Discussion
Hi all just dropping by to say hello...
Have finally ticked the box and completed my full set of German brands having purchased my first Audi.....
Although not new... It's new to me... I've gone for an A6 3.2 Quattro (2005) Hoping the 4wd will make the winter a little easier...
So hello to all.
Rags
Have finally ticked the box and completed my full set of German brands having purchased my first Audi.....
Although not new... It's new to me... I've gone for an A6 3.2 Quattro (2005) Hoping the 4wd will make the winter a little easier...
So hello to all.
Rags
Edited by Raggie on Saturday 19th October 19:08
Thanks... I have been on the bay trying to find a set of wheels for the winter...
Totally top value for money.... Well I thought so. Little concerned over the internet stories of timing chain stretching... But I faced the fear of bore scoring on the porker so this is no different...(fingers crossed)....
Rags
Totally top value for money.... Well I thought so. Little concerned over the internet stories of timing chain stretching... But I faced the fear of bore scoring on the porker so this is no different...(fingers crossed)....
Rags
blueg33 said:
Bear in mind that in snow quattro helps you get going pretty well, stopping and turning though is just the same as a non quattro except you tend to be going faster.
(unless you fit winter tyres)
That's not the case. Engine breaking on the Quattro is far superior because it is distributed through all four wheels. Weight distribution is also nearer neutral due to the extra weight of the drivetrain at the rear, and the 4 wheel drive vehicles have a different ratio to the steering rack; all of this improving handling and stopping.(unless you fit winter tyres)
J
jith said:
blueg33 said:
Bear in mind that in snow quattro helps you get going pretty well, stopping and turning though is just the same as a non quattro except you tend to be going faster.
(unless you fit winter tyres)
That's not the case. Engine breaking on the Quattro is far superior because it is distributed through all four wheels. Weight distribution is also nearer neutral due to the extra weight of the drivetrain at the rear, and the 4 wheel drive vehicles have a different ratio to the steering rack; all of this improving handling and stopping.(unless you fit winter tyres)
J
Outback
Fabia
A6
The A6 is no better at stopping and turning in the snow than the E60 5 series or the Volvo V70 that preceeded it. It still had wide tyres that turn into ski's, it has lots of mass and quattro means you get going more easily, tend to go faster and have more momentum which add to the issues.
Kidding yourself that this is not the case will (in snow) lead to a nasty surprise.
I note from your profile that you have never had a quattro - please don't let theory confuse you about the reality
blueg33 said:
jith said:
blueg33 said:
Bear in mind that in snow quattro helps you get going pretty well, stopping and turning though is just the same as a non quattro except you tend to be going faster.
(unless you fit winter tyres)
That's not the case. Engine breaking on the Quattro is far superior because it is distributed through all four wheels. Weight distribution is also nearer neutral due to the extra weight of the drivetrain at the rear, and the 4 wheel drive vehicles have a different ratio to the steering rack; all of this improving handling and stopping.(unless you fit winter tyres)
J
Outback
Fabia
A6
The A6 is no better at stopping and turning in the snow than the E60 5 series or the Volvo V70 that preceeded it. It still had wide tyres that turn into ski's, it has lots of mass and quattro means you get going more easily, tend to go faster and have more momentum which add to the issues.
Kidding yourself that this is not the case will (in snow) lead to a nasty surprise.
I note from your profile that you have never had a quattro - please don't let theory confuse you about the reality
Well I think you need to open your eyes a bit more. Did you note from my profile the bit about over 40 years experience in motor engineering and development.
At the moment I own 4 Audis. But more appropriately I owned one of the first URs in Scotland; a left hand drive square headlamp model. That was when I worked on the rally cars incidentally. In my workshop right now is a 100 Quattro Turbo Avante with a manual gearbox, an original 100 S4, a UR and a Cabriolet.
This week we have 2 more URs in, a 90 Quattro 20 valve Sport, an S8, an S4 Bi-turbo and whatever else needs my attention. If my life depended on it right now, I couldn't tell you how many Quattros I've owned and driven.
