Winter tyres on S5: To fit, or not to fit...
Discussion
Hi,
I've put this in here rather than General Gassing, as I'm more interested in views/experiences from other people driving quattro/4motion cars.
I recently replaced my daily driver with a '09 S5 convertible, and it's about to need four new tyres. Given the time of year, I'm contemplating a set of winter tyres (Michelin Alpin PA4) on it, but wondered if anyone had experience to share of need/benefit of fitting winters in the UK.
I happened to have taken t'wife's B7 S4 Avant to work when it really snowed last winter. It hadn't snowed at all when I left home, but whilst at work snowed heavily and most of the 45 miles home were on snow - by the time I got to the back road to our village I was driving on 4 or 5 inches of fresh snow. All this on summers and I was impressed with the stability/grip.
Also any experiences of running winters in summer? I recently read something that suggested that if you're only going to run one set of tyres all year in the UK, that winters would be a better compromise, being less bad in the summer than summer tyres are in winter.
http://www.continental-tyres.co.uk/www/tyres_uk_en...
Taken with a pinch of salt, as it's written by a company trying to sell tyres
Thanks in advance for any thoughts/comments.
I've put this in here rather than General Gassing, as I'm more interested in views/experiences from other people driving quattro/4motion cars.
I recently replaced my daily driver with a '09 S5 convertible, and it's about to need four new tyres. Given the time of year, I'm contemplating a set of winter tyres (Michelin Alpin PA4) on it, but wondered if anyone had experience to share of need/benefit of fitting winters in the UK.
I happened to have taken t'wife's B7 S4 Avant to work when it really snowed last winter. It hadn't snowed at all when I left home, but whilst at work snowed heavily and most of the 45 miles home were on snow - by the time I got to the back road to our village I was driving on 4 or 5 inches of fresh snow. All this on summers and I was impressed with the stability/grip.
Also any experiences of running winters in summer? I recently read something that suggested that if you're only going to run one set of tyres all year in the UK, that winters would be a better compromise, being less bad in the summer than summer tyres are in winter.
http://www.continental-tyres.co.uk/www/tyres_uk_en...
Taken with a pinch of salt, as it's written by a company trying to sell tyres

Thanks in advance for any thoughts/comments.
It really depends on where you live, staying near Aberdeen and having hobbies that involve going more remote places means that my Q7 will be wearing the winter wheels with snow tyres this month.
With (quite well worn) summer tyres it would go in snow but stopping or turning were severely compromised. With the winters on it hard braking on packed snow is effective.
If you're unlikely to be off main roads or live in the south I'd get all season tyres.
With (quite well worn) summer tyres it would go in snow but stopping or turning were severely compromised. With the winters on it hard braking on packed snow is effective.
If you're unlikely to be off main roads or live in the south I'd get all season tyres.
I've got all seasons on my A8. They work very well in much colder and snowier winters, and much hotter summers than anything you'll get in the UK, and don't seem to wear unduly either.
A set of summers and winters would ultimately offer better performance, but not that you'd notice unless you were on the track or in the mountains.
A set of summers and winters would ultimately offer better performance, but not that you'd notice unless you were on the track or in the mountains.
I've got spare set of wheels for winter, 18" alloys and Dunlop Winter Sport 3D tyres.
Traction whilst setting off isn't a problem with quattro but regardless if you have FWD, RWD or AWD, braking is the problem on summer tires and that's where you will see biggest difference.
For the piece of mind and safety is worth getting them if you can afford it. You just need to be careful not to brake too hard so people behind stand no chance ;-)
Traction whilst setting off isn't a problem with quattro but regardless if you have FWD, RWD or AWD, braking is the problem on summer tires and that's where you will see biggest difference.
For the piece of mind and safety is worth getting them if you can afford it. You just need to be careful not to brake too hard so people behind stand no chance ;-)
I shall be putting winter tyres and wheels on my TTS as soon as the temp drops to around 7.
I do around 350-500 miles per week and live in Aberdeenshire, winter tyres for a few months of the year is something i just want to do, but i guess it depends on where you live and how harsh the weather can be.
I used to live in Oxfordshire and never had winter tyres on my mk 1 TT and i never had any problems, but the weather in Aberdeenshire can be a lot harsher, im also now leaving the house at 6 AM and must get to work no matter what or i dont get payed, so a set of winter wheels and tyres is the done thing.
I do around 350-500 miles per week and live in Aberdeenshire, winter tyres for a few months of the year is something i just want to do, but i guess it depends on where you live and how harsh the weather can be.
