Anyone driven a Performante and 16M
Anyone driven a Performante and 16M
Author
Discussion

batmanbegins

Original Poster:

149 posts

186 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
How do they compare? Gallardo range is too big and despite being about to be replaced, Performante looks like good value at circa £130k for a soft top Superleggera when the softtop Scud aka 16M is circa £180k (e.g. http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/l...

I guess you'll get more of a slap in the face on residuals on the Gallardo. Anyone driven both though and can offer an opinion on comparisons?

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
drive a 16m, and you'll run the risk of being mistaken for andrewd frown

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
I haven't driven either so can't answer the question but was told that new Gallardo is going to be circa £200k with the essential options and far from hurting residuals current Gallardo's could firm up ?
Can see the logic as I'm sure F430 residuals have been held up by 458 prices

With any car its about buying at the right time and for me after the major depreciation has already occurred.

I'm currently looking to add 1 from the following 3 :
458
MP4 12C
or Gallardo 560-4

You pays your money you take your chance I guess

AndrewD

7,659 posts

315 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
I had 4 Gallardos before I got my 16m. IMO the Performante is a spammed up Lp560 spyder, whilst the 16m is the real deal

marcusjames

785 posts

292 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
andrew said:
drive a 16m, and you'll run the risk of being mistaken for andrewd frown
^^ What he said!

woppum

1,137 posts

217 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
Yeah you don't want that. Bit poxy inside too.
What about a 458 Spyder.

APOLO1

5,400 posts

225 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
I haven't driven either so can't answer the question but was told that new Gallardo is going to be circa £200k with the essential options and far from hurting residuals current Gallardo's could firm up ?
Can see the logic as I'm sure F430 residuals have been held up by 458 prices

With any car its about buying at the right time and for me after the major depreciation has already occurred.

I'm currently looking to add 1 from the following 3 :
458
MP4 12C
or Gallardo 560-4

You pays your money you take your chance I guess
I have never owned a 458, Have driven a few...Not as fast IMHO as they are made out to be. Along with the worst deprecation of the bunch. Way to many unsold cars around...IMHO

The 12C is epic, but beware the face lift is only a few months away....

I owned 570/4 SP. Spider last summer. Taking into account that the chassis is almost 10 years old the steering is a bit RR discovery like. The car was epic. The sound of the V10 with the roof down....Doesn't get any better.....never missed a beat in 5 months on 7k miles, including 2 trips to Monaco and back...

Bunty Killa

534 posts

230 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Performante better looking car

Murcielago_Boy

2,014 posts

270 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
The 16M is far from perfect (but then I have some kind of problem with every modern Ferrari) but it's the most fun production car they've made for ages.

LamboCraig

108 posts

165 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
More Raw to drive, an exceptional sound, great balance with little scuttle flex and superb weighted steering. One other thing it has buckets of torque through the rev range ! (LP570-4)

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
APOLO1 said:
I have never owned a 458, Have driven a few...Not as fast IMHO as they are made out to be. Along with the worst deprecation of the bunch. Way to many unsold cars around...IMHO

The 12C is epic, but beware the face lift is only a few months away....

I owned 570/4 SP. Spider last summer. Taking into account that the chassis is almost 10 years old the steering is a bit RR discovery like. The car was epic. The sound of the V10 with the roof down....Doesn't get any better.....never missed a beat in 5 months on 7k miles, including 2 trips to Monaco and back...
Interesting thoughts from an owner.

I too am not a fan of the 458, and there are way too many of them out there.

I love the 12C and prefer it to the 458, but it seems to me that valuations need to settle down a bit and there is a danger of over paying.

The Lamborghini looks like a solid bet if you buy wisely and don't pay too much.

Much as we love these cars, having your trousers pulled down each time you sell does tend to taint the experience IMO. I guess I am just a tightarse. smile

APOLO1

5,400 posts

225 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
toppstuff said:
Interesting thoughts from an owner.

I too am not a fan of the 458, and there are way too many of them out there.

I love the 12C and prefer it to the 458, but it seems to me that valuations need to settle down a bit and there is a danger of over paying.

The Lamborghini looks like a solid bet if you buy wisely and don't pay too much.

Much as we love these cars, having your trousers pulled down each time you sell does tend to taint the experience IMO. I guess I am just a tightarse. smile
Not being a tight arse....It called being prudent......To use the words of Gordon Brown.. The 12C is IMHO fair value now..... I would forget the 458 including the SP to say its about to be upstaged in all areas is understatement IMHO.

The Lmabo was an absolute riot.....

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
APOLO1 said:
Not being a tight arse....It called being prudent......To use the words of Gordon Brown.. The 12C is IMHO fair value now..... I would forget the 458 including the SP to say its about to be upstaged in all areas is understatement IMHO.

The Lmabo was an absolute riot.....
Prudent is the word when its your entire life savings. I'm use to losing circa £10k a year depreciation plus running costs and sacrifice everything else to have a nice car,changing it on average every 18 months.
I can't afford to have my pants completely taken doen every time as at this end of the market the buying/selling costs are at least another £10k each time.