You will doubtless remember the winter of 2 years ago. Now what is that I have just arrived in outside my workshop? Oh look! An A6 2.8 30 valve QUATTRO!


Believe it or not it went around corners and stopped very well indeed. In fact that day it was 18 degrees below and as you can see from the photos I was the only one open in the estate.
Oh, and by the way, I'm also a police trained Class 1 advanced driver; that's not in my profile either. What it does is give you the ability to make Quattros stop and steer in the snow as well as go.
I see from your profile you're a property developer. That'll make you yet another expert on here then, eh?
J
jith said:
You note from my profile do you?
Well I think you need to open your eyes a bit more. Did you note from my profile the bit about over 40 years experience in motor engineering and development.
At the moment I own 4 Audis. But more appropriately I owned one of the first URs in Scotland; a left hand drive square headlamp model. That was when I worked on the rally cars incidentally. In my workshop right now is a 100 Quattro Turbo Avante with a manual gearbox, an original 100 S4, a UR and a Cabriolet.
This week we have 2 more URs in, a 90 Quattro 20 valve Sport, an S8, an S4 Bi-turbo and whatever else needs my attention. If my life depended on it right now, I couldn't tell you how many Quattros I've owned and driven.
You will doubtless remember the winter of 2 years ago. Now what is that I have just arrived in outside my workshop? Oh look! An A6 2.8 30 valve QUATTRO!


Believe it or not it went around corners and stopped very well indeed. In fact that day it was 18 degrees below and as you can see from the photos I was the only one open in the estate.
Oh, and by the way, I'm also a police trained Class 1 advanced driver; that's not in my profile either. What it does is give you the ability to make Quattros stop and steer in the snow as well as go.
I see from your profile you're a property developer. That'll make you yet another expert on here then, eh?
J
Touchy or what! I was going on the info available to me.Well I think you need to open your eyes a bit more. Did you note from my profile the bit about over 40 years experience in motor engineering and development.
At the moment I own 4 Audis. But more appropriately I owned one of the first URs in Scotland; a left hand drive square headlamp model. That was when I worked on the rally cars incidentally. In my workshop right now is a 100 Quattro Turbo Avante with a manual gearbox, an original 100 S4, a UR and a Cabriolet.
This week we have 2 more URs in, a 90 Quattro 20 valve Sport, an S8, an S4 Bi-turbo and whatever else needs my attention. If my life depended on it right now, I couldn't tell you how many Quattros I've owned and driven.
You will doubtless remember the winter of 2 years ago. Now what is that I have just arrived in outside my workshop? Oh look! An A6 2.8 30 valve QUATTRO!


Believe it or not it went around corners and stopped very well indeed. In fact that day it was 18 degrees below and as you can see from the photos I was the only one open in the estate.
Oh, and by the way, I'm also a police trained Class 1 advanced driver; that's not in my profile either. What it does is give you the ability to make Quattros stop and steer in the snow as well as go.
I see from your profile you're a property developer. That'll make you yet another expert on here then, eh?
J
I agree quattros go round corners well in the dry and the wet, but I still think you are wrong, having driven quattro's here in the UK and in the Alps in winter many times, often back to back with 2wd equivalent, I maintain that it is misleading to suggest that a quattro on summer tyres stops and steers any better than a 2wd on snow, certainly to any degree that most drivers would notice.
Put a quattro on winter tyres and its noticeabley better than its 2wd cousins on winter tyres.
I am not a motor engineer, but I have considerable drving experience both on the road in competition.
Maybe, you would like to offer a personal indemnity to everyone who reads your comments and decides that their quattro on summer tyres will stop and turn in snow as effectively as it gains speed.
Physics is much the same with 2wd and quattro when it comes to stopping and turning in snow. Momentum is much the same, the friction coeffcient of the tures doing the steering is much the same.
I have tried doing spome reserach this morning, I can find plenty of evidence that quattro gets you going better, but no evidence at all that it helps you stop or turn in snow, in most cases the evidence is quite the contrary.
