Rs4 b7 test drive - knocking gearbox
Rs4 b7 test drive - knocking gearbox
Author
Discussion

stef1808

Original Poster:

1,036 posts

188 months

Tuesday 15th October 2013
quotequote all
The rs4 saloon I drove has 55k on the clock and is built 2007 being sold by a private dealer

The first shift I did into 1st refused to go into gear. The salesman just said let go of the clutch and try again

So I tried again and didn't go again. He then said your pushing the gear to far and just needs a little bit. When I did this it went no problem.

On getting the car checked I was warned also about "knocking" from the gearbox

Is this anything to be concerned about

1 person told me to stay away the gearbox is on its way out but maybe I'm looking to much into it

Any thoughts?

Thanks
S

Ps: as I put down my deposit, the dealer told me last buyer of the car was put off the car from the gearbox decide not to buy it and lost his deposit.


Edited by stef1808 on Tuesday 15th October 21:14

Murph7355

42,099 posts

287 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
I tried a few prior to buying mine and don't recall gearbox knocks or difficulty shifting in any of them (and some were ropey cars).

Good ones might be getting harder to find, but not impossible. So I'd walk personally. Unless it's very cheap and a specialist looked it over and gave a decent diagnosis/cost to fix (even then, tbh, I'd prefer it was fixed before purchase).

16plates

1,927 posts

158 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Sounds odd. Never heard of it being a common issue on B7's.

I'd probably walk away to be honest. There are good cars out there for sensible money and, in some cases, with warranties.

That said it could be as straight forward as a clutch master/slave cylinder or even low fluid... Worth checking i suppose.






graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Sounds unusual, and being a big ticket item, I'd take a walk.
I've not heard of those symptoms before, but it could be that if the clutch was replaced, but not the dual mass flywheel, which is often the cheapskate option (it's good practice to replace both at the same time), this failing could cause difficulty going into gear, but I wouldn't have thought it would manifest itself as a 'knocking'
Either way, there's plenty of B7 saloons on the market not to have to buy a risky car
DrG on here is your man if you want an indy inspection

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Wednesday 16th October 2013
quotequote all
Definitely doesn't sound right; B7 gearbox even when cold is easy to use.

I would want to know what was wrong and what it cost before putting money into that. It wouldn't be unreasonable to expect a dealer selling such a thing to be a bit proactive about resolving such a conspicuous fault.