2006 (06)Golf GTI Vs 2007 (57) Leon Cupra
2006 (06)Golf GTI Vs 2007 (57) Leon Cupra
Author
Discussion

Tame Technician

Original Poster:

2,467 posts

235 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
As usual when one if my mates want to buy a car, I get dragged in to look over them and offer advice. Then they ignore my advice and buy something slower, more economical and boring. But not this time.

Mate wants a hot hatch. Needs to be 5 door, and wont have the focus ST I recommended. (we all love 5 cylinders here dont we)

So after some autotrader we are drawn between two cars, both under 45k miles with good history, very similar money.

Seat has 240bhp so I'm advising that, golf should be better built and has same basic engine box, running gear but tune is only 200bhp.

Anyone out there owned either or both who can offer an opinion or view, we would be very grateful.




VS



Edited by Tame Technician on Monday 14th October 21:58

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Monday 14th October 2013
quotequote all
as you have said the golf is a bit better built, nice interior, worth more and visibility is a tad better

however the cupra has a bigger turbo(ko4 based i believe) and will hit more or less 300bhp with a remap

depends what he is after and if he could live with the cupra for example, i personally think the mk5 golf is fairly bland unless its a edition 30 myself

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
Pre-facelift hot SEATs ride very hard. The interior isn't great, but it isn't as woeful as some people like to claim. Those huge front pillars make rear visibility better than front.

shtu

4,622 posts

177 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
If the residual value matters to them, the VW will be a better bet.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
shtu said:
If the residual value matters to them, the VW will be a better bet.
That is true - but only if the cost the same to buy.

TBH, I thik that that generation Seat is ugly. Much prefered the looks of the one that came out with the MKIV Golf.

Because of that, I'd have the Golf.

the-photographer

5,217 posts

207 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
You could have your cake and eat it, by finding an ED30 Golf!

Otherwise, they are basically the same car (Leon with the S3 engine) so its really personal preference.

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
Presumably we're talking around £6-7k here, based on year/models that are being shown? You'd be pretty damn lucky to find a tidy ED30 for that little.

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
ed30's are about 10k still, and the k1 leon looks much better than the standard cupra

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
I'd go with the Leon as it has the better engine.

K1 is just a body kit on a standard cupra.

But......if you can then possibly stretch to an Edition 30 although they are still strong money for a good one and believe me good ones are hard to find.

the-photographer

5,217 posts

207 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
chris285 said:
ed30's are about 10k still, and the k1 leon looks much better than the standard cupra
Ah, in that case the best GTI you can find then.

si_xsi

1,325 posts

226 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
i was in exactly the same position and car choice this time last year. Both good cars in themselves - although i never got round to test driving the Cupra.

In the end i went for the mk V gti as i prefered the looks, interior and slightly better residuals. Its just the best compromise and all rounder. if my budget had stretched (i needed a car not more than 4 yrs old due to car allowance reasons) i would of gone with the facelift cupra with the better interior. Both are quite rare cars and difficult to find an unmolestered example.

I think with the cupra you would notice the extra pull from 50-60mph onwards, but economy would be a little worse. I hear they ride quite firm. I regulalry see 35-38mpg in the gti which is as claimed on my daily commute and it never really drops below 28 when you press on, although i did acheive 22mpg when i had to rush back one evening last week but i wont go there biggrin


ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
I don't know how you're managing 38mpg. I can't get above 35 even if I drive like a saint. I'm averaging about 30.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
The only time I saw more than 30 in my Edition 30 was when I done a 200 mile trip from Edinburgh to Croft!. Even then it was only 30.9.

SkyJawa

11 posts

260 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
Also, if it matters, Golf has a NCAP rating of 5 against the Seat's 4.

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
Tell him to just get the focus ST you suggested, much more interesting.

billzeebub

3,913 posts

230 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
I love everything about this gen Golf GTI. 100% the Golf

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
SkyJawa said:
Also, if it matters, Golf has a NCAP rating of 5 against the Seat's 4.
That's a good point which is often forgotten. The A3 and Octavia from that era also 'only' got got 4-stars. Not sure what the difference was to make the Golf score higher.

Crafty_

14,234 posts

231 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
Don't forget its not just engine, the Leon will have better brakes (4pot brembos if I remember rightly?)

If the friend wants to fit in with the VW cricle jerk, get the golf.
If he wants a better car ot drive, get the Leon.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
The Leon has better brakes over the golf but not 4 pots. That was only the mk1 Cupra R

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
AGK said:
The Leon has better brakes over the golf but not 4 pots. That was only the mk1 Cupra R
yep the mk1 leon had 323mm brembo 4pot setup, the mk2 leon is seat sport brakes but they are better than the brembo's