The Relentless Pursuit of Progress In The Outside Lane - not
Discussion
This thread is inspired by something that happened to my dad the other day, and is a situation that I'm sure many of us have found ourselves in at one point or another, give or take the nature of the end result.
On a 50mph A-road, in near torrential rain, my aforementioned pops is driving his delightful 1970s saloon car up at the limit in the left hand lane. Ahead, a van pulls straight out from a junction, perhaps not thinking, or perhaps assuming that my dad can just move over. However, in the outside lane and a safe distance back is a man driving a Vauxhall Zafira over the limit. My father is faced with two options - slam on the brakes (no ABS, very wet conditions) and hope for the best, or deftly indicate and move out to avoid collision or dangerous braking, knowing that the driver of said Zafira has time to react and slow down to allow things to proceed safely. Instead of risking some squirrely braking in the wet my father chooses to move out to overtake the van and move in again ASAP.
Now, this is what happened: The man in the Zafira honks and honks and honks and shouts and speeds up, riding my dad's coattails until he pulls in a safe distance ahead of the van, at which time the little Zafira is still honking. Mr. Zafira then decides to pull in sharply ahead a of my dad and brake sharply in front of him, causing danger and sudden braking for both my dad and the driver of the van behind.
Now, this made me a bit angry when I first heard about it but it's a situation I have been forced into before. Even when anticipating junctions, there is sometimes no allowance given to those who might want to move over to let traffic join. I feel that that "fast lane" progress maker should have some responsibility to anticipate junctions, hazards and afford other road users some understanding in these situations and certainly not use their vehicle to intimidate someone. On Pistonheads I have read more grievances about people 'being in the way' than I've read about tailgaters so I wondered if anyone had an alternate take on this situation so I could vehemently disagree with you and so that people could sort of skim through this post and then reply with only vaguely relevant anecdotes about bad drivers and nothing good comes of all this whatsoever.
:/
TL;DR - Britain.
On a 50mph A-road, in near torrential rain, my aforementioned pops is driving his delightful 1970s saloon car up at the limit in the left hand lane. Ahead, a van pulls straight out from a junction, perhaps not thinking, or perhaps assuming that my dad can just move over. However, in the outside lane and a safe distance back is a man driving a Vauxhall Zafira over the limit. My father is faced with two options - slam on the brakes (no ABS, very wet conditions) and hope for the best, or deftly indicate and move out to avoid collision or dangerous braking, knowing that the driver of said Zafira has time to react and slow down to allow things to proceed safely. Instead of risking some squirrely braking in the wet my father chooses to move out to overtake the van and move in again ASAP.
Now, this is what happened: The man in the Zafira honks and honks and honks and shouts and speeds up, riding my dad's coattails until he pulls in a safe distance ahead of the van, at which time the little Zafira is still honking. Mr. Zafira then decides to pull in sharply ahead a of my dad and brake sharply in front of him, causing danger and sudden braking for both my dad and the driver of the van behind.
Now, this made me a bit angry when I first heard about it but it's a situation I have been forced into before. Even when anticipating junctions, there is sometimes no allowance given to those who might want to move over to let traffic join. I feel that that "fast lane" progress maker should have some responsibility to anticipate junctions, hazards and afford other road users some understanding in these situations and certainly not use their vehicle to intimidate someone. On Pistonheads I have read more grievances about people 'being in the way' than I've read about tailgaters so I wondered if anyone had an alternate take on this situation so I could vehemently disagree with you and so that people could sort of skim through this post and then reply with only vaguely relevant anecdotes about bad drivers and nothing good comes of all this whatsoever.
:/
TL;DR - Britain.
What if the zafira had hit your dad? Wouldn't that have been worse? Hope he's okay but the cause of the problem got away without a telling off. All your dad did was move the problem onto someone else. I don't blame anyone other then the van driver, but is your dads car so crap that braking at 50mph would spin it off? If so, time to change it maybe?
HertsBiker said:
What if the zafira had hit your dad? Wouldn't that have been worse? Hope he's okay but the cause of the problem got away without a telling off. All your dad did was move the problem onto someone else. I don't blame anyone other then the van driver, but is your dads car so crap that braking at 50mph would spin it off? If so, time to change it maybe?
No, certainly not crap, but given the situation would have involved emergency braking on his part, the Zafira was doing way over the limit and had plenty of time to lift off instead of speeding up to prove a point, I reckon my dad was in the right. The Zafira had penty of time to react and lift off, and has a responsibility to read the road and anticipate - so I don't agree that he "moved the problem." in that sense.On the one hand, a driver should not change lanes in a way which forces someone else to change speed or direction. On the other hand, if a driver is travelling well in excess of the posted limit, he is reserving for himself a much greater length of road ahead than he is really entitled to.
