Supposed Trademark infringement help
Supposed Trademark infringement help
Author
Discussion

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
Need some help or advice.

The scenario: A good friend was served a letter from a much larger company with a similar name to theirs stating to cease trading immediately as they are claiming that my friend was passing off their name. My friend has trademarked their name (which was after this other company trademarked theirs). The name itself I don't want to disclose, but its similar to froo-pa against froop. They both sell drinks.

So currently my friend got a solicitor to send a strong reply saying their claim is nonsense. They've received a reply that this company want to take it further. She's feeling quite down and helpless as she's built up this brand name and everyone knows the business by this name, but this company is big and most likely has deeper pockets than her (and even if she did, would it even be worth trying to fight??).

I hate the idea of her being bullied, and especially for no good reason but realistically what can she do? Would there be any solicitors who would take this on as no win no fee or is that being hopelessly optimistic?

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
I've just been told as well that the second letter includes a claim for damages since she was trading, which I assume is to claim a percentage of the profits for her supposed infringement of copyright?? If that's true, I'm stunned.

davepoth

29,395 posts

230 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
It sounds to me like your friend may well be on a bit of a sticky wicket. If the name of her product is similar to the big company's, and she's selling the same sort of thing as the big company, there is a quite high chance that the big company will win. I would suggest that she gets some proper (non-internet) legal advice as big "brands" can be particularly vicious.

grumbas

1,180 posts

222 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage, especially as part of trademark registration checks for similar trademarks - this I guess would weaken their case?

Ultimately though I think you're probably right it will come down to who can afford the best lawyers.

mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
I would do some reading up at ipo.gov.uk

If the other co took out either a UK or EU trademark first, then it's slightly surprising that she was awarded the similar trademark for the same category of trade

At the end of the day, this can come down to who has deeper pockets, and legal fees can be adjudged against the infringer so unless you are very confident and have the money to fight itthere may be an argument for backing off before the legal bills rack up (sad but true)

mikef

6,158 posts

282 months

Saturday 5th October 2013
quotequote all
grumbas said:
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage.
I believe the other company would only have been informed by the Intellectual Property Office at application stage if they held a UK trademark, not an EU or other international mark. Their attorneys may well have picked this up later

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
Is friend a ltd company? Please say that they are not a sole trader.

LooneyTunes

9,539 posts

189 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
mikef said:
grumbas said:
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage.
I believe the other company would only have been informed by the Intellectual Property Office at application stage if they held a UK trademark, not an EU or other international mark. Their attorneys may well have picked this up later
I'm not sure about that. One of mine I seem to recall the IPO mentioning a US mark and debating whether they were similar enough or not to require notification.

renmure

4,952 posts

255 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
You are getting befuddled by Copyright and Trademarks.
It is a very specialised area of law so you would be best to get the advice from a registered Trademark Attorney.

You will find someone local using the link here ( http://www.itma.org.uk/links )

(Mrs Renmure does this sort of thing as a day job so if you want to email me the details I will ask her to reply to you directly if that helps)

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
mikef said:
grumbas said:
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage.
I believe the other company would only have been informed by the Intellectual Property Office at application stage if they held a UK trademark, not an EU or other international mark. Their attorneys may well have picked this up later
I'm not sure about that. One of mine I seem to recall the IPO mentioning a US mark and debating whether they were similar enough or not to require notification.
I think they were notified but chose not to object. The cynical side of me wonders if they wanted to see how well the business did, then sue for damages and gain out of it?

The IPO office were no help, they just told her they don't get involved.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
TooLateForAName said:
Is friend a ltd company? Please say that they are not a sole trader.
They are ltd. I've suggested just transferring assets to a new company and winding it up...would this work?

The company suing are basing their whole case on phonetics, that when saying my friend's brand it uses their brand name but my friend has a hyphen in place that makes it different the way it's said. Its pretty disgusting how heavy handed they're being over a small company.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
mikef said:
grumbas said:
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage.
I believe the other company would only have been informed by the Intellectual Property Office at application stage if they held a UK trademark, not an EU or other international mark. Their attorneys may well have picked this up later
I'm not sure about that. One of mine I seem to recall the IPO mentioning a US mark and debating whether they were similar enough or not to require notification.
I think they were notified but chose not to object. The cynical side of me wonders if they wanted to see how well the business did, then sue for damages and gain out of it?

The IPO office were no help, they just told her they don't get involved.

Seany88

Original Poster:

1,249 posts

251 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
LooneyTunes said:
mikef said:
grumbas said:
Far from an expert but if your friend has trademarked their name, the other company could/should have objected at this stage.
I believe the other company would only have been informed by the Intellectual Property Office at application stage if they held a UK trademark, not an EU or other international mark. Their attorneys may well have picked this up later
I'm not sure about that. One of mine I seem to recall the IPO mentioning a US mark and debating whether they were similar enough or not to require notification.
That's what my friend thought, they were notified and woukd have had time to object but chose not to. Maybe they decided to see how well the business did with an idea to sue for damages later?

The IPO office is no help, they say they don't get involved with disputes.

FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Are both companies HQ'd in the UK?

FurtiveFreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Are both companies HQ'd in the UK?

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Seany88 said:
I've just been told as well that the second letter includes a claim for damages since she was trading, which I assume is to claim a percentage of the profits for her supposed infringement of copyright?? If that's true, I'm stunned.
Serious question:

She must have done a trademark search before registering heres. When she found there was a large company in the same sector selling similar items, why did she proceed with the knowledge that the other company name sounded the same?


To give another perspective, I'm currently having to employ a solicitor at £300 an hour to defend our mark and literature from a competitor who has literally used 'copy and paste' and used that to get sales. What's the nature of her copyright infringement?

My advice:

If the solicitor is not an IP/Trademark specialist, get one. The best case scenario is that she can put forward a formal agreement not to use the name or to differentiate between brands.

renmure

4,952 posts

255 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
My advice:

If the solicitor is not an IP/Trademark specialist, get one.
Earlier in the thread I offered the opinion of a £390 + vat/ hr one for free.