2ltr vs 3ltr diesel
Author
Discussion

Roony

Original Poster:

378 posts

260 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
I'm thinking about purchasing an a4 cabrio circ 08 or 09. I will mostly be doing motor way miles and was thinking about the safe 2ltr diesel engine...... But then I thought about the 3ltr..... Can any one tell me pro's and cons of both? Ie running costs? Mpg? Upkeep etc...

any help would be appreciated

thanks

RGambo

888 posts

200 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
One's more powerful and will use more diesel. That's about it really.
My mrg on a motorway is 38-40 in a 3.0 245bhp 3.0 diesel. I think the 2.0 l will average more like 45 on a motorway.

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
I've previously owned the older 2.0 TDI manual in a 2005 A4 Avant. The most I ever got out of it was 47 MPG on a motorway run. And that was trying.

My current 2008 A6 3.0 TDI Tip will see 42 MPG under the same conditions (sticking to 70).

3.0 every day smile

Freedomfighter

170 posts

161 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
Good luck with the 2.0tdi, well known issues with the engine whereas the 3.0tdi is bombproof. Look around on net about the issues with the 2.0tdi, scary stuff! I should know, my cousins went on him and it went from being worth £11k to £3-4k due to needing a new engine etc....

Freedomfighter

170 posts

161 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
A problem of later 2.0TDI PD 140s and 170s is failure of the oil pump. The oil pump is driven from a balancre shaft via a short hexagonal shaft. The peaks of this hexagonal shaft locate in six corresponding but minute grooves machined within the otherwise circular-bored oil pump drive shaft. Thus, the oil pump drive relies entirely on an interference fit of little more than 0.010" along the peaks of the hexagonal shaft. After about 50,000 miles, the shaft can round off, resulting in a totally destroyed engine and turbo, plus a bill of up to £9,000. If the danger is known and the oil pump is removed by the garage in good time, a new replacement pump will cost over £500, plus the labour etc to remove and refit it. However, it is also possible to save the old pump and modify the drive at a fraction of the cost of a new one. Many local machine shops already have numbers of these pumps in for such rectification, the drive shaft of each having been on the point of rounding off.

Courtesy of honest john

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
Freedomfighter said:
A problem of later 2.0TDI PD 140s and 170s is failure of the oil pump. The oil pump is driven from a balancre shaft via a short hexagonal shaft. The peaks of this hexagonal shaft locate in six corresponding but minute grooves machined within the otherwise circular-bored oil pump drive shaft. Thus, the oil pump drive relies entirely on an interference fit of little more than 0.010" along the peaks of the hexagonal shaft. After about 50,000 miles, the shaft can round off, resulting in a totally destroyed engine and turbo, plus a bill of up to £9,000. If the danger is known and the oil pump is removed by the garage in good time, a new replacement pump will cost over £500, plus the labour etc to remove and refit it. However, it is also possible to save the old pump and modify the drive at a fraction of the cost of a new one. Many local machine shops already have numbers of these pumps in for such rectification, the drive shaft of each having been on the point of rounding off.

Courtesy of honest john
IIRC it was 2.0 TDIs upto mid 2006 that had the ste oil pump.

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Sunday 13th October 2013
quotequote all
Later B7 engines were better but that 2.0 at that point is still no peach. 3.0 is in a completely different league.

Roony

Original Poster:

378 posts

260 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
Thanks all, never realised that the 2 ltrs had such problems... is this not the most popular deisel engine ever! So long as I can achieve 40 mpg from a 3ltr on the motorway run that is good enough for me!

Freedomfighter

170 posts

161 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
Roony said:
Thanks all, never realised that the 2 ltrs had such problems... is this not the most popular deisel engine ever! So long as I can achieve 40 mpg from a 3ltr on the motorway run that is good enough for me!
You'll get 40mpg plus a whole load of fun with the 3.0tdi. I'm so impressed with mine it's fantastic. If you frequent the Audi forums etc they are held in high esteem. Yes the 2.0tdi is popular, IMO due to peoples perceived running costs etc but when you take into account the benefits of the 3.0 I.e the power, reliability, 6 cylinder rather than 4, it's apparent theirs only one winner!

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
Roony said:
Thanks all, never realised that the 2 ltrs had such problems... is this not the most popular deisel engine ever! So long as I can achieve 40 mpg from a 3ltr on the motorway run that is good enough for me!
You'll be fine with 40 on the motorway smile