E91 Gas Conversion?
E91 Gas Conversion?
Author
Discussion

Griff4.0

Original Poster:

61 posts

268 months

Monday 7th October 2013
quotequote all
I've just moved out to Bulgaria with my new (to me) 2010 E91 320i. Started asking about gas conversion as my mileage is pretty high and one engineer has asked whether the injector nozzles are within the head or external. Apparently if they are internal they won't touch the job. Any advice would be gratefully received.

8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Friday 11th October 2013
quotequote all
LPG is a surefire way to kill the engine and the installer will claim no responsibility.

Dont do it.

Rumple

15,459 posts

182 months

Saturday 12th October 2013
quotequote all
How does it kill the engine?

ArmaghMan

2,805 posts

211 months

Saturday 12th October 2013
quotequote all
8Tech said:
LPG is a surefire way to kill the engine and the installer will claim no responsibility.

Dont do it.
Run an M5 on it for 50000 miles. No damage whatsoever.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Saturday 12th October 2013
quotequote all
My 328 is on 210000 miles, been on LPG since 80, you will have to back up the statement that it kills your engine I feel.

Griff4.0

Original Poster:

61 posts

268 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
I appreciate the feedback guys - certainly there's enough there to suggest that with the older engines at least LPG is a viable proposition. I've done a little research of my own and found that the engine in my motor is the N43B20. Has anyone out there had an LPG conversion on this specific engine?

8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
My 328 is on 210000 miles, been on LPG since 80, you will have to back up the statement that it kills your engine I feel.
Easy,

5 of the 7 owners who I know who have had LPG on their vehicles, including a Factory fit install on a Ford Trannsit, and another OEM install on a Fiat Fiorino have all had catastrphic engine failures ranging from headgasket failures to burnt-out valves. Of the 100's of other motorists I know, there have not been that many engine failures in total, just a few on 3 cylinder engines.

Now the owners of these 2 vans just use the fact that their vehicles CAN run on LPG to get free access to the Congestion Charge Zone.

Fuel consumption will INCREASE in the region of 25% when using LPG.

The 2 that currently remain ok are an 840i V8 and a 4.6iS X5.

Try this for size.......

http://www.amrautos.co.uk/index.php/lpg-systems

Quote........"Warranty, All Major Vehicle Manufacturers will exclude any damage to engines caused by the installation ofLPG, including Valve Seat Recession and Burnt Valves under their new car warranty.All Warranties sold with LPG Conversions do not cover Valve Seat Recession or Burnt valves. Check before buying.

All After Market Warranties specifically exclude Valve Seat Recession and burnt valves. Check before buying.


All LPG Importers and Suppliers will not pay for damage to engines caused by the fitting of their LPG Equipment."

I rest my case.


redtwin

7,518 posts

213 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
So the only two engines you know to have survived running on LPG are BMWs?.

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
8Tech said:
buggalugs said:
My 328 is on 210000 miles, been on LPG since 80, you will have to back up the statement that it kills your engine I feel.
Easy,

5 of the 7 owners who I know who have had LPG on their vehicles, including a Factory fit install on a Ford Trannsit, and another OEM install on a Fiat Fiorino have all had catastrphic engine failures ranging from headgasket failures to burnt-out valves. Of the 100's of other motorists I know, there have not been that many engine failures in total, just a few on 3 cylinder engines.

Now the owners of these 2 vans just use the fact that their vehicles CAN run on LPG to get free access to the Congestion Charge Zone.

Fuel consumption will INCREASE in the region of 25% when using LPG.

The 2 that currently remain ok are an 840i V8 and a 4.6iS X5.

Try this for size.......

http://www.amrautos.co.uk/index.php/lpg-systems

Quote........"Warranty, All Major Vehicle Manufacturers will exclude any damage to engines caused by the installation ofLPG, including Valve Seat Recession and Burnt Valves under their new car warranty.All Warranties sold with LPG Conversions do not cover Valve Seat Recession or Burnt valves. Check before buying.

All After Market Warranties specifically exclude Valve Seat Recession and burnt valves. Check before buying.


All LPG Importers and Suppliers will not pay for damage to engines caused by the fitting of their LPG Equipment."

I rest my case.

Sounds like your friends have had some bad luck. I know a few people running on gas and haven't had any issues.

That link is full of rubbish.

LPG kit manufacturers have their kits fitted and mapped by random third party installers, how on earth can they warranty anything?

8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
redtwin said:
So the only two engines you know to have survived running on LPG are BMWs?.
Correct, as well as the 328i mentioned on this thread.