A few wrongs been done here.
The van should only have pulled out if when doing so, it wouldn't interfere with your dad's direction and speed. So wrong on the van driver for that.
Wrong for the car in the outside lane breaking the speed limit as well.
Sounds like your dad was between a rock and a hard place.
Pull out and annoy the pleb in the outside lane (i say pleb based on how he behaved after this), or stay in his lane and risk crashing into the van or spinning out.
Your dad could have slowed down slightly in anticipation for the van's possibility of pulling out and given the road conditions, but the point being if others are driving properly, he shouldn't need to
The van should only have pulled out if when doing so, it wouldn't interfere with your dad's direction and speed. So wrong on the van driver for that.
Wrong for the car in the outside lane breaking the speed limit as well.
Sounds like your dad was between a rock and a hard place.
Pull out and annoy the pleb in the outside lane (i say pleb based on how he behaved after this), or stay in his lane and risk crashing into the van or spinning out.
Your dad could have slowed down slightly in anticipation for the van's possibility of pulling out and given the road conditions, but the point being if others are driving properly, he shouldn't need to
Taking it at face value your dad made the correct choice, if he had braked and spun or braked and hit the van then there would have been a good chance the Zafira would have ended up involved anyway. This way he just pissed off an inattentive/poor driver rather had an accident.
One of the situations where having power in reserve helps.
One of the situations where having power in reserve helps.
If I'm breaking the speed limit then I accept sometimes having to slow down. As long as someone does not present themselves straight in front of my bumper I do not mind.
In this instance the Zafira could have seen the scene unfolding and reasonably anticipated what was going to happen. If avoiding action had to be taken, the driver should not have been surprised.
Zafira driver = twonk.
In this instance the Zafira could have seen the scene unfolding and reasonably anticipated what was going to happen. If avoiding action had to be taken, the driver should not have been surprised.
Zafira driver = twonk.
Johnnytheboy said:
An angry Zafira driver? Whatever next?
This I'm afraid. The man will be full of shame for having to drive such a mundane vehicle while others can enjoy their car. He hopes someday when he grows up and gets big, he can have a car like your dads. Until then he will be mister angry, and hate all other car users because of his shame.TheD said:
Johnnytheboy said:
An angry Zafira driver? Whatever next?
This I'm afraid. The man will be full of shame for having to drive such a mundane vehicle while others can enjoy their car. He hopes someday when he grows up and gets big, he can have a car like your dads. Until then he will be mister angry, and hate all other car users because of his shame.The Zafira driver condemned himself when purchasing the car so was clearly in the wrong no matter what.
I was offered one as a courtesey car once. I said to the dealer "what f
king courteous about giving me that".
Being offered a free Zafira is a little like enjoying a fine meal and the waiter then bringing you a steaming turd and saying "complements of the house".
There are some unfortunate souls who got their women in the family way who have no choice but to drive a car like a Zafira.
There ought to be a charity to help out those poor b
ds you can just picture the adverts for it.
There is a worst car though. The Meriva. My recurring nightmare is being given a Meriva as a company car and I had no choice but to accept. This is not unfounded. I had to drive a Meriva once from Stansted to Manchester. The choice was tha or stay overnight ar Stansted. What a choice that was.
The Zafira driver was without a doubt wrong.
I was offered one as a courtesey car once. I said to the dealer "what f
king courteous about giving me that". Being offered a free Zafira is a little like enjoying a fine meal and the waiter then bringing you a steaming turd and saying "complements of the house".
There are some unfortunate souls who got their women in the family way who have no choice but to drive a car like a Zafira.
There ought to be a charity to help out those poor b
ds you can just picture the adverts for it. There is a worst car though. The Meriva. My recurring nightmare is being given a Meriva as a company car and I had no choice but to accept. This is not unfounded. I had to drive a Meriva once from Stansted to Manchester. The choice was tha or stay overnight ar Stansted. What a choice that was.
The Zafira driver was without a doubt wrong.
Pistom said:
The Zafira driver condemned himself when purchasing the car so was clearly in the wrong no matter what.
I was offered one as a courtesey car once. I said to the dealer "what f
king courteous about giving me that".
Being offered a free Zafira is a little like enjoying a fine meal and the waiter then bringing you a steaming turd and saying "complements of the house".
There are some unfortunate souls who got their women in the family way who have no choice but to drive a car like a Zafira.
There ought to be a charity to help out those poor b
ds you can just picture the adverts for it.
