S8 or A8 4.2TDi?
Author
Discussion

MrTickle

Original Poster:

1,825 posts

270 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Looking at 2008/9 age S8 with a budget of around 18K - however I have noticed that the 4.2TDi also falls into that sort of money too.....

MPG to one side, which is the better buy? Are there any issues with the 4.2TDI cars? I would have expected them to have been more expensive due to their economy.


Tom8

6,713 posts

185 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Get an S8. Awesome experience, sound and driving pleasure. A8 is a nice car but diesel takes away the love and it just becomes an implement.

S8honglonglong

21 posts

163 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
I have never driven a 4.2TDi, but if fuel consumption (I average around 17mpg... you can get 25mpg if you average 50mph on motor way...) is not a problem for you, I highly recommend S8.

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

237 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Another vote for the S8.
I have a Tdi A8 (albeit the 3.0 six) and would dearly dearly love an S8 but can't make it work on 500 miles a week.

Do it for those that cannot

Dilligaf10

2,431 posts

241 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
I have a 4.2TDi with a remap and it is such an immense car.

It has covered over 200,000 miles whilst in my care over the last 3 1/2 years and never missed a beat. The only problem I can recall is a DPF sensor needed replacement and a suspension sensor. It has close to 400bhp and I think around 800ft/lb of torque, (could be nm though). I still get a thrill driving it even though I usually drive a 3.0TDi version now.

Servicing costs at our local main dealer are good but they know that they get 6 to 8 services out of me every year across the two A8's I have.

Not so highly strung as the S8 but not so vocal either. Can still get around 30mpg even when pushing on really hard, mid to high 30's in normal,driving. The torque push of these cars is just so linear, keeps going until really, really stupid speeds.

Try one, even standard they are superb.

dvs_dave

9,040 posts

256 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Do you want the LWB version for the extra rear legroom? The SWB version doesn't have a lot more room in the back than an A6. If so that rules out the S8.
If you want LWB and the performance of the S8 then you'll need to go for the W12.

MrTickle

Original Poster:

1,825 posts

270 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Thanks guys,

I want a SWB model, I have been using an A7 TDI which is big enough and TBH sometimes a touch long in some parking spaces - so the idea of an LWB version day to day doesn't appeal. I am replacing both the A7 and a 911 with one car - hence the S8 was top of my list originally. I have owned an S6 and liked it - but always thought the S8 offered 'more' for relatively little difference in price (used). My worry with the 4.2TDI is that it wouldn't feel 'special' enough and the extra £150 per month in fuel might be worth it for the enjoyment of the S8.

MrTickle

Original Poster:

1,825 posts

270 months

Thursday 31st October 2013
quotequote all
Just another quick question....

Are ceramics a good thing or a liability on a 6 year, 60K miles car?