Credit score - open to identity theft?

Credit score - open to identity theft?

Author
Discussion

crazy about cars

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

171 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
I think I am being overly paranoid here but am a bit concerned. I signed up to a 14 day trial credit reports to get my credit report. If you cancel within 14 days the report is virtually free. The catch is you need to call customer services to cancel, which I did.

I am surprised to see that the guy on the other end have more detailed information than what is shown on my report. He spent a good 10 minutes convincing me to stay but in the end I told him I wasn't ready to pay almost £16/month for the report.

This got me thinking though, which the information he has it would be very easy to use my information to commit identity fraud. Am I wrong in thinking this way?

w00tman

607 posts

147 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
I think I am being overly paranoid here but am a bit concerned. I signed up to a 14 day trial credit reports to get my credit report. If you cancel within 14 days the report is virtually free. The catch is you need to call customer services to cancel, which I did.

I am surprised to see that the guy on the other end have more detailed information than what is shown on my report. He spent a good 10 minutes convincing me to stay but in the end I told him I wasn't ready to pay almost £16/month for the report.

This got me thinking though, which the information he has it would be very easy to use my information to commit identity fraud. Am I wrong in thinking this way?
Paranoid.

What makes you so special that someone (who probably has hundreds of people call him each month and has access to millions of details) is willing to pick your details about anyone elses, in order to ruin their own life on the off-chance of making a few quid?

Bank employees, doctors, estate agents - anyone in a position of trust could do the very same thing. But they don't, for the most part, do they?

bigandclever

13,839 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th October 2013
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
the report is virtually free
And virtually meaningless anyway smile

Sarnie

8,064 posts

211 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
And virtually meaningless anyway smile
This.

It also amazes me how they have carved out an industry from this. Ten years ago you could get a copy of your credit file for £2, now it's nearly £200 a year off the back of people's paranoia.

phil-sti

2,697 posts

181 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
crazy about cars said:
the report is virtually free
And virtually meaningless anyway smile
double this, I have the highest possible credit score with experian and yet Wonga wouldn't lend me a fiver.

P-Jay

10,626 posts

193 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Paranoid, they had all the information they discussed with you already - they're the people who actually hold it.

There is a possibility that a member of staff at Experian et all could take every single bit of financial information about you and use it to get up to no good - however it's not easy - there are loads of safeguards in place, to have access to this sort of information you have to go through an annual background check, if you're in financial trouble - you won't get a job, and people are sacked and reassigned if they get into trouble.

Secondly, simply having someone's Name, Address, DOB etc isn't the key to simply walking into DFS and walking out with a brand new sofa with someone else name on the finance paperwork - all those annoying bits of 'petty bureaucracy' 'computer says no' and 'silly rules' which can seem pointless, actually do make sense if you understand the bigger picture. In actual fact, getting all the details about someone to complete a credit application is a lot easier than getting a job in a finance role or at Experian, making it useful for criminal activity is much harder - which is why even in an age of chip and pin and ever more secure internet security - you're far, far more likely to have your card details compromised.

As for Experian credit expert and all that, it's a lot of smoke and mirrors - utterly useless. If you want to know what information they hold on you, write to them and pay the £2. Risk scores are entirely down to the actual application and the organisation you're applying with and will vary hugely, there isn't even a standard scale - some places have a 1-10, a -5 to +15 or even a 0-1600, even then the score is just part of the puzzle.

crazy about cars

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

171 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
Thanks... can't help being paranoid as going through a hard time - just found out today the place I work with is going through a merger. Thanks again for replies.


megaphone

10,803 posts

253 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
You are right to be paranoid, there is way too much info held on us by 'reliable' institutions or companies. It will all come back and bite us on the arse one day. Be afraid...

Edited by megaphone on Wednesday 9th October 16:38

crazy about cars

Original Poster:

4,454 posts

171 months

Tuesday 8th October 2013
quotequote all
Thanks, thats very insightful.

P-Jay said:
Paranoid, they had all the information they discussed with you already - they're the people who actually hold it.

There is a possibility that a member of staff at Experian et all could take every single bit of financial information about you and use it to get up to no good - however it's not easy - there are loads of safeguards in place, to have access to this sort of information you have to go through an annual background check, if you're in financial trouble - you won't get a job, and people are sacked and reassigned if they get into trouble.

Secondly, simply having someone's Name, Address, DOB etc isn't the key to simply walking into DFS and walking out with a brand new sofa with someone else name on the finance paperwork - all those annoying bits of 'petty bureaucracy' 'computer says no' and 'silly rules' which can seem pointless, actually do make sense if you understand the bigger picture. In actual fact, getting all the details about someone to complete a credit application is a lot easier than getting a job in a finance role or at Experian, making it useful for criminal activity is much harder - which is why even in an age of chip and pin and ever more secure internet security - you're far, far more likely to have your card details compromised.

As for Experian credit expert and all that, it's a lot of smoke and mirrors - utterly useless. If you want to know what information they hold on you, write to them and pay the £2. Risk scores are entirely down to the actual application and the organisation you're applying with and will vary hugely, there isn't even a standard scale - some places have a 1-10, a -5 to +15 or even a 0-1600, even then the score is just part of the puzzle.