There is a worst car though. The Meriva. My recurring nightmare is being given a Meriva as a company car and I had no choice but to accept. This is not unfounded. I had to drive a Meriva once from Stansted to Manchester. The choice was tha or stay overnight ar Stansted. What a choice that was.
The Zafira driver was without a doubt wrong.
This reminds me of a car hire I'd booked in France when we'd gone away with the outlaws. I'd booked via an agent a 7 seater such as an Espace. There was some confusion when we arrived, and the bloke said Zafira, Ois... No I reply. My french is limited. But No went a long way and was repeated often. Ended up with a Chrysler Voyager, which was crap to drive, but at least fitted us + luggage. It was a close escape, given that it was at Nice, and we'd coincidently booked at the same time as Monaco GP and Cannes Film Festival.I was offered one as a courtesey car once. I said to the dealer "what f
king courteous about giving me that". Being offered a free Zafira is a little like enjoying a fine meal and the waiter then bringing you a steaming turd and saying "complements of the house".
There are some unfortunate souls who got their women in the family way who have no choice but to drive a car like a Zafira.
There ought to be a charity to help out those poor b
ds you can just picture the adverts for it. There is a worst car though. The Meriva. My recurring nightmare is being given a Meriva as a company car and I had no choice but to accept. This is not unfounded. I had to drive a Meriva once from Stansted to Manchester. The choice was tha or stay overnight ar Stansted. What a choice that was.
The Zafira driver was without a doubt wrong.
Perhaps here, just a suggestion that your dad wrongly anticipated the distance or the closing speed of the zafira.
If there was indeed enough room for the zafira to just lift off as you say, then either your dad did the whole 'I am pulling out and not going to accelerate to match moving traffic' type scenario or the zafira driver had a couple of screws loose(well that is evident by the honking and braking)
I can't imagine many drivers...even the mental ones causing such a scene if the situation was indeed a 'lift off' not to say it never happened, just that it is unlikely.
If there was indeed enough room for the zafira to just lift off as you say, then either your dad did the whole 'I am pulling out and not going to accelerate to match moving traffic' type scenario or the zafira driver had a couple of screws loose(well that is evident by the honking and braking)
I can't imagine many drivers...even the mental ones causing such a scene if the situation was indeed a 'lift off' not to say it never happened, just that it is unlikely.
Edited by barker22 on Thursday 24th October 21:27
I dont think the people carriers speed means the driver is at fault, the horn is afterall meant to let other road users aware that you are there. Taking your fathers logically safe approach might be lost in translation after having caused somebody to brake hard.
I would imagine the van driver may be at fault here above anybody else.
Evasive action is surely only safe if it doesnt cause other road users to accomodate sudden changes in road conditions.
I would imagine the van driver may be at fault here above anybody else.
Evasive action is surely only safe if it doesnt cause other road users to accomodate sudden changes in road conditions.
Zafira driver at fault. If I choose to drive faster than the limit on DCs and motorways, I don't hassle people for driving to the limit - they could be on 9 points or simply want to keep a clean licence/legal, etc, etc.
If I was the Zafira driver, I would have seen the situation develop and eased up, or sped up and passed before the situation developed in better conditions. Either approach has little effect on the overall journey time
If I was the Zafira driver, I would have seen the situation develop and eased up, or sped up and passed before the situation developed in better conditions. Either approach has little effect on the overall journey time

Van driver and OP's dad at fault IMHO...
Van driver should have used his mirrors and adjusted speed to merge safely... OP's dad should have anticipated joining traffic and once again adjusted speed accordingly.
Moving out in to the path of faster overtaking traffic forcing them to brake is a no no... regardless of whether they were exceeding the speed limit or not.
However Zafira driver is a fool for re-acting and brake testing OP's dad...
Too many drivers on the roads these days think they are "driving kings" and when things go wrong cannot accept they made a mistake or didn't anticipate a potential hazard and therefore want to blame someone else...
Van driver should have used his mirrors and adjusted speed to merge safely... OP's dad should have anticipated joining traffic and once again adjusted speed accordingly.
Moving out in to the path of faster overtaking traffic forcing them to brake is a no no... regardless of whether they were exceeding the speed limit or not.
However Zafira driver is a fool for re-acting and brake testing OP's dad...
Too many drivers on the roads these days think they are "driving kings" and when things go wrong cannot accept they made a mistake or didn't anticipate a potential hazard and therefore want to blame someone else...
The cause of the first incident, the conflict between dad and the van was the van driver. The van driver should have adjusted his speed to join the traffic without interfering with its progress.
The cause of the second incident was the Zafira driver as if he had been driving lawfully your dad would have had no problem at all as he could not have been caught by the Zafira driver at all and dad could complete the manoeuvre with no danger to anyone.