Maybe the BMW engines are more resilient than the others, but I can only comment from experience, 30 years of it, so I give my view and advice on the topic, sorry if one of the other posters gives a different view, but you are better to be fully informed rather than getting one side of the discussion.

I am sure the owners of the other failed cars would be far more critical of the LPG than me though.

Try calling your dealer pretending you have an LPG conversion on the car, and ask about fault finding etc.

Dont forget the monster costs of proper LPG spark plugs too. They are that price to take the punishment that LPG deals out.

Weigh-up the fuel cost savings against the downsides, 25% less mpg, availability of both fuel and parts for the LPG conversion (installers are disappearing all the time), servicing and (possible) engine issues, then judge for yourself.

Good luck,

8Tech.


Edited by 8Tech on Wednesday 16th October 15:19

8Tech

2,222 posts

229 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
buggalugs said:
8Tech said:
buggalugs said:
My 328 is on 210000 miles, been on LPG since 80, you will have to back up the statement that it kills your engine I feel.
Easy,

5 of the 7 owners who I know who have had LPG on their vehicles, including a Factory fit install on a Ford Trannsit, and another OEM install on a Fiat Fiorino have all had catastrphic engine failures ranging from headgasket failures to burnt-out valves. Of the 100's of other motorists I know, there have not been that many engine failures in total, just a few on 3 cylinder engines.

Now the owners of these 2 vans just use the fact that their vehicles CAN run on LPG to get free access to the Congestion Charge Zone.

Fuel consumption will INCREASE in the region of 25% when using LPG.

The 2 that currently remain ok are an 840i V8 and a 4.6iS X5.

Try this for size.......

http://www.amrautos.co.uk/index.php/lpg-systems

Quote........"Warranty, All Major Vehicle Manufacturers will exclude any damage to engines caused by the installation ofLPG, including Valve Seat Recession and Burnt Valves under their new car warranty.All Warranties sold with LPG Conversions do not cover Valve Seat Recession or Burnt valves. Check before buying.

All After Market Warranties specifically exclude Valve Seat Recession and burnt valves. Check before buying.


All LPG Importers and Suppliers will not pay for damage to engines caused by the fitting of their LPG Equipment."

I rest my case.

Sounds like your friends have had some bad luck. I know a few people running on gas and haven't had any issues.

That link is full of rubbish.

LPG kit manufacturers have their kits fitted and mapped by random third party installers, how on earth can they warranty anything?
So one person fits the kit and a third party maps the ECU? Well, thats the first way for a failure to not get resolved as each blames the others systems. A bit like when your computer crashes, the computer supplier blames the software and visa versa.

So you are correct enough to rubbish that link? Maybe its time for YOU to back up your statement with the massive experience of ONE car.

If you are so sure, maybe you would like to warrant the install on the OP's car?

buggalugs

9,297 posts

268 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
You obviously have very strong feelings on this issue.

If you buy a timing belt do they warranty your engine?

Edited by buggalugs on Wednesday 16th October 15:58

Blu3R

2,380 posts

230 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Engines that have failed due to burnt valve seats only go to show the misunderstanding of the compatibility of LPG with that particular engine. If you use a valve saver system on seats that are known to be soft then that type of failure won't occur.
Good systems use fuel trims on each injector too which drastically reduces the likelihood of detonation from running lean.
Granted some engines accept LPG better than others and I don't claim to know too much about how or why but stating you'll use 25% more fuel is not true in most cases. 0-20% is more accurate.

Essentially a better understanding of what you've fitted will avoid most of the 'it's crap and ruined my engine' sweeping statements that turn regular people into keyboard warriors.

Griff4.0

Original Poster:

61 posts

268 months

Thursday 17th October 2013
quotequote all
I give up

marskesean

1 posts

144 months

Thursday 25th February 2016
quotequote all
Did you ever get your LPG conversion done? There are great systems for the E91 now. Don't worry about valves and heads on BMW's, I have never heard of a single case of failure due to LPG on any of the 1000's of BMW conversions. One having done 350k since conversion at 80k. Other brands of engine however with soft valves can fail after a few thousand miles.

I'm on my 3rd LPG car, E46 330i manual achieving 360 miles on 54 litres of LPG at £0.49 a litre (petrol £0.99 a litre). Tanks is in the spare wheel well. Beats any diesel on economy but compared to economical diesels a pleasure to drive the straight 6 petrol engine. (I have had a few BMW diesels, true car enthusiasts will always go back to petrol). Also a lot cheaper to buy second hand than equivalent diesel. It's a bit like real ale and lager, lager drinkers will never appreciate real ale smile