"They've been good to us.."
Discussion
I operate in a service industry where loyalty to the incumbent supplier is vast. I am on a strong business development campaign to take our services and activities into new regions within the UK.
Prospects acknowledge that our service delivery is better, our background relevant, our customer testimonials first class, yet when we ask "Well, please give us a try" we are met with the stone wall of...
"I can't you see, ACME have been good to us in the past"
We have a no payment satisfaction promise, our market is not price sensitive and we boast a 100% repeat rate.
Any ideas on how we overcome the "They've been good to us" issue we face day in, day out?
Prospects acknowledge that our service delivery is better, our background relevant, our customer testimonials first class, yet when we ask "Well, please give us a try" we are met with the stone wall of...
"I can't you see, ACME have been good to us in the past"
We have a no payment satisfaction promise, our market is not price sensitive and we boast a 100% repeat rate.
Any ideas on how we overcome the "They've been good to us" issue we face day in, day out?
Sounds like you are essentially appealling to emotion, "please give us a try" - in doing so you are staking your delivery in their first order totally on the line.
What is your USP ?
What do you do that is different from the incumbent, what element of the service leads to 100% satisfaction and allows you to offer a guarantee.
Is there an incentive to switch ? 10% off first order ? You need a hook and a USP or other differentiator.
It's all about the bottom line. Work the numbers, show how if they move over to you they will be £x better off this year and £y after 5 years. Tell a compelling story about how you can deliver this (decreased costs, increased retention/customer satisfaction, greater market share etc.).
They need a good reason (preferably, a few) to use your services and yes, you will have an uphill battle to unseat the incumbent. It's not enough to show that they haven't got anything to lose (that's a very negative message and you'll get nowhere) - you need to change their mindset so that you are the preferred solution because you will deliver more benefit to their business, and once you've done that you need to work the account to convince the key stakeholders that not only will they gain with you, they will lose with the current supplier.
It's an incredibly hard thing to do well and needs a solid, targetted approach as well as good industry and market knowledge, political savvy and (perhaps most importantly) the ability to keep knocking on doors until people start listening to what you're saying. I'm rubbish at all of that which is why I stick to technical sales
They need a good reason (preferably, a few) to use your services and yes, you will have an uphill battle to unseat the incumbent. It's not enough to show that they haven't got anything to lose (that's a very negative message and you'll get nowhere) - you need to change their mindset so that you are the preferred solution because you will deliver more benefit to their business, and once you've done that you need to work the account to convince the key stakeholders that not only will they gain with you, they will lose with the current supplier.
It's an incredibly hard thing to do well and needs a solid, targetted approach as well as good industry and market knowledge, political savvy and (perhaps most importantly) the ability to keep knocking on doors until people start listening to what you're saying. I'm rubbish at all of that which is why I stick to technical sales

coyft said:
Consistency. Keep knocking on the door every now and again. Just pop in say hello, be there for the one day that they may need you. It might take years, but at least you know that the next one in the door is going to face the same problem.
Sure that is one way to go, you certainly need bouncebackability in BD, but I am often approached this way, and it is too easy to say, thanks, lovely to see you and do nothing or not buy. Really good BD people open doors and create sales in any market.
In my opinion it is worth trying a variety of classic BD tactics.
QU, "Is there any reason you wouldn't consider switching suppliers for this service?"
Answer - " They've been really good to us"
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
coyft said:
Consistency. Keep knocking on the door every now and again. Just pop in say hello, be there for the one day that they may need you. It might take years, but at least you know that the next one in the door is going to face the same problem.
I agree with this. If a customer is perfectly happy (and not price sensitive), they have no reason to change supplier. In fact, it is a lot of effort on their part, so they are likely to avoid doing it without good reason (and based upon the lack of price sensitivity, I'd assume we're not talking about commodity product/service sales here). The best you can do is make sure they are aware of what your market position is, and why you believe you are the best supplier to them and then wait until a change of circumstance puts them in a position to give you a go.This is more of an account management stance (albeit an account with no revenue generated), rather than overt sales. Aggressive sales tactics just annoy customers who are happy with their current setup.
"I can't see you, ACME have been good to us in the past"
Ask them
"It's clear ACME do a great job for you by the loyalty you are willing to show them, however If you were to think really hard, is there one thing you would really love ACME to do better, differently, more of or start doing ?"
This may give you an angle to pursue and is a lot less aggressive than anything that sounds like a direct challenge
Alternatively simple ask them what ACME do so well ...keeps the conversation going and once again provides you valuable insight.
Ask them
"It's clear ACME do a great job for you by the loyalty you are willing to show them, however If you were to think really hard, is there one thing you would really love ACME to do better, differently, more of or start doing ?"
