The great pretenders...
The great pretenders...
Author
Discussion

davecymru

Original Poster:

36 posts

188 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
Now that there is a dedicated Lamborghini section on-ere, I thought I'd start a hopefully interesting topic and ask what actual Lamborghini owners think of the Kit Car / Replica Lambos?

I admit up front that this is a question that i have a vested interest in, as i am a life long Lamborghini Enthusiast, Countach anorak and for the last year I've also been the owner of a MasterCo Countach Kit Car. And while I know that even though i shouldn't care what others think, I am quite self conscious taking my car out as it does have the possibility of starting quite heated conversations.

Over the past few years I've had lots of conversations about replicas / kit-cars / copies / knock-off's / tributes (whatever you want to call them) and from what I've seen this does seem to be a very Marmite topic, but I've never really discussed it with Lamborghini owners so I thought I'd ask on here as I am genuinely interested in what people think, even if I may disagree with some of it!


I'll kick things off with my thoughts that as a life long Lamborghini enthusiast I will admit that these kit cars do trouble me a bit, especially the replicas of the newer models as that somehow doesn't seem to be 'right'. But then again old-man Lamborghini was very complimentary about the Countach replicas he'd seen and how much thought and effort were put into them, which is one of the main reasons why i don't mind owning mine! But then again I'm very much a realist and I'm as proud of the fact that my kit car is a kit that i work on/modify myself as I am that it looks like a Countach and also it's on a Q plate so i don't pretend it's a real one!

I'd be interested to hear your thoughts....


Please note: I know what Forums can be like so I'll say up-front that I'm not looking for any form of personal reassurance, acceptance, or a pat on the arm and a comforting 'there, there' and i hope that I've managed to get across that I am actually interested in discussing this!


Dolittle

1,256 posts

189 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
It's like wearing a fake Rolex, I wouldn't. For me it would be the fact that I knew I was driving a fake car, most Lambo owners could spot a fake a mile off, I'd feel a bit silly. I would rather spend the money on a cheaper alternative. I dont see the point, unless the point is to show off.

Diablo SV

291 posts

174 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
I think when it comes to the Countach the appeal is in the styling of the car rather than what's under the bonnet , sure it,s great to own a real one but when funds just don't stretch to 100k plus I don,t see any problem owning a replica countach if it,s a good representation . Costs are down , you can do things to it yourself quite cheaply and you still get the benefit of an iconic image sitting on your drive . Yep , I,m all for it , just don,t take on the real thing on the motorway . As for Murci / Diablo replicas it,s different somehow , they are not so stylish as the countach so I don,t really see the point in replicating one .

carspath

909 posts

208 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
just enjoy whatever you've got , and just ignore any snide comments that might come the car's way

the countach shape is truly wonderful , and a good replica will allow you to enjoy that

the countach is also fascinating for its engine,its engine-gearbox layout, its handbuilt chassis, its hand beaten aluminium body, the people involved in its development--stanzani, dallara, Wallace, Alfieri, gandini , and its history

a replica is more affordable, and can give a lot of pleasure

Adz The Rat

19,160 posts

240 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
The only people you are ever going to impress is people who dont have a clue, so whats the point?

You know you are driving a fake, so why not put the money into a fun car?

lambo_xx

2,199 posts

228 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
Never really understood it to be honest. As someone said earlier it's like wearing a fake Rolex.

I remember a while ago a friend of mine was telling me about her "friend who had a Ferrari" and an unfortunate incident where the front bonnet (boot) wasn't shut properly and flew up, smashing the windscreen! Now she for some reason had pictures of the car and whilst looking at them it was obvious to me that it was a replica...most obviously being that 355s bonnets are hinged at the front of the panel and open away from the windscreen therefore making it impossible to smash it.

So I just said "oh dear that’s a shame" and quickly changed the subject!

I mean I really don't care what other people do it's none of my business however I wouldn't do it. As I said at some point someone will know it isn't real and then it'll be quite awkward...
The only replicas I like or would have is something like a GT40 replica, where the cars are so rare that it would be almost expected that the car was a replica. If that makes sense.

Diablo SV

291 posts

174 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
lambo_xx said:
Never really understood it to be honest. As someone said earlier it's like wearing a fake Rolex.

I remember a while ago a friend of mine was telling me about her "friend who had a Ferrari" and an unfortunate incident where the front bonnet (boot) wasn't shut properly and flew up, smashing the windscreen! Now she for some reason had pictures of the car and whilst looking at them it was obvious to me that it was a replica...most obviously being that 355s bonnets are hinged at the front of the panel and open away from the windscreen therefore making it impossible to smash it.