Herein is the peril and contradiction of the oft-used phrase on here of "making progress". The Zafira driver has no right to claim the high ground in this incident because he knows that he is in the wrong. In addition to that, if you choose to "make progress" other wise known as "driving like a cu*t" you should be prepared to look far enough ahead to accommodate those who, like dad, have chosen to make their progress within the law.
I don't agree that the Zafira necessarily indicates the skill or attitude of the driver in the way suggested. It is my experience that as the cost and performance of the car increases so the attitude that the road belongs to the driver and everyone should clear out of the way gets stronger. The posts above strongly support this hypothesis.
Thankfully dad is OK, unfortunately our man in the Zafira and his attitude is still at large and is common on our roads.

The cause of the second incident was the Zafira driver as if he had been driving lawfully your dad would have had no problem at all as he could not have been caught by the Zafira driver at all and dad could complete the manoeuvre with no danger to anyone.
Herein is the peril and contradiction of the oft-used phrase on here of "making progress". The Zafira driver has no right to claim the high ground in this incident because he knows that he is in the wrong. In addition to that, if you choose to "make progress" other wise known as "driving like a cu*t" you should be prepared to look far enough ahead to accommodate those who, like dad, have chosen to make their progress within the law.
I don't agree that the Zafira necessarily indicates the skill or attitude of the driver in the way suggested. It is my experience that as the cost and performance of the car increases so the attitude that the road belongs to the driver and everyone should clear out of the way gets stronger. The posts above strongly support this hypothesis.
Thankfully dad is OK, unfortunately our man in the Zafira and his attitude is still at large and is common on our roads.
Seesure said:
Van driver and OP's dad at fault IMHO...
Van driver should have used his mirrors and adjusted speed to merge safely... OP's dad should have anticipated joining traffic and once again adjusted speed accordingly.
Moving out in to the path of faster overtaking traffic forcing them to brake is a no no... regardless of whether they were exceeding the speed limit or not.
However Zafira driver is a fool for re-acting and brake testing OP's dad...
Too many drivers on the roads these days think they are "driving kings" and when things go wrong cannot accept they made a mistake or didn't anticipate a potential hazard and therefore want to blame someone else...
See what I mean. Van driver should have used his mirrors and adjusted speed to merge safely... OP's dad should have anticipated joining traffic and once again adjusted speed accordingly.
Moving out in to the path of faster overtaking traffic forcing them to brake is a no no... regardless of whether they were exceeding the speed limit or not.
However Zafira driver is a fool for re-acting and brake testing OP's dad...
Too many drivers on the roads these days think they are "driving kings" and when things go wrong cannot accept they made a mistake or didn't anticipate a potential hazard and therefore want to blame someone else...

Edited by pitmansboots on Friday 25th October 08:55
I'm going to use the 'if' word here not out of any disrespect to OP or his Dad but experience has shown that after time people frequently rationalise things in their favour post event. However will take everything as written to be a true reflection.
If the Zafira could have simply lifted off and slowed on compression braking then OP's Dad did very little wrong imo.
But let's be generous to Zafira and say the blame is split according to the ubiquitous 80/20 rule.
If he then reacted to that by actually speeding up to make the situation worse and then braking at last moment to tailgate and prolonged horn abuse, then he takes the 20% of the blame notionally still attached to Dad and takes 80% of that.
If he then finally cuts in and brake tests then he transfers all the rest onto himself.
Conclusion Zafira = knob grade one.
QED.
If the Zafira could have simply lifted off and slowed on compression braking then OP's Dad did very little wrong imo.
But let's be generous to Zafira and say the blame is split according to the ubiquitous 80/20 rule.
If he then reacted to that by actually speeding up to make the situation worse and then braking at last moment to tailgate and prolonged horn abuse, then he takes the 20% of the blame notionally still attached to Dad and takes 80% of that.
If he then finally cuts in and brake tests then he transfers all the rest onto himself.
Conclusion Zafira = knob grade one.
QED.
Interesting. Because the PHer (or his Dad) is the one dawdling and the faster driver is in a Zafira then the faster driver is to blame and by far the majority agree with pitsmansboots.
So what if the PHer were in the outside lane in his MX5 and the inside lane was a 90 year old in a Honda Jazz who did exactly the same thing? Pretty well guarantee that everyone would be demanding the jazz driver have his licence revoked for not understanding the an MX5 is such a precise bit of kit
So what if the PHer were in the outside lane in his MX5 and the inside lane was a 90 year old in a Honda Jazz who did exactly the same thing? Pretty well guarantee that everyone would be demanding the jazz driver have his licence revoked for not understanding the an MX5 is such a precise bit of kit

Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