Or maybe read what specialist (not marketing departments) say
This research shows stopping distances for 2wd and 4wd on snow to be identical with the same tyres
Research Paper
Mac Demere said:
"Sure-footed all-wheel-drive handling." That's the kind of lingo you're likely to hear in car ads and marketing material, and it has prompted me to shout at televisions, print ads, and the occasional car-company rep: All-wheel drive doesn't help handling!
It's disingenuous to say or infer that AWD enhances cornering prowess, or that it'll help a driver avoid a fallen tree or dodge Bambi. When it comes to handling, all-wheel drive is overrated (not to mention heavy and gas-sucking), especially in foul weather.
"I'd rather have a Camry on four new snow tires than the best all-wheel-drive vehicle on all-season tires," said one tester who requested anonymity.
Before you start flaming, I'm not anti-AWD. Rather, I'm just incensed by those who fudge its ability beyond all recognition. AWD is great at aiding accelerating on slick surfaces and keeping a vehicle moving on snowy roads. Rally racers like AWD because it helps their over-powered cars accelerate on gravel and dirt paths. I co-drove an AWD car to victory in a 24-hour race, and in the rain I enjoyed how the car accelerated off the corners.
However, my experience—hard-earned from wrecking more than one AWD vehicle during snow-handling tests for a tire company—is that AWD is counter-productive when the roads are slick. At the same time AWD doesn't improve your handling, it does offer an overly optimistic sense of available traction, and it provides the potential to be going so much faster when you need to stop. (Note to those from warm climes: Snowbanks are not puffy and cushiony.) The laws of physics mean a vehicle's cornering power is the job of the tires and suspension.
"In the snow, it is all about the tires," says automotive engineer Neil Hannemann, whose resume includes helping to develop the original Dodge Viper, creating a proof-of-concept vehicle for the original all-wheel-drive Chrysler minivan, and driving ice racers on frozen lakes. Having power to four wheels rather than two sounds like it would help the car handle, which is why you see those ads that infuriate me. But good tires beat AWD.
Some disagree, saying AWD helps bad-weather handling because it quells power on oversteer, the fishtailing rear-drive cars experience when a ham-footed driver is too rough on the accelerator. It is true that AWD is excellent at preventing the tail from stepping out under power. But this is not "improving handling." It's really aiding acceleration.
And it's true that some advanced AWD systems now on the market help the car turn a little bit if the driver is assertively pushing the accelerator; they do it by dragging the inside wheel and diverting more force to the outside wheel. But my experience, and that of the test drivers I consulted, found little more than a small benefit. Once the tires' grip limit is reached, no more can be created. (For nitpickers and engineers: Yes, more aerodynamic downforce will increase grip, but I'm talking about road-going vehicles at highway-legal speeds, where that kind of performance edge isn't really applicable.)
There are more advanced AWD systems on the horizon. These torque-vectoring differentials are advanced versions of the current systems that cause one or more tires to turn faster or slower. The goal of these systems is to harness the grip all four tires have to offer.
Even so, we're talking about minor improvements. If you're looking for the peace of mind in knowing that you'll be able to get home if an unexpected snowstorm hits, AWD may be a good choice for you. However, if you think that AWD will help your car better grip slippery corners or dodge an indecisive squirrel, you're sadly mistaken. A good set of snow tires is a better investment if you live where it snows frequently or if the highway department is poor at plowing roads.
It's disingenuous to say or infer that AWD enhances cornering prowess, or that it'll help a driver avoid a fallen tree or dodge Bambi. When it comes to handling, all-wheel drive is overrated (not to mention heavy and gas-sucking), especially in foul weather.
"I'd rather have a Camry on four new snow tires than the best all-wheel-drive vehicle on all-season tires," said one tester who requested anonymity.
Before you start flaming, I'm not anti-AWD. Rather, I'm just incensed by those who fudge its ability beyond all recognition. AWD is great at aiding accelerating on slick surfaces and keeping a vehicle moving on snowy roads. Rally racers like AWD because it helps their over-powered cars accelerate on gravel and dirt paths. I co-drove an AWD car to victory in a 24-hour race, and in the rain I enjoyed how the car accelerated off the corners.