So I just said "oh dear that’s a shame" and quickly changed the subject!

I mean I really don't care what other people do it's none of my business however I wouldn't do it. As I said at some point someone will know it isn't real and then it'll be quite awkward...
The only replicas I like or would have is something like a GT40 replica, where the cars are so rare that it would be almost expected that the car was a replica. If that makes sense.
Ermmmm , No ! Makes no sense to me , you,d have a replica GT 40 but state a replica Countach is like wearing a fake Rolex and you wouldn't,t do it . What,s the difference ? How about AC Cobra ? D type jag ? I just don,t understand the discrimination between the car types . I think many see a Countach replica as a sin of some sort for whatever reason but perfectly acceptable for other cars , just don,t get it

RedBull

1,142 posts

253 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
When I was trying to pluck up the courage to take the plunge and buy a Countach, I did briefly consider going the replica route but not for long. For me, the Countach was a boyhood dream car and to truly realise my dream it had to be the real thing. Even my wife told me not to get a replica as I'd never be happy with it.
I'll be honest, as the OP asked, I would be embarrassed driving a replica, because I would feel like a fake myself, pretending to have something that I haven't. I get the argument about being more accessible, cheaper to buy, run, maintain etc., but it just wouldn't be right for me. As someone already said, like wearing a fake Rolex.
That said, I have no problem with those who do choose to own a replica, it's their choice and doesn't affect me. The most common question I get is "is it a replica?" and to be able to answer "no" is a wonderful feeling, and the sudden increase in interest says a lot to me.
I definately draw the line at replicas that go as far as putting Lamborghini badges on though, that is a step too far in my book.

Edit: just looked at your profile OP, probably not very far from me, so just in case you're a very large and unhinged sort of chap, I think replicas are fantastic smile

Edited by RedBull on Wednesday 23 October 19:41

catfood12

1,575 posts

173 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
Shocking. Read the views of real Lambo owners...

http://www.lambopower.com/forum/index.php?showtopi...

fatboy18

19,565 posts

242 months

Thursday 24th October 2013
quotequote all
Mind if I chip in as an ex Kit car owner smile

This is how I see it, nothing wrong in having a kit car that looks very similar to which ever mark you like, but don't introduce it or sell it as so.

I had a Dax Tojerio fitted out with a full blown TVR Tuscan challenge series race engine, it was bloody quick (when it ran right) rolleyes If you don't know what a Dax Tojerio is, its based on the Cobra design. It was not an AC Cobra.

It does annoy me when you look in the classifieds under AC to find it full of replicas, they should be in the Kit car section fair and square, its the Same with people who have Viper replicas, I do not approve of there adverts being in the same place.

So if you have a kit car, please call it by the cars make and model, thank you.

davecymru

Original Poster:

36 posts

188 months

Friday 25th October 2013
quotequote all
Some really interesting opinions so far and much more diverse than I'd expected, thanks all for the honesty!

Personally I've never been 100% in agreement with the Fake Rolex comparison as you don't build/maintain that yourself, but i do fully agree with it from the aspect of "don't pretend it's a real one".

Having spent years looking in to Countach's before i bought my Kit Car, i always used to be sure that if i did get a kit rather than a real one (the recent spike in prices has made the real option a non-starter ftm!) I didn't want one with a Q plate for the very reason that people would know it's a kit car. But what I've actually found from owning one is that I'm now completely of the opposite opinion and i think that people 'should' know it's a kit car and personally i like having the Q plate to show that! Especially if it's a bad replica like some of the ones on that Lambopower link, as enforcing Q plates on kit cars would make the distinction much clearer.

It's interesting to hear that some of you have been asked "is it a kit" and that is one aspect that has always unsettled me as you've spent a lot of money on your cars and kits do make the general public doubt the authenticity of the originals. Especially so with the Ferrari 355 market, which has been hit by the cheap MR2 rebody kits.
But then again on the flip side when i have been asked if mine is a kit (and i always say yes!), I've always found that people are still just as interested in talking about the fact that it is a kit and how it's built.


Note to RedBull: don't worry it takes a lot to offend me, and please feel free to beep and shake your fists angrily at me if you ever see me out-n-about in my MasterCo smile

sjn2004

4,051 posts

268 months

Sunday 27th October 2013
quotequote all
So what prevented you starting such a thread when it was the late and great FML forum?

davecymru

Original Poster:

36 posts

188 months

Sunday 27th October 2013
quotequote all
Nothing sinister, I just never used to really read that other forum much, in fact i never really came on pistonheads too much apart from the SW and kit-car areas and when I saw this area get created and I started reading some of the posts and it got me thinking smile