sfo route has wifi!
Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Thursday 3rd October 23:08


Edited by Otispunkmeyer on Thursday 3rd October 23:09
tbh, I can't remember what meals we had, other than on the way there was Beef Brisket (nice!) plus something else and on the way back was bbq chicken (nice), ice cream sandwich, something else.... plus as many pretzels as you wanted (had to go get more from back of plane, but hey, they were nice!). We had other stuff too, but being too excited/tired I don't really remember.

The films on the seatback - they had a LOT. Recent ones too. So if you get them over streaming, it will be ok smile

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Friday 4th October 2013
quotequote all
United are stbags. I fking loathe them and hope to celebrate their demise one day. Sadly, they're not that much worse than any other US carrier - most of them are awful and it's usually a surprise if you exit the plane feeling positive. Delta and AA are passable, but still meh unless you fly biz class.
On the plus side it's elevated my opinion of BA massively.

A few weeks back United cancelled the last leg of my flight because it was overbooked (despite being a 1 hour flight at the end of a 4-stop business class flight that was booked over 6 months ago and checked in as soon as it was available).

This afternoon I was meant to be flying to Vegas with them, and surprise surprise, they're overbooked and I'm now flying tomorrow (unless I want to be on standby for 8 hours in a horrid little airport). Again, booked over 2 months ago, and a day's worth of gambling and booze consumption wasted.
Next time they're the only option (which is the only reason I've ever booked with them), I'll drive - even if it's a couple of thousand miles.


Otispunkmeyer

Original Poster:

13,832 posts

186 months

Friday 4th October 2013
quotequote all
Wow, that is bad.

Even their CEO admits the "product" isn't up to scratch. Bet he still takes home a whacking great pay packet and bonus each year though!

Geoff Stilwell

679 posts

206 months

Friday 4th October 2013
quotequote all
Hey guys...look i fly United every few weeks. London to San Francisco and then on the Hawaii. SF is now the United main hub airport. All the flights currently into SF are on 747-400's. This year i have had only 1 delayed flight back They all left on time and get there on time. On these flight in Economy you get a meal and all soft drinks include plus a snack going out. You only pay for alcohol. My last flight was 4 weeks ago and the plane was fine. If you dont like 747's then fly into LAX and they use 777 - 200's. Going west i go into SF and coming back i always go via LAX. At the end of the day you have upgraded to P/Economy. You will be just behind Business Class. Go to United Airlines airlines website..put in you booking code and they will show you the plane your on. The films that are on etc etc. PM me if you want any further info. Heathrow to SF is 10.5 hours..not 12 and my flight back was 9 hours.

Edited by Geoff Stilwell on Friday 4th October 20:36


Edited by Geoff Stilwell on Friday 4th October 20:38