This may give you an angle to pursue and is a lot less aggressive than anything that sounds like a direct challenge
Alternatively simple ask them what ACME do so well ...keeps the conversation going and once again provides you valuable insight.
Can you offer anything competitors don't?
Can you give examples/case studies of where the customer swapped to you and what you did for them?
Ask them about the service in detail if you can, the more they tell you the more chance you have o finding something they don't do well or don't do at all.
Customers interest is often pricked by using terms that they haven't heard of. When they do they think 'What's that? I don't get that currently, what am I missing out on?, may be I should talk to this company to find out more...'
Can you give examples/case studies of where the customer swapped to you and what you did for them?
Ask them about the service in detail if you can, the more they tell you the more chance you have o finding something they don't do well or don't do at all.
Customers interest is often pricked by using terms that they haven't heard of. When they do they think 'What's that? I don't get that currently, what am I missing out on?, may be I should talk to this company to find out more...'
Gargamel said:
Sure that is one way to go, you certainly need bouncebackability in BD, but I am often approached this way, and it is too easy to say, thanks, lovely to see you and do nothing or not buy.
Really good BD people open doors and create sales in any market.
In my opinion it is worth trying a variety of classic BD tactics.
QU, "Is there any reason you wouldn't consider switching suppliers for this service?"
Answer - " They've been really good to us"
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
That's hilarious! OP - please don't listed to this advice if you're trying to win new business! Really good BD people open doors and create sales in any market.
In my opinion it is worth trying a variety of classic BD tactics.
QU, "Is there any reason you wouldn't consider switching suppliers for this service?"
Answer - " They've been really good to us"
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
It's not aggressive, it's moronic and puts backs up more than anything. It's as if you know you've lost the sale and want to chuck in a quick insult.
You have never had someone say 'now you phrase it in such a sarcastic and childish way I simply must prove that I am interested in saving money. Where do I sign?'
Funniest thing I've read for ages.
Vary who you talk to. A buyer may have a good relationship with good service but the end user may not. The finance director may not think the price is good. These are networking things though as no business will thank you for ringing up and saying part of their organisation is rubbish.
coyft said:
Gargamel said:
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
"Just so we are clear, get the fYes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
k out of my office". 
I have two main suppliers that I use and don't really bother with others. I use them because I like the people I deal with, always the same point of contact and no pointless questions every time I order.
The only sales pitch that would work with me is too offer to pick up any slack if they were too busy to fulfill my requirements at any time, which would give you a foot in the door.
Gargamel said:
In my opinion it is worth trying a variety of classic BD tactics.
QU, "Is there any reason you wouldn't consider switching suppliers for this service?"
Answer - " They've been really good to us"
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
Questionable which would get you thrown out of most offices fastest: Your Q2; or "what percentage of your order value does your current supplier return to you in cash?"... QU, "Is there any reason you wouldn't consider switching suppliers for this service?"
Answer - " They've been really good to us"
QU " so just so we are clear, you have no interest in improving your service or reducing your costs? "
Yes it's aggressive, but personally I think offering a guaranteed refund if it goes wrong is a negative message.
Polite persistence is absolutely key. Be there, and ready, for the one time the incumbent screws up or can't help. But take time to work out if the person you're speaking to is actually the person who makes the decisions.
C Lee Farquar said:
Nothing winds me up more than schoolboy salesman closes.
I have two main suppliers that I use and don't really bother with others. I use them because I like the people I deal with, always the same point of contact and no pointless questions every time I order.
The only sales pitch that would work with me is too offer to pick up any slack if they were too busy to fulfill my requirements at any time, which would give you a foot in the door.
I'd respond very well to this. If a salesman said look I know you like who you are with now but next time they are out of stock or dont have what you need give me a call and we will show you how we do things. If that was followed up with an email stating the same and asking me to file it for future use I might just do that.I have two main suppliers that I use and don't really bother with others. I use them because I like the people I deal with, always the same point of contact and no pointless questions every time I order.
The only sales pitch that would work with me is too offer to pick up any slack if they were too busy to fulfill my requirements at any time, which would give you a foot in the door.
All you would need to do on that order is do it very well and possibly ask to be able to quote on the other stuff too and you are up and running.
jeremyc said:
Offer them a free, short term trial of your service in parallel with their existing supplier so they can compare and have a direct experience of the benefits you offer?
I like this. You need to offer something that isn't mutually exclusive to their continued relationship with their existing supplier, at least for now. Parallel works. The other option is supply them with something that their competitor doesn't, and expand sideways once you have a relationship.In your language, make it comfortable rather than being competitive and combative. Putting it in horrible terms, you're trying to get them to embark on an affair, not divorce their wife when they get home.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