However, my experience—hard-earned from wrecking more than one AWD vehicle during snow-handling tests for a tire company—is that AWD is counter-productive when the roads are slick. At the same time AWD doesn't improve your handling, it does offer an overly optimistic sense of available traction, and it provides the potential to be going so much faster when you need to stop. (Note to those from warm climes: Snowbanks are not puffy and cushiony.) The laws of physics mean a vehicle's cornering power is the job of the tires and suspension.
"In the snow, it is all about the tires," says automotive engineer Neil Hannemann, whose resume includes helping to develop the original Dodge Viper, creating a proof-of-concept vehicle for the original all-wheel-drive Chrysler minivan, and driving ice racers on frozen lakes. Having power to four wheels rather than two sounds like it would help the car handle, which is why you see those ads that infuriate me. But good tires beat AWD.
Some disagree, saying AWD helps bad-weather handling because it quells power on oversteer, the fishtailing rear-drive cars experience when a ham-footed driver is too rough on the accelerator. It is true that AWD is excellent at preventing the tail from stepping out under power. But this is not "improving handling." It's really aiding acceleration.
And it's true that some advanced AWD systems now on the market help the car turn a little bit if the driver is assertively pushing the accelerator; they do it by dragging the inside wheel and diverting more force to the outside wheel. But my experience, and that of the test drivers I consulted, found little more than a small benefit. Once the tires' grip limit is reached, no more can be created. (For nitpickers and engineers: Yes, more aerodynamic downforce will increase grip, but I'm talking about road-going vehicles at highway-legal speeds, where that kind of performance edge isn't really applicable.)
There are more advanced AWD systems on the horizon. These torque-vectoring differentials are advanced versions of the current systems that cause one or more tires to turn faster or slower. The goal of these systems is to harness the grip all four tires have to offer.
Even so, we're talking about minor improvements. If you're looking for the peace of mind in knowing that you'll be able to get home if an unexpected snowstorm hits, AWD may be a good choice for you. However, if you think that AWD will help your car better grip slippery corners or dodge an indecisive squirrel, you're sadly mistaken. A good set of snow tires is a better investment if you live where it snows frequently or if the highway department is poor at plowing roads.
Edited by blueg33 on Monday 21st October 15:10
Hey Guys.. the reason I went for the Quattro was last winter I was in a Merc C250 Auto.. which was pushed out of the snow by some kids.. the winter before in a BMW Cabro with Run Flats.. where I couldn't get out of a hotel car park without a tow..
So with or without winter tyres I have to be on a better chance with this one..
That said.. the winter tyre hunt is on going and they will be fitted when the temp drops enough to get value from them..

So with or without winter tyres I have to be on a better chance with this one..

That said.. the winter tyre hunt is on going and they will be fitted when the temp drops enough to get value from them..

I'm with blueg33 here.
My previous B7 A4 Quattro went through it's first winter with me on almost new dunlop summer tyres. On it's second winter I had mid range Kumho winters on. The difference in the stopping ability alone of the car with winters on was pronounced.
But what do I know, I'm just a telecommunications engineer
My previous B7 A4 Quattro went through it's first winter with me on almost new dunlop summer tyres. On it's second winter I had mid range Kumho winters on. The difference in the stopping ability alone of the car with winters on was pronounced.
But what do I know, I'm just a telecommunications engineer

Dr G said:
Talent, experience and quattro with regard to everything except traction will only offer slight improvements on snow.
If you want more stopping and more turning you need to add more friction.
Thats what I thought, but an automotive engineer (see above) says I am wrong.If you want more stopping and more turning you need to add more friction.
All of the research I can find and all of the maths relates to the friction coefficient of the tyre and the surface, they all make it clear that awd does not and cannot create friction.
My experience of driving my RS4 in the snow is that engine braking is very good - and driving carefully with plenty of forward planning means you can keep off the brakes most of the time.
A good 4WD system doesn't magically create grip but makes the best of what you have.