I used to live in Oxfordshire and never had winter tyres on my mk 1 TT and i never had any problems, but the weather in Aberdeenshire can be a lot harsher, im also now leaving the house at 6 AM and must get to work no matter what or i dont get payed, so a set of winter wheels and tyres is the done thing.
TheHobbit said:
Also any experiences of running winters in summer? I recently read something that suggested that if you're only going to run one set of tyres all year in the UK, that winters would be a better compromise, being less bad in the summer than summer tyres are in winter.
http://www.continental-tyres.co.uk/www/tyres_uk_en...
Taken with a pinch of salt, as it's written by a company trying to sell tyres
Thanks in advance for any thoughts/comments.
I'd also read that Continental quote. And I'm not sure that it makes much difference to them whether you buy one set or two. You can only run one set of rubber at a time, so everything lasts twice as long. If anything, I respect them more for saying that if you can only afford one set, them run the ones that will keep you safer for more of the year.http://www.continental-tyres.co.uk/www/tyres_uk_en...
Taken with a pinch of salt, as it's written by a company trying to sell tyres

Thanks in advance for any thoughts/comments.
That aside, the second year I ran winters on our E61 530d, I ended up not taking them off for the summer (long story, but the fact that I needed two new summer tyres (which I kept putting off as they were £250 each) combined with my general laziness, meant that I left them on so long, it wasn't worth taking them off as they'd have to go back on again in about a month).
So they stayed on. They were Dunlop Winter Sport SP3s and they lasted 24,000 miles on the rear and longer on the front - not sure how much longer they would have gone on as I sold the car and the wheels before they wore out. In fact, the only reason I had to replace the rears was due to the camber on the BM wearing out the inner shoulders.
So as far as I'm concerned there's definitely some truth in that.
Now that I have quattro, I'm not sure I 'need' them as such. Most of the times I had problems in the BM were due to lack of traction to get moving not stopping, but having said that, seeing cars left abandoned everywhere last year, maybe it was only due to having the tyres on, that I didn't have any problems.
As a second point, everything I've read says that you should avoid all-season tyres entirely. They're nowhere near as good as winters in the winter and they're not as good as summers in the summer.*
- Though I did read one test last year that put one set of all-seasons as good as the winters, if not a little better.
What my personal recommendation would be is that you should look at the ratings for the tyres in the cold and wet - as that's what the tyres will have to cope with the most. I only say this as I bought a set of tyres on ebay for waht I thought was a bargain as they were highly rated in the snow, but it turned out the testers had refused to give them an overall rating as they were so-o-o-o bad in the wet. Funnily enough, I took those back (teach me to read the description very carefully next time).
For the recored, I have Pirelli Snowcontrol 190s on my MINI and Dunlop Winter Sport 4D on the Audi. I was going to replace the Snowcontrols as I thought they might be overkill, but their current rating says they're actually very good in the wet.
HTH.
Edited by Kell on Monday 14th October 14:30
I have brought a set of winter wheels for my wifes S4 B8, 18" RS4 replica wheels with Toyo Snowprox S953 600 miles of use £600 from the bay.... be careful to get the correct hub centre bore size.
All our vehicles have winter wheel packages, also we are driving to the alps this christmas so should give them a good test.
All our vehicles have winter wheel packages, also we are driving to the alps this christmas so should give them a good test.
Jim909 said:
I shall be putting winter tyres and wheels on my TTS as soon as the temp drops to around 7.
I do around 350-500 miles per week and live in Aberdeenshire, winter tyres for a few months of the year is something i just want to do, but i guess it depends on where you live and how harsh the weather can be.
I used to live in Oxfordshire and never had winter tyres on my mk 1 TT and i never had any problems, but the weather in Aberdeenshire can be a lot harsher, im also now leaving the house at 6 AM and must get to work no matter what or i dont get payed, so a set of winter wheels and tyres is the done thing.
That's part of the key, I think. I'm in Oxfordshire and I can work from home a bit if the weather turns.I do around 350-500 miles per week and live in Aberdeenshire, winter tyres for a few months of the year is something i just want to do, but i guess it depends on where you live and how harsh the weather can be.
I used to live in Oxfordshire and never had winter tyres on my mk 1 TT and i never had any problems, but the weather in Aberdeenshire can be a lot harsher, im also now leaving the house at 6 AM and must get to work no matter what or i dont get payed, so a set of winter wheels and tyres is the done thing.
As it is, the tyre place near work (Protyre Gloucester) are saying that Michelin Alpin PA4 are in short supply and are out of stock for 6+ weeks minimum.
I need tyres soon/now so I've ordered four Pilot Sport PS3 - They have an "A" rating in the wet, so we'll see how we get on.
Thanks for all the replies and views.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