Need to make sure the next car is the "right one" and potential keeper to go with my F355 GTS.

Always had Ferrari's so my heart is drawn to 458 and general feedback seems to be its the best of that bunch of 3.

MP4 -12C appeals on paper but not sure its such a WOW as the Ferrari and was unaware of the facelift and what that might do to residuals

Lambo is the wild one but its an old car even in LP format looking very similar to a 2004 car and again a new model is due end of 2014 so residual is the question mark along with the E-gear transmission

Decisions decisions decisions - the ferrari seems the safest bet overall but the most expensive as well

Any opinions from owners or potential owners always valued

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
Prudent is the word when its your entire life savings. I'm use to losing circa £10k a year depreciation plus running costs and sacrifice everything else to have a nice car,changing it on average every 18 months.
I can't afford to have my pants completely taken doen every time as at this end of the market the buying/selling costs are at least another £10k each time.

Need to make sure the next car is the "right one" and potential keeper to go with my F355 GTS.

Always had Ferrari's so my heart is drawn to 458 and general feedback seems to be its the best of that bunch of 3.

MP4 -12C appeals on paper but not sure its such a WOW as the Ferrari and was unaware of the facelift and what that might do to residuals

Lambo is the wild one but its an old car even in LP format looking very similar to a 2004 car and again a new model is due end of 2014 so residual is the question mark along with the E-gear transmission

Decisions decisions decisions - the ferrari seems the safest bet overall but the most expensive as well

Any opinions from owners or potential owners always valued
I agree with APOLO's analysis that the 458 is over-supplied in the UK and there are too many of them. Prices are on a precipice IMO.

Robbo66

3,930 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
Prudent is the word when its your entire life savings. I'm use to losing circa £10k a year depreciation plus running costs and sacrifice everything else to have a nice car,changing it on average every 18 months.
I can't afford to have my pants completely taken doen every time as at this end of the market the buying/selling costs are at least another £10k each time.

Need to make sure the next car is the "right one" and potential keeper to go with my F355 GTS.

Always had Ferrari's so my heart is drawn to 458 and general feedback seems to be its the best of that bunch of 3.

MP4 -12C appeals on paper but not sure its such a WOW as the Ferrari and was unaware of the facelift and what that might do to residuals

Lambo is the wild one but its an old car even in LP format looking very similar to a 2004 car and again a new model is due end of 2014 so residual is the question mark along with the E-gear transmission

Decisions decisions decisions - the ferrari seems the safest bet overall but the most expensive as well

Any opinions from owners or potential owners always valued
How you feel sticking your cash into a 458 is the 'safest bet' beggars belief IMO.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Robbo66 said:
How you feel sticking your cash into a 458 is the 'safest bet' beggars belief IMO.
I don't think there is a clear cut winner so open to other suggestions and opinions to help me make up my mind

They are all terrific cars, with plus and minus points but residual value is equally as important as the car itself with my limited funds.

I agree 458 is in oversupply but prices are being carefully managed up. MP4 - 12C is equally in oversupply at the moment given that its probably even more niche market than Ferrari
Lambo market is all over the place with all the different incarnations and knowing what the best option is difficult and running costs are more expensive

Robbo66

3,930 posts

264 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
I agree 458 is in oversupply but prices are being carefully managed up.
No...the RRP prices are being 'carefully managed up', not the trade bid to the poor soul who is getting out of one.
So you buy extremely high, and sell extremely low. Worst case scenario, but again your choice.

toppstuff

13,698 posts

278 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Robbo66 said:
GRBF430F1 said:
I agree 458 is in oversupply but prices are being carefully managed up.
No...the RRP prices are being 'carefully managed up', not the trade bid to the poor soul who is getting out of one.
So you buy extremely high, and sell extremely low. Worst case scenario, but again your choice.
Yep - I think the spread between retail and trade is huuuuge right now.

APOLO1

5,400 posts

225 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
I don't think there is a clear cut winner so open to other suggestions and opinions to help me make up my mind

They are all terrific cars, with plus and minus points but residual value is equally as important as the car itself with my limited funds.

I agree 458 is in oversupply but prices are being carefully managed up. MP4 - 12C is equally in oversupply at the moment given that its probably even more niche market than Ferrari
Lambo market is all over the place with all the different incarnations and knowing what the best option is difficult and running costs are more expensive
carefully managed up dream on.. Lol.with the 458 you can get what you want for what you what well almost.....In my view the face lift price is already factored into the 12c. The new one which will sell out over night in my view, will be 250Kish with a good spec.....But it will have no peers this side of the 918, Lfa, and P1.

If it were me I would be going for LP570/4 SP at 120-130k, how many RHDs are there 12-14?

footsoldier

2,298 posts

223 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Do you know how the MCL policy of ongoing upgrades to 12C will apply to the 'facelift' spec? ie will any of the improvements be available to existing pre-lift owners. or is this a re-set?

This seems to be one of the biggest impediments to new sales of 12C - I look at classifieds and think there's little difference at the moment between an upgraded £125k 2011 model and a new one.