Is Google Trying to Stuff Your SME Business Too?
Is Google Trying to Stuff Your SME Business Too?
Author
Discussion

RegMolehusband

Original Poster:

4,117 posts

288 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
After several years of having great Google positions as a result of working hard at good content and SEO I find in the last 18 months or so that we have been steadily dropping down the organic ranking in favour of big name companies like Costco, Homebase etc. These companies might have a single page to sell online quite low quality products in comparison to our whole website having 300 pages dedicated to providing great products and added value services.

I am quite sure that business growth has been stunted as a result of Google moving the goalposts with their algorithm updates.

Is this Google trying to encourage thousands of SMEs to pay more for Adwords?

Yours frustratedly

"Reg"

RJD223

253 posts

226 months

Monday 21st October 2013
quotequote all
Same here. We used to be top of page 1 for our keywords and now, despite the SEO work being done, we're now going slowly up from page 50 odd and at the moment we're on page 12.

It's had a massive impact on our service related business...

gartioni

2 posts

264 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
I had the same issue. My site was flying high for a couple of years, up to February 2011 when Google introduced Panda.

We were furious because we'd only done what Google and all the 'white hat' optimizers recommended.
After taking a serious financial battering, we've crawled back slowly to a half-decent position for some of our product searches,
trying not to offend the mighty Google.

The only positive was that, although we might have taken a big hit, many of our competitors seem to have been wiped off the results
pages altogether, so they were obviously doing something devious and have subsequently been sent to hell by the Panda and Penguin.

I found a really good tool (link below) for checking the impact of Google's updates.
When I ran it, I was informed that my site was guilty of being 'thin and low-quality' (-100% and stay behind after school!).
It says it prefers "sites that continually publish lengthy, informative content from highly regarded authors".
That's very admirable of Google, but it just means that instead of putting merchandise on my site with the relevant information,
now I'm expected to write an essay about every product and pad it out.

What I find most irritating is that Google is essentially saying to us that we need to work through the pain, because we'll all benefit
from a much better web in the future. The reality is that the search results are dominated by 800lb gorilla sites like eBay and Amazon,
which I don't have a problem with when the results are relevant, but far too often they're not.

Keep your eye on Mount Sinai, Google will have more commandments for you soon.


The Google Penalty Checker Tool - http://fruition.net/google-penalty-checker-tool.

RegMolehusband

Original Poster:

4,117 posts

288 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Thank you Gartioni, I'm going to try that link later today.

Google has led us down one path during the last few years creating a multi billion dollar SEO industry (and huge cost to businesses) and getting us to do things in a certain way. Then they move the goalposts where that form of SEO is no longer valid AND by favouring big brands which now costs us lost sales as we disappear off the rankings.