Esprit V8 vs Ferrari 348 – running costs
Discussion
All
I’m in the market for a used sports car for around the 25-30K mark in the New Year. I’ve pretty much made up my mind on an Esprit V8 GT but the only car that keeps nagging at the back of my head in the same price bracket is a 348 (I’ve already ruled out a 993, Tuscan or Cerbra before anyone suggests them). The main thing that puts me off the 348 as opposed to the Esprit is the servicing costs.
But are Ferraris really as expensive to run as everyone makes out? Obviously I’m not expecting to run it for peanuts but also I don’t have the skills to do any of the work myself. Working on the assumption that the purchase price, petrol, tax and insurance are going to be about the same for both cars the only difference I see is servicing.
For the Lotus I’m budgeting on two main dealer services a year at 500-700 GBP a go (assuming nothing major breaks) plus about a1K reserve for tyres, pads and unexpected bills giving a annual servicing budget of about 2.5K GBP. Can I run a 348 on that kind of money (or not a lot more than that)? Some people have suggested I’ll need to put double that aside to run a Ferrari for a year.
One of the key things is, for my budget, I’m looking at a 97-99 Lotus whereas I’m looking at a 90-92 Ferrari so there is quite an age difference. However I’ve seen 348’s with recent cam belt services done for around my budget and from what I can see that is the only major scheduled expense.
Any comments/advice welcome.
Thanks
Gary
I’m in the market for a used sports car for around the 25-30K mark in the New Year. I’ve pretty much made up my mind on an Esprit V8 GT but the only car that keeps nagging at the back of my head in the same price bracket is a 348 (I’ve already ruled out a 993, Tuscan or Cerbra before anyone suggests them). The main thing that puts me off the 348 as opposed to the Esprit is the servicing costs.
But are Ferraris really as expensive to run as everyone makes out? Obviously I’m not expecting to run it for peanuts but also I don’t have the skills to do any of the work myself. Working on the assumption that the purchase price, petrol, tax and insurance are going to be about the same for both cars the only difference I see is servicing.
For the Lotus I’m budgeting on two main dealer services a year at 500-700 GBP a go (assuming nothing major breaks) plus about a1K reserve for tyres, pads and unexpected bills giving a annual servicing budget of about 2.5K GBP. Can I run a 348 on that kind of money (or not a lot more than that)? Some people have suggested I’ll need to put double that aside to run a Ferrari for a year.
One of the key things is, for my budget, I’m looking at a 97-99 Lotus whereas I’m looking at a 90-92 Ferrari so there is quite an age difference. However I’ve seen 348’s with recent cam belt services done for around my budget and from what I can see that is the only major scheduled expense.
Any comments/advice welcome.
Thanks
Gary
HI,
I have a 348 spider for the last 3 years. No problems at all. My mums partner has a lotuse Esprit V8 for the same period - last 3 years.
He has had more problems with the lotus due to the gearbox and clutch.
Overall servcing on the Lotus ahs ended up being more then on my Ferrari.
When you buy a 348 best to go for the latest model of the 348's either - GTS, GTB or Spider. The spider is the best them all most upto date was being produced along side the 355.
The lotus is a great car and the engines are bullet proof like the ferrari 348, but its got that gearbox issue.
Since the esprit has been taken out production I will say prices will stabliss and maybe go up. Its a real classic supercar.
The build quality is the same as the Ferrari.
The Esprit is a very quick car with 0-60 in 4.2 secs and 0-100 in 10.5 secs.
Quicker then the 348's but mine has been chipped and decatted with a out put of 365 BHP, stays with 355.
The looks of both cars are awesome...
The noise of the 348 with a Tubi and decatted is out of this world compared to the lotus.
The Esprit has more mowdown grunt but the Ferrari has a better at high revs, it sings...
I have a 348 spider for the last 3 years. No problems at all. My mums partner has a lotuse Esprit V8 for the same period - last 3 years.
He has had more problems with the lotus due to the gearbox and clutch.
Overall servcing on the Lotus ahs ended up being more then on my Ferrari.
When you buy a 348 best to go for the latest model of the 348's either - GTS, GTB or Spider. The spider is the best them all most upto date was being produced along side the 355.
The lotus is a great car and the engines are bullet proof like the ferrari 348, but its got that gearbox issue.
Since the esprit has been taken out production I will say prices will stabliss and maybe go up. Its a real classic supercar.
The build quality is the same as the Ferrari.
The Esprit is a very quick car with 0-60 in 4.2 secs and 0-100 in 10.5 secs.
Quicker then the 348's but mine has been chipped and decatted with a out put of 365 BHP, stays with 355.
The looks of both cars are awesome...
The noise of the 348 with a Tubi and decatted is out of this world compared to the lotus.
The Esprit has more mowdown grunt but the Ferrari has a better at high revs, it sings...
Thought of a DB7 ? not exactly my cup of tea certainly worth a look. I think the 348 is a cracking motor but having never owned one obviously could not say. I knew someone that had an Esprit 2.0 turbo and could not say enough good things about it. My experience is go drive them if you can, then decide.
>> Edited by Toolman on Thursday 4th November 13:29
>> Edited by Toolman on Thursday 4th November 13:29
My brother own a 1998 GT3 Esprit, used pretty much as his every day car/ Clocked up about 10K miles in a year, but it was for ever back at the dealers getting something sorted...the whole time my TVR Chimp was driving me up and down the motorways quite happily
I dread to think how much it cost him.