Engine braking distributed to all 4 wheels, rather than 100% of engine braking effort on the front wheels or 75% of braking to the front wheels.
Agreed I'm sure 2wd with winters will be better than 4wd on summers.
But - my experience is that proper 4wd is better than 2wd if both on summers.
Ignoring haldex stuff ( which I also have in Audi and Volvo variations)
A good 4WD system doesn't magically create grip but makes the best of what you have.
Engine braking distributed to all 4 wheels, rather than 100% of engine braking effort on the front wheels or 75% of braking to the front wheels.
Agreed I'm sure 2wd with winters will be better than 4wd on summers.
But - my experience is that proper 4wd is better than 2wd if both on summers.
Ignoring haldex stuff ( which I also have in Audi and Volvo variations)
Raggie said:
Hi all just dropping by to say hello...
Have finally ticked the box and completed my full set of German brands having purchased my first Audi.....
Although not new... It's new to me... I've gone for an A6 3.2 Quattro (2005) Hoping the 4wd will make the winter a little easier...
So hello to all.
Rags
Congratulations, I love my Quattro...it made short work of last winter's snow.Have finally ticked the box and completed my full set of German brands having purchased my first Audi.....
Although not new... It's new to me... I've gone for an A6 3.2 Quattro (2005) Hoping the 4wd will make the winter a little easier...
So hello to all.
Rags
Edited by Raggie on Saturday 19th October 19:08
Any pics of your 3.2?
Thanks y2 blade.. Only picked up this PM so none yet.... Will get some by the weekend though.
For an 8 year old car it has surprisd me with how well it's aging.... Few things that are not perfect... Couple of car park dings... alloys not perfectly balanced..so had to take it straight to the tyre boys...and some marks on the leather I didn't notice during the viewing...
But for the winter hack purposes (with the winter tyres) it's looks like it will be fine... But just to make sure it's booked in to a local audi specialist this week for a health check... Not that I didn't trust the dealer, he seemed very straight and fair,,, but his "prepared for sale" amd my "yes that's good" are were always going to be on a different level...
I have been known to clash with Main Dealers on the prep on my new cars.. So this dealer wouldn't have stood a chance if I applied the same standard....lol..
That said four hours into my ownership he is still getting a thumbs up.....lol
For an 8 year old car it has surprisd me with how well it's aging.... Few things that are not perfect... Couple of car park dings... alloys not perfectly balanced..so had to take it straight to the tyre boys...and some marks on the leather I didn't notice during the viewing...
But for the winter hack purposes (with the winter tyres) it's looks like it will be fine... But just to make sure it's booked in to a local audi specialist this week for a health check... Not that I didn't trust the dealer, he seemed very straight and fair,,, but his "prepared for sale" amd my "yes that's good" are were always going to be on a different level...
I have been known to clash with Main Dealers on the prep on my new cars.. So this dealer wouldn't have stood a chance if I applied the same standard....lol..
That said four hours into my ownership he is still getting a thumbs up.....lol
Raggie said:
...some marks on the leather...
Gliptone liquid leather Scuffmaster kits work (almost) miracles and are cheap. Very easy to apply and durable too.Searider said:
A good 4WD system doesn't magically create grip but makes the best of what you have.
Eloquently put - what I was trying to say (badly).blueg33 said:
Dr G said:
Talent, experience and quattro with regard to everything except traction will only offer slight improvements on snow.
If you want more stopping and more turning you need to add more friction.
Thats what I thought, but an automotive engineer (see above) says I am wrong.If you want more stopping and more turning you need to add more friction.
All of the research I can find and all of the maths relates to the friction coefficient of the tyre and the surface, they all make it clear that awd does not and cannot create friction.
The Quattro did *slow down* better in the snow under engine braking.
But hit the brake pedal, and it was just like the FWD and locked up the wheels / ABS kicked in etc.
I too got bitten by the fact that you can accelerate quicker but not stop as quickly, but fortunately without any consequence (I overshot a 'T' junction, but fortunately there was no traffic to hit - or hit me) - it was a lesson learned.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



