Small Claim Help Please
Author
Discussion

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Would any of the PH solicitors / barristers be able to give me a bit of advice?

I have raised a small claims action in a court in England, for non-payment of fees. The 14-day period ran out yesterday. The defendants lodged an "Acknowledgement of Service" on Friday, but I haven't actually seen that yet. I have received a letter today from the defendant's solicitors asking for information.

I could do with a bit of advice on how (or if) to respond, if anybody can help. I would prefer to keep this private because you never know who is reading.


7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
This advice, like all, is worth the amount you've paid for it. An amount that reflects my lack of professional qualifications and the fact you may not claim on my professional indemnity insurance. Those big lawyers fees are worth something, after all.

AoS gives them 28 days to respond.

The defence may want to clarify the claim in order to defend (or acknowledge it). If your claim is unclear or if you haven't sent a letter before action laying out the claim, then it is hard for them to defend or accept. Depends on what their communication is.

In general your obligation is to be as helpful as possible to the other side to help them understand your claim and its strength to save the court time and costs. Being obviously awkward with the other side's legal team won't endear you to the district judge, although as a litigant in person you'll probably get away with murder.

Edited by 7db on Tuesday 22 October 15:33

7db

6,060 posts

261 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Also -- you won't see the AoS typically, the next thing you'll see is a notice that the claim is defended, a copy of that defence together with an allocation questionnaire and a mediation form.

PurpleMoonlight

22,362 posts

188 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Tell the solicitor what is owed any why it is owed.

Why wouldn't you ..


johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
How small is the claim?

Somnophore

1,364 posts

207 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Just provide them with info on the figure what it's fore and evidence that is owed. Then they can't day you were were being unhelpful

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
I have received a letter today from the defendant's solicitors asking for information.
Is it information they reasonably need? To defend the claim? If so provide it to them. Copy in the court.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Is it information they reasonably need? To defend the claim? If so provide it to them. Copy in the court.
This, and keep a record of what you send but there's no need to copy in the court as all that will happen is whatever you send will sit in a file. Whatever you send will no doubt form part of what you'll need to disclose when you get directions for a final hearing (if it's not settled before then, the court will need a copy by the date you're ordered to file evidence by, but not before (unless the court decides to haul the matter in for a directions hearing, which sometimes happens with small claims).

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 22nd October 2013
quotequote all
Guys

Thanks for the replies. This is new to me, and I was worried that correspondence out of the court system might be prejudicial - your advice is that it's more likely to help my case. I'll look out my evidence to answer their questions, and send it on tomorrow.

The amount is about £1600 by the way.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Wednesday 23rd October 2013
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Guys

Thanks for the replies. This is new to me, and I was worried that correspondence out of the court system might be prejudicial - your advice is that it's more likely to help my case. I'll look out my evidence to answer their questions, and send it on tomorrow.

The amount is about £1600 by the way.
Quite often claims don't contain enough detail for a proper defence (this is partly a problem caused by the limited detail Moneyclaim Online allows) and it's reasonable for you to provide additional information to clarify the nature of the claim.

How much detail you provide now is up to you, but you may find a defendant who is represented may well be advised by their solicitors to settle if it's plain from the detail that there's no chance of their client winning. Whether they do or not is up to them, sometimes people want their day in court (people like this often find such days are very expensive). It may also be that once you've sent the information you get a properly drafted defence.

One point to note with small claims is you only need to disclose documents / information that you intend to rely on (i.e. that which supports your case) unless ordered otherwise by the court, though if you've anything that doesn't support your case you'll need to take a commercial decision on how to progress the case if and when you receive a defence.

I attend (in a professional capacity) quite a lot of small claims trials (I've done 3 in the last week alone), feel free to PM if you need any help.




tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
Update:

Filed my claim, they filed a defence saying that they are not liable and dismissing the claim in total (my problem is that the person who appointed my company has since died - there was nothing on paper, although I do have evidence that a verbal contract existed).

Anyway, both sides have agreed to mediation, and an appointment has been set for a couple of weeks.

In the meantime, I have received a letter from the other side's solicitor, offering to settle at half of the claim value (that's about £800 for a £1.600 claim). It seems sensible to settle rather than stick out for every penny, but I am in a quandary - should I accept that first offer, or would I be seen as being awkward if I said "without prejudice to the whole of my claim, I agree to the principle of a lower settlement, but not that amount"?


northwest monkey

6,370 posts

220 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
I've got absolutely no legal qualifications whatsoever, but it seems odd to me they are saying they aren't liable for any bill but offering you £800 anyway.

Let me know their address, and I'll send them a bill they can pay half of as welllaugh

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
northwest monkey said:
I've got absolutely no legal qualifications whatsoever, but it seems odd to me they are saying they aren't liable for any bill but offering you £800 anyway.
Yes quite. That's what I thought - so I thought I might ask for a figure a bit closer to what I claimed for.

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Tuesday 26th November 2013
quotequote all
northwest monkey said:
I've got absolutely no legal qualifications whatsoever, but it seems odd to me they are saying they aren't liable for any bill but offering you £800 anyway.
Yes quite. That's what I thought - so I thought I might ask for a figure a bit closer to what I claimed for.

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
Yes quite. That's what I thought - so I thought I might ask for a figure a bit closer to what I claimed for.
It's not unusual to deny liability then to offer to settle for commercial reasons. For example that figure might be based on what they estimate it will cost them to defend the claim, which would be costs that they could not recover even if you lost the case.

In claims that aren't small claims there is a procedure (the part 36 procedure) whereby offers can be made which can affect the right to some legal costs if the winner recovers less than was offered by way of settlement.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
tvrgit said:
northwest monkey said:
I've got absolutely no legal qualifications whatsoever, but it seems odd to me they are saying they aren't liable for any bill but offering you £800 anyway.
Yes quite. That's what I thought - so I thought I might ask for a figure a bit closer to what I claimed for.
In similar situations I have replied in that way. Just be nice/reasonable and don't take the piss.
This is a situation where they can't be bothered to go to court because of a)what it will cost them and b)the amount of money is too small to them to bother.
A polite note thanking them for their offer, apologising that you feel it is a little too low given that you genuinely believe full entitlement in this situation but for ease you would probably accept Y will probably see all parties happy

tvrgit

Original Poster:

8,490 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th November 2013
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
A polite note thanking them for their offer, apologising that you feel it is a little too low given that you genuinely believe full entitlement in this situation but for ease you would probably accept Y will probably see all parties happy
I have thought about this over today, and propose to "meet halfway" to resolve the situation. Thanks for the advice.