A friend of mine also owns a 1994 348 (not sure exactly what model) and get it serviced at an Independant Ferrari specialist (advertised on PH) for about £600 a go. He has clocked up I believe 40K in 2 years and has not spent a penny on it other than servicing, belts and tyres.
My money would go on the 348!
I dread to think how much it cost him.
A friend of mine also owns a 1994 348 (not sure exactly what model) and get it serviced at an Independant Ferrari specialist (advertised on PH) for about £600 a go. He has clocked up I believe 40K in 2 years and has not spent a penny on it other than servicing, belts and tyres.
My money would go on the 348!
Its like all cars if you use a main dealer you are going to pay over the odds. As stated above use a reputable independant dealer and the costs become more realistic???
Also a recent survey has proved that independants do a better job than main dealers with many main dealers doing work not needed and missing things they should have done.
Go with a 348 and use a good indi?
Later
Mike
Also a recent survey has proved that independants do a better job than main dealers with many main dealers doing work not needed and missing things they should have done.
Go with a 348 and use a good indi?
Later
Mike
allanlambo said:
Ive had both a 348 and a Lotus TT. Lotus is a great car, far better than the Ferrari in everyway. Its also been completely reliable. I prefer the Lotus to my 355 also.
Passed a exotic car hire place today. Is it worth hiring one on Honolulu? Bloody rained since I got here, what's going on?
>> Edited by maranellouk on Sunday 7th November 07:53
I would go with the 348 without a doubt. Never driven an Esprit but heard nothing but problems with them, although if you are after the quickest, the lotus wins hands down, if you are after the wow factor get the Ferrari. The budget you are looking at will only get you a good left hooker, if you want a good r/h, you are looking anything from £32-37k. And try a few before you buy otherwise you could land yourself with a big cash headache.
Reliabilty wise, touch wood, never had a problem with mine. Allow £2k per year running costs.
Hope its some help
Reliabilty wise, touch wood, never had a problem with mine. Allow £2k per year running costs.
Hope its some help
If you go for the Esprit V8 go for one thats had the engine rebuilt due to the liners, having this done IS A GOOD THING, once rebuilt problem does not reoccur and is the biggest maintenace issue on these cars (Rebuild is circa £6k).
Other maintence cost are obviously not cheap, but given its a junior league supercar are not silly
Other maintence cost are obviously not cheap, but given its a junior league supercar are not silly
Posting in the ferrari section will probably not give you a balanced response i think..
Buy a good example of either and you'd be fine, a bad one will make you cry and hurt your wallet - thats true whether its lotus or ferrari.
BTW I think you're budgetting a little light for regular maintenance, which ever car you go for.
If you want to know anything about running an esprit v8 i can probably help.
Rob
Buy a good example of either and you'd be fine, a bad one will make you cry and hurt your wallet - thats true whether its lotus or ferrari.
BTW I think you're budgetting a little light for regular maintenance, which ever car you go for.
If you want to know anything about running an esprit v8 i can probably help.
Rob
maranellouk said:
allanlambo said:
Ive had both a 348 and a Lotus TT. Lotus is a great car, far better than the Ferrari in everyway. Its also been completely reliable. I prefer the Lotus to my 355 also.
Passed a exotic car hire place today. Is it worth hiring one on Honolulu? Bloody rained since I got here, what's going on?
>> Edited by maranellouk on Sunday 7th November 07:53
Recently visited Honolulu and fancied doing the whole Magnum PI thing. Trouble is the H1 is like the M25 on a Friday, the one excellent driver road that there is (Round Diamond Head out toward Haunama Bay) is full of hire cars and buses that continually stop/start at the car parking beauty spots... Suppose you could do it at night, mind you if its wet and you get it wrong then its rocks or rocks + the Pacific! The main strip through Waikiki is always good for the Saturday pose though. I settled for a Mustang cab, possibly the worst piece of pig iron I've ever driven but kind of looks the part!
Cheers!
I drove by this morning and I saw (albeit breifly) a Maserati Spyder, some corvettes, hummers etc.
Apparently, there is a Lambo for hire somewhere so I am going to look around for that but the Maser would be rather nice for the week. However, if you are going to showboat..........Lamborghini all the way.
MARA
I drove by this morning and I saw (albeit breifly) a Maserati Spyder, some corvettes, hummers etc.
Apparently, there is a Lambo for hire somewhere so I am going to look around for that but the Maser would be rather nice for the week. However, if you are going to showboat..........Lamborghini all the way.
MARA
I have a V8 Esprit and drives it 3 to 4 days a week = close to a daily drive car. Liners were done by the previous owner and maintenance cost is no more than my other main drive category is a Volvo XCV70. The Esprit V8 is reliable and don't have any issues with it. I did however replaced the clutch slave cylinder which was a wear and tear item and gearbox is fine.
The esprit could well cost more to run than the 348 i would have thought.
Also bear in mind that there is a large contingent of people (including lotus) who maintain that the v8 inherent engine and liner problems is a myth and that its more to do with a poor cooling system. Answer = upgrade it inc. better radiators.
Also bear in mind that there is a large contingent of people (including lotus) who maintain that the v8 inherent engine and liner problems is a myth and that its more to do with a poor cooling system. Answer = upgrade it inc. better radiators.
Gassing Station | Supercar General